Información jurídica inteligente
 España | 900 649 672

La individualización judicial de las sanciones

Document Citas 1 Citado por Relacionados
Vincent
AutorPrudencio C. Moreno Trapiella
Páginas137-191
CAPÍTULO IV
LA INDIVIDUALIZACIÓN JUDICIAL
DE LAS SANCIONES
I. LA INDIVIDUALIZACIÓN JUDICIAL DE LAS PENAS
 /DDSDUHQWHFRQWUDGLFFLyQHQWUHODWD[DWLYLGDG
GHOD/H\SHQDO\HOQHFHVDULRPDUJHQDDWULEXLU
DOMXH]HQODLQGLYLGXDOL]DFLRQGHODSHQD
&RPR HVVDELGRKDVWDOD,OXVWUDFLyQHOiPELWR SHQDOHVWDEDPDUFDGR SRU
HODUELWULRMXGLFLDOGRQGHHOMXH]SRGtDVHxDODU SHQDV QR SUHGHWHUPLQDGDV SRU
ODOH\ \WUDWiQGRVH GHSHQDV LQGHWHUPLQDGDVFRQFUHWDUODV 5HDFFLRQDQGRFRQWUD
HOGHVPHGLGRDUELWULRMXGLFLDOGHO Ancien Régime ³ORVUHYROXFLRQDULRVVHQWtDQ
XQDSURIXQGDGHVFRQÀDQ]D IUHQWH DO DUELWULR GHO MXH] HQ OD ÀMDFLyQ GHODVSH-
QDV³ODÀORVRItDSHQDOOLEHUDOTXLVRDFDEDUFRQHODUELWULRHQQRPEUHGHOSULQ-
FLSLRGHOHJDOLGDG 1.
(OPRGHORSHQDOTXH VDOHGHOD,OXVWUDFLyQUHVXHOYHHOFRQÁLFWR HQWUHMXVWLFLD
PDWHULDO\VHJXULGDGMXUtGLFDDIDYRUGHHVWD~OWLPDWUDWDQGRGHFHUUDUDXOWUDQ]D
ODSXHUWDDODSRVLEOHLQWHUSUHWDFLyQMXGLFLDOGHODQRUPDSHQDO5HSUHVHQWDODDV-
SLUDFLyQPi[LPD GHOSRVLWLYLVPR OHJDOLVWDHO DVLJQDUD FDGDGHOLWR XQDSHQD DE-
VROXWDPHQWHSUHGHWHUPLQDGDQR VXVFHSWLEOH GH VHU PRGLÀFDGD SRUHOMX]JDGRU
/DOH\KDGHGHWHUPLQDUGHOPRGRPiVUtJLGRSRVLEOH \VLQFRQFHVLyQ GHQLQJ~Q
PDUJHQDODFRQFUHFLyQMXGLFLDOODSHQDH[DFWDDLPSRQHUSRUFDGDGHOLWR
7DOPRGHOR TXHWXYRXQD HQFDUQDFLyQ SRVLWLYD HQ HO&yGLJR3HQDO IUDQFpV
GHKXERGHDEDQGRQDUVH WUDVFRPSUREDU TXHHOOR LPSHGtDWHQHU HQFXHQWD
ODVSHFXOLDULGDGHV GHFDGD FDVRSRU ORTXH ÀQDOPHQWHVH YROYLyD DWULEXLUDORV
1 Vid. A. TORÍO LÓ PE Z ,©7LSLFLGDG 5HIHUHQFLDDORVWLSRV SHQDOHVDELHUWRVªHQ -JIMÉNE Z VIL L AR E JO
GLU9inculación del juez a la ley penal,&*3-&XDGHUQRV GH'HUHFKR -XGLFLDO;9,,  SS
\VV+DVWDOD,OXVWUDFLyQVHxDODNIE T OHUDWDQWRHOarbitrio TXH HOMXH]SRGtDVHxDODUSHQDVQRSUHGHWHUPL-
QDGDVSRUODOH\\DGHPiVGHVHxDODUSHQDVex novoLJXDOPHQWHHVWDEDIDFXOWDGRFXDQGRVHWUDWDEDGHSH-
QDVLQGHWHUPLQDGDVSDUDFRQFUHWDUODV HQGHÀQLWLYDTXH HOSULQFLSLRGH WLSLFLGDGGHODVSHQDV HUDGHVFR-
QRFLGRHQHO'HUHFKR SHQDOPHGLHYDO\HQ HO$QWLJXR5pJLPHQVid. A. NIE T OEl arbitrio judicial$ULHO
SS2 LJXDOPHQWHHQODFRQRFLGDH [SUHVLyQGHBEC C AR IA ©WDPSRFROD DXWRULGDGGHLQWHU-
SUHWDUODVOH\HVSHQDOHVSXHGHUHVLGLUHQORVMXHFHVFULPLQDOHVSRU ODPLVPDUD]yQTXHQRVRQOHJLVODGRUHV
>@1RKD\FRVDWDQ SHOLJURVDFRPRDTXHOD[LRPDFRP~QTXH SURSRQHSRUQHFHVDULRFRQVXOWDUHOHVStULWX
GHODOH\ªVid. C. BECC AR IA , De los delitos y las penasWUDGGH7RPiV\9DOLHQWH2UELVS
 PRUDENCIO C. MORENO TRAPIELLA
MXHFHVXQFLHUWRDUELWULR SDUD TXH GHWHUPLQDVHQ OD SHQDGHQWURGH XQRV OtPLWHV
Pi[LPR\PtQLPR.
/DH[SHULHQFLDGHPRVWUyTXH LJXDO GH SHUQLFLRVD UHVXOWD GHMDU DO H[FOXVLYR
DUELWULRGHOMXH]ODGHWHUPLQDFLyQGHODSHQDFRPRODVOODPDGDVSHQDVÀMDV+R\
VHVHxDODTXHKDEUi GHVHUODOH\ ODTXHÀMHHOPDUFRSXQLWLYRHVHOOHJLVODGRUHO
TXHKDGHGHWHUPLQDUODFODVHGHSHQD\HOquantumGHpVWDHVRVtQRGHXQDPD-
QHUDÀMD \ DEVROXWDPHQWHSUHGHWHUPLQDGD VLQR VHxDODQGRXQ Pi[LPR \XQPt-
QLPRHQWUHORVFXDOHVKDGHSRGHUPRYHUVHHOMXH]
(QQXHVWURVLVWHPDSXQLWLYRODQHFHVDULDFRUUHODFLyQHQWUHODIDOWD\ODVDQFLyQ
RODSURSRUFLRQDOLGDGGHODV SHQDVFDVL VLHPSUHVH KDUHOHJDGR HQIDYRU GHOSULQ-
FLSLRGHOHJDOLGDG\GHVHJXULGDGMXUtGLFD(OMXH]SHQDOGHEHDSOLFDUODOH\SHQDO
DXQTXHD VXMXLFLR HOKHFKRSXQLEOH QRIXHVH PHUHFHGRUGH OD SHQDR pVWDUHVXOWH
GHVSURSRUFLRQDGDFRQ HO JUDGR GH PDOLFLD \HOGDxR FDXVDGR SRU HO GHOLWR(dura
lex, sed lex) (QSULQFLSLR©ORVMXHFHVQRGHEHUtDQFRQVLGHUDUHQ VXVGHFLVLRQHVVL
HOUHVXOWDGRHVMXVWRHQUHODFLyQFRQHOFDVRFRQFUHWR\PiVHVSHFtÀFDPHQWHVLOD
SHQDHVRQRSURSRUFLRQDGDDOD´PDOLFLDµRDO GDxRFDXVDGR(OORHVWDQWRFRPR
GHFLUTXHODVSHQDVVHGHEHQDSOLFDUVLQFRQVLGHUDUODJUDYHGDGGHOGHOLWRFRQFUHWR
DOJRTXHFKRFDFRQODH[LJHQFLDGHMXVWLFLD\SURSRUFLRQDOLGDGGHODVSHQDVª.
+R\\D QDGLH REVHUYD FRQWUDGLFFLyQHQWUH HO SULQFLSLR GHOHJDOLGDG SHQDO \
GHVHJXULGDGMXUtGLFD\ODQHFHVDULDDGDSWDFLyQGHODSHQDDFDGDGHOLWR\DFDGD
GHOLQFXHQWHSDUWLFXODU(OSULQFLSLRGHOHJDOLGDGSHQDOH[LJHTXHFRUUHVSRQGDDOD
OH\ODGHWHUPLQDFLyQ GHOPDUFRSXQLWLYRFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDFDGDXQR GHORVGHOL-
WRVTXH WLSLÀFDDO PLVPRWLHPSRODSHQDSDUDTXHFXPSODORVÀQHVGHSUHYHQ-
FLyQHVSHFLDO\UHKDELOLWDWRULRVTXHODFDUDFWHUL]DQDUW&(KDGHDGDSWDUVH
DODVFLUFXQVWDQFLDVGH FDGDGHOLWR\GHFDGDGHOLQFXHQWHSDUWLFXODUORTXHODOH\
JHQHUDO\DEVWUDFWDQRSXHGHKDFHU
1RHV SRVLEOHFXPSOLU ODVH[LJHQFLDVGHULYDGDV GHOSULQFLSLR GHSURSRUFLR-
QDOLGDGVLQODLQGLYLGXDOL]DFLyQMXGLFLDOGHODVSHQDV/DLQGLYLGXDOL]DFLyQMXGL-
FLDOGHODSHQD FRQVLVWLUtDDVtHQOD DGDSWDFLyQSRUSDUWHGH ODDXWRULGDGMXGLFLDO
GHODSHQDSUHYLVWDOHJDOPHQWHDOFDVRFRQFUHWRHQDWHQFLyQDODHQWLGDGGHOKH-
FKR\VREUHWRGRFRQHOQXHYR&yGLJR DUWD OD SHUVRQDOLGDG\ FLUFXQV-
WDQFLDVGHOFXOSDEOH.
'HQWURGH HVRVPiUJHQHVVXSHULRUHLQIHULRUHQWUHXQ Pi[LPR\ XQPtQLPR
HQWUHORVTXH SXHGHPRYHUVH HOMXH]VXUJHGHQXHYR HOarbitrio judicial DUELWULR
TXHSHVHDORVGHQRGDGRVLQWHQWRVGH UHGXFFLyQQRKDSRGLGRVHUHUUDGLFDGRWR-
WDOPHQWH/RVMXHFHVHQPD\RURPHQRUPHGLGDVLHPSUHKDQWHQLGRTXHUHFXUULU
DODUELWULRSDUDUHVROYHUORVDVXQWRVHQORVTXHODOH\QROHVRIUHFtDXQDUHVSXHVWD
XQtYRFDSUHIDEULFDGD
/DGLVFUHFLRQDOLGDG HQ HOiPELWR SHQDODSDUHFHDFDXVD GHODLQFDSDFLGDG
TXHWLHQHHOOHJLVODGRU GHHVWDEOHFHUXQDWLSRORJtDH[DFWD\FRPSOHWDGHOGHVYD-
+LVWyULFDPHQWHVHKDQVXFHGLGRVLVWHPDVGHDEVROXWDSUHGHWHUPLQDFLyQOHJDOHVHOFDVRGHO&yGLJR
3HQDOIUDQFpVGH H[SRQHQWHGH ODLGHRORJtDUHYROXFLRQDULD\ GHOSDSHODVLJQDGR SRUDTXpOODD ODOH\
FRPRHQHOH[WUHPR RSXHVWRHO&yGLJR3HQDO LWDOLDQRGHTXH GDEDXQDSULRULGDGDEVROXWDD ODVH[L-
JHQFLDVGHODLQGLYLGXDOL]DFLyQMXGLFLDOORTXHGHMDEDXQ DPSOLRDUELWULRDOMXH]HQODGHWHUPLQDFLyQHLQGL-
YLGXDOL]DFLyQGHODSHQD(QWDOVHQWLGR5DÍ A Z RO C A , Derecho penal general0DGULG7HFQRVS
E. BACIG A LUPO©/D´ULJXURVDDSOLFDFLyQGHODOH\µVHJ~QHODUW GHO&yGLJR3HQDOªHQ-JIMÉ-
NE Z VIL L AREJOGLUVinculación del juez a la ley penal,&*3-&XDGHUQRVGH'HUH FKR-XGLFLDO;9,,
S
LA INDIVIDUALIZACIÓN JUDICIAL DE LAS SANCIONES 
ORUGHOKHFKRWHQLHQGRQHFHVDULDPHQWHODOH\TXHUHPLWLUVHDOFULWHULR GHODSOL-
FDGRU/DHVHQFLDGHOIHQyPHQRGLVFUHFLRQDOVHFRQFUHWDHQXQDLQFDSDFLGDGRQ-
WROyJLFD GH ODV OH\HV SDUD H[SUHVDU DOJXQRV GDWRV GH YDORU (O OHJLVODGRU QR
SXHGHFRQWHPSODU HQOD QRUPDDEVWUDFWDHO WRWDOGHVYDORU GHOKHFKRLOtFLWR GH-
MiQGRVHSDUDHOPRPHQWRGHODLQGLYLGXDOL]DFLyQODWRPDHQ FRQVLGHUDFLyQGH
GHWHUPLQDGRVHOHPHQWRVGHYDORU
(O&yGLJR3HQDOYLJHQWHGHWHUPLQDHOPDUFRSHQDODEVWUDFWRFRUUHVSRQGLHQWH
DFDGDÀJXUDGHOLFWLYDPDUFRSHQDOTXHSXHGHUHVXOWDUPRGLÀFDGRSRUODFRQFX-
UUHQFLDGHODVFLUFXQVWDQFLDVDWHQXDQWHV\DJUDYDQWHVOHJDOPHQWHSUHYLVWDV(ODU-
ELWULRMXGLFLDOVHPXHYHVRODPHQWHGHQWURGHORVOtPLWHVUHVLGXDOHVTXHODOH\ÀMD
XQDYH]HIHFWXDGDVODVGRVRSHUDFLRQHVDQWHULRUHVLas penas han de poder adap-
tarse a las circunstancias de cada delito y cada delincuente, es decir, han de po-
der ser individualizadas. (OPRGRHQTXHDSDUHFHQRUPDWLYDPHQWHHVWDEOHFLGDOD
HVFDODGHSHQDVODLQFOXVLyQRQRGHFLUFXQVWDQFLDVPRGLÀFDWLYDVGHODUHVSRQVD-
ELOLGDGLQFLGHLQGHIHFWLEOHPHQWHVREUHORVPiUJHQHVDWULEXLGRV DOyUJDQRHQFDU-
JDGRGHLPSRQHUHQODVDQFLyQ
 /DFLHQFLDSHQDO\HOFRQWUROGHODUELWULRMXGLFLDOHQODPHGLFLyQ
GHODSHQD/DLQGLYLGXDOLD]DFLyQMXGLFLDOGHODSHQD
(QOD DSOLFDFLyQGHOD SHQDFRQÁX\HQGRV SULQFLSLRVDSDUHQWHPHQWHFRQWUD-
SXHVWRV'HXQODGR HOSULQFLSLRGHOHJDOLGDGSHQDOTXHLPSOLFDTXHGHEHVHUOD
OH\ODTXHFRQFDUiFWHU SUHYLR\JHQHUDOGHWHUPLQHFRQFHUWH]DODFRQFUHWDSHQD
FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHDFDGDXQRGHORVGHOLWRVTXHWLSLÀFD\GHRWURODGRODHYLGHQWH
QHFHVLGDGGHTXHODSHQDVLVHGHVHDTXHpVWDFXPSODORVÀQHVGHSUHYHQFLyQHV-
SHFLDO \ UHKDELOLWDWRULRV TXH OD FDUDFWHUL]DQ VH DGDSWH D ODV FLUFXQVWDQFLDV GH
FDGDGHOLWR\GHFDGDGHOLQFXHQWHSDUWLFXODU.
'HEHQFRQMXJDUVHSRUWDQWRHOSULQFLSLRGHOHJDOLGDGTXHLPSRQHODH[LVWHQ-
FLDGH SHQDVFLHUWDV \GHWHUPLQDGDV \OD QHFHVLGDGGH DGDSWDUOD SHQDDOKHFKR
FRQFUHWR\DOGHOLQFXHQWHSDUWLFXODU.
/R FLHUWR HV TXH QR REVWDQWH VHU OD LQGLYLGXDOL]DFLyQ OHJDO OD GHFLVLYD HQ
QXHVWUR'HUHFKRHO&yGLJR3HQDOGHKDSRWHQFLDGRODLQGLYLGXDOL]DFLyQMX-
GLFLDOTXH FRQVLVWH HQ ODDGDSWDFLyQGH OD SHQD SRUSDUWH GH OD DXWRULGDGMXGL-
FLDODOFDVRFRQFUHWRHQDWHQFLyQDODHQWLGDGGHOKHFKR\DODSHUVRQDOLGDG\FLU-
FXQVWDQFLDVGHOFXOSDEOHGHFRQIRUPLGDGFRQODVUHJODVTXHODOH\PDUFDDOMXH]
(VWDRSHUDFLyQ GHFRQFUHFLyQ GHOD SHQDDEVWUDFWDHVWDEOHFLGDSRUODOH\DO
FDVRFRQFUHWRHVXQD RSHUDFLyQ DEVROXWDPHQWH QHFHVDULD SRUTXHODOH\SRUVX
J. L GO N ZÁ L E Z CU S S AC,©$UELWULRMXGLFLDO\DUWGHO &yGLJR3HQDOFRPHQWDULRGHOD 6HQWHQFLD
GHGHPDU]RGH5$ªPoder Judicial,Q~PS
R. DÍAZ ROC A, Derecho penal general, op. cit.,S
&RPRKDQ VHxDODGRCOBO y VIVESVHRSWD JHQHUDOPHQWH©SRUHOVLVWHPD GHÀMDFLyQOHJDO GHXQ
PDUFRSXQLWLYR(OOHJLVODGRU GHWHUPLQDODFODVHGHSHQD >@\HOquantumGHpVWDV SHURQRGHXQD PD-
QHUDÀMD\ DEVROXWDVLQR VHxDODQGRXQPi[LPR \XQ PtQLPR>@HQWUHORV TXHSXHGHPRY HUVHHOMXH]
HOLJLHQGRVHJ~QVX SUXGHQWHDUELWULRª (QHO&yGLJR 3HQDOYLJHQWH©OD ÀMDFLyQGH HVHPDUFROHJDO WLHQH
OXJDUD WUDYp VGH  GRV HWDSDVXQD SULP HUD HQ TXH VH GHWHUPLQD HO PDUFR SHQDO DEVWUDFWR FRUUHVSRQ-
GLHQWHDODÀJXUDGHGHOLWR\RWUD SRVWHULRUHQTXHHVHPDUFRSHQDOUHVXOWDPRGLÀFDGRSRUOD FRQFXUUHQ-
FLDGHODVFLUFXQVWDQFLDVDWHQXDQWHV\DJUDYDQWHVOHJDOPHQWHSUHYLVWDV(ODUELWULRMXGLFLDOVHPXHYHVROD-
PHQWHGHQWURGHORVOtPLWHVUHVLGXDOHVTXHODOH\ÀMDXQDYH] HIHFWXDGDVODVGRVRSHUDFLRQHVDQWHULRUHVª
Vid. M. COBO DEL ROSAL y T. S. VIVES ANTÓN ,'HUHFKR Penal. Parte general9DOHQFLD7LUDQWOR%ODQFK
SS

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba
Índice de navegación

Búsquedas relacionadas:

Otros documentos interesantes:

VLEX utiliza cookies de inicio de sesión para aportarte una mejor experiencia de navegación. Si haces click en 'Aceptar' o continúas navegando por esta web consideramos que aceptas nuestra política de cookies. ACEPTAR