La calificación de las rentas procedentes de transacciones digitales

AutorSoraya Rodríguez Losada
Páginas67-92
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP89
+;
Nc"ecnkhkecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu""
rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu
Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc
(#∋)∃∗∋#/+:∋3/&/0/+!∋%&∋#/+>3&∃#∀3/+0∃+!∃#∃%1∋+2∀3/3%∀∃#∋+4+,#∀5−&/#∀∋6+
73∀8∃#∗∀0/0∃+0∃+Β∀Χ∋
Hgejc"fg"tgegrek„p"24/2;/423;"
Hgejc"fg"cegrvcek„p"45/2;/423;
TGUWOGP
Gpvtg"nqu"fgpqokpcfqu"itcpfgu"tgvqu"fg"nc"hkuecnkfcf"fg"nc" geqpqoc"fkikvcn"gpwogtcfqu"
gp"nc" Ceek„p" 3" fgn"Rncp" DGRU" ug" gpewgpvtc"nc" ecnkhkecek„p" fg" ncu"tgpvcu" fgtkxcfcu" fg" nqu"
pwgxqu"oqfgnqu"fg" pgiqekq0"Gp" guvg"rwpvq."gn" vtcdclq"tgcnk¦cfq" rqt"gn"VCI"fg"nc" QEFG"
gp"gn" c‚q" 4223" ukiwg"ukgpfq" ¿vkn" c" nc"jqtc" fg" ecnkhkect" ncu" tgpvcu"qdvgpkfcu" gp" gn" octeq"
fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu0" Gp"gn" rtgugpvg"guvwfkq" ug"gpwogtctƒp" wpc"ugtkg" fg"eqpvtcvqu"
vrkequ" tgncekqpcfqu"eqp" vtcpuceekqpgu" fkikvcngu." tgeqpfwekgpfq"ncu"tgpvcu"qtkikpcfcu"c"
ncu"fkuvkpvcu"ecvgiqtcu"rqukdngu tq{cnvkgu"rqt"gn" wuq"fg"dkgpgu" rtqvgikfqu"rqt"Rtqrkgfcf"
Kpfwuvtkcn."Kpvgngevwcn"q"mpqy/jqy="rciqu"rqt"gn"cttgpfcokgpvq"fg"gurcekq"q"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"
wp"qtfgpcfqt."wp"ugtxkfqt"q"wp"gswkrq"ukoknct="rciqu"rqt"ugtxkekqu"rtguvcfqu"c"enkgpvgu="q"
dgpghkekqu"gortguctkcngu0"
Rcncdtc u"encxggeqpqoc" fkikvcn." dgpghkekqu" gortguctkcngu." tgicncu." ugtxkekqu"fg"
cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec0"
CDUVTCEV
Ejctcevgtk¦cvkqp" qh"kpeqog" fgtkxgf" htqo" pgy" dwukpguu" oqfgnu" ku" qpg" qh" vjg" uq/ecnngf"
dtqcfgt"vcz"ejcnngpigu" tckugf"d{" vjg"fkikvcn" geqpqo{"nkuvgf" qp"DGRU"Rtqlgev" Cevkqp"30" Cv"
vjku"rqkpv."vjg"yqtm"ecttkgf"qwv"d{"vjg"QGEF"VCI"kp"vjg"4223"Tgrqtv"ku"uvknn"tgngxcpv0"V{rkecn"
fkikvcn"vtcpucevkqpu"yknn" dg"nkuvgf" kp"vjku" rcrgt."cpf"vjg"rc{ogpvu" yknn"dg"ejctcevgtk¦gf" cu"
tq{cnvkg u"hqt"v jg"wug" qh"eqr{t kijv"qt "cp{"qv jgt"uko knct"kp vcpikdng"rtqrgt v{="tgpvcn"rc{ogpvu"
hqt"jktkpi" urceg"qt" hqt"vjg" wug"qh"c" eqorwvgt."c"ugtxgt" qt"c" ukoknct"fgxkeg=" rc{ogpvu"hqt"
ugtxkegu"rtqxkfgf"vq"enkgpvu="qt"dwukpguu"rtqhkvu0"
Mg{"yqtfufkikvcn"geqpqo{."dwukpguu"rtqhkvu."tq{cnvkgu."ugtxkegu"qh"c"vgejpkecn"pcvwtg0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
8:
UWOCTKQ>6+ >3∋0−%%∀Η36+ >>6+ Ο∋4/.&∀∃∗+ Ι∋#+ ∃.+ −∗∋+ 0∃+ 5∀∃3∃∗+ Ι#∋&∃Χ∀0∋∗+ Ι∋#+ (#∋Ι∀∃0/0+ >30−∗∀/.ϑ+
>3&∃.∃%&−/.+∋+ π3∋µ;1∋µ6+>>>6+ (/Χ∋∗+ Ι∋#+ ∃.+/##∃30/∆∀∃3&∋+ 0∃+ ∃∗Ι/%∀∋+ ∋+Ι∋#+∃.+ −∗∋+ 0∃+−3+
∋#0∃3/0∋#ϑ+−3+∗∃#8∀0∋#+ ∋+−3+∃Ρ−∀Ι∋+ ∗∀∆∀./#6+>Β6+(/Χ∋∗+Ι∋#+ ∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+Ι#∃∗&/0∋∗+/+ %.∀∃3&∃∗6+
Β6+ γ ∃ 3∃ )∀ % ∀∋ ∗+ ∃ ∆Ι # ∃∗ /# ∀/ . ∃∗ 6+ Β > 6+ : /& ∃Χ ∋ #Τ /∗ + 3∋ + ∀ 3% .− ∀ 0/ ∗+ ∃ 3+ ∃ . + >3 )∋ # ∆∃ + 0∃ .+ , 9Ξ + 0∃ + Ψ [[ Ζβ +
∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+0∃+%∋∆Ι−&/%∀Η3+∃3+./+3−5∃+4+Ι/Χ∋∗+Ι∋#+∀∆Ι#∃∗∀Η3+∃3+Ν!6+Β>>6+γ∀5.∀∋Χ#/)Τ/
K0" KPVTQFWEEKðP
Nc" vtcpuhqtocek„p" fkikvcn" jc" rgtokvkfq" swg" gortgucu" {" rtqhgukqpcngu" rwgfcp"
xgpfgt"rtqfwevqu"q"rtguvct"ugtxkekqu"fg"pwgxcu"ocpgtcu."fkhgtgpvgu"c"nqu"ogfkqu"
vtcfkekqpcngu0"Guvq"jc"xgpkfq"rncpvgcpfq"fwfcu"tgncekqpcfcu"eqp"nc"ecnkÞ ec ek„p"fg"
ncu"tgpvcu"qdvgpkfcu"{"eqp"nc"gzkuvgpekc"fg"wp"vtcvcokgpvq"Þuecn"fkhgtgpvg"tgurgevq"
fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"ukoknctgu0
Eqp"gn" rtqr„ukvq" fg" fgucttqnnct" vtcdclqu" tgncekqpcfqu" eqp"gn" vtcvcokgpvq" Þuecn"
fgn"eqogtekq"gngevt„pkeq"{"fct"tgurwguvc"c"cniwpc"fg"guvcu"ewguvkqpgu."gn"Eqokvf‌i"
fg" Cuwpvqu" Hkuecngu" fg" nc" QEFG" etg„" wpc" ugtkg" fg" „ticpqu" vf‌iepkequ" uwdukfkc/
tkqu"gp"gpgtq"fg"3;;;."swg"kpvgitcdcp"c"rgtuqpcn"fg"nc"Cfokpkuvtcek„p"fg"rcugu"
okgodtqu"{" pq"okgodtqu"{"fg"gortgucu."gzrgtvqu"gp" ncu" tgurgevkxcu"ƒtgcu"fg"
guvwfkq0"Gp"rctvkewnct."ug"etgctqp"ekpeq"itwrqu"vf‌iepkequ"cuguqtgu"≅&∃%13∀%/.+/08∀;
∗∋#4+Χ#∋−Ι∗ϑ+gp"cfgncpvg."VCIu+rctc"
cuguqtct"uqdtg"nc"crnkecek„p"rtƒevkec"fgn"rtkpekrkq"fg"Qvvcyc"tgncvkxq"cn"itcxcogp"
gp"gn" nwict" fg"eqpuwoq=" *4+" gn" VCI"vgepqn„ikeq." swg"cuguqtcdc" {"fcdc"crq{q"
vgepqn„ikeq"c"nqu"qvtqu"itwrqu"eqpuwnvkxqu"vf‌iepkequ="*5+"gn"VCI"fg"gxcnwcek„p"rtq/
hgukqpcn"fg"fcvqu."rctc"cuguqtct"uqdtg"nc"xkcdknkfcf"{"rtcevkecdknkfcf"fgn"fgucttqnnq"
fg"kphqtocek„p"kpvgtpcekqpcnogpvg"eqorcvkdng"{"nqu"tgswkukvqu"fg"eqpugtxcek„p"
fg"nqu" tgikuvtqu." cu"eqoq"fg"nqu"cewgtfqu"fg" tgecwfcek„p" fg"korwguvqu="*6+"gn"
VCI"uqdtg"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu."rctc"cuguqtct"uqdtg"e„oq"ug"crnkecp"ncu"pqt/
ocu"xkigpvgu"uqdtg"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"fg"nqu"eqpxgpkqu"rctc"gxkvct"nc"fqdng"
korqukek„p"gp" gn" eqpvgzvq" fgn"eqogtekq" gngevt„pkeq." cpcnk¦cpfq" rtqrwguvcu" fg"
tgincu"cnvgtpcvkxcu="{"*7+"gn"VCI"fg"ecnkÞecek„p."swg"vgpc"eqoq"qdlgvkxq"rtkpekrcn"
cuguqtct"uqdtg"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"xctkcu"encugu"fg"rciqu"fg"eqogtekq"gngevt„pkeq"{"
fgvgtokpct"uk"nc"tgpvc"ug"rgtekdc"rqt"wpc"xgpvc"q"eqpeguk„p"fg"rtqrkgfcf."rqt"nc"
rtguvcek„p"fg"wp"ugtxkekq"q"eqoq"wp"#∋4/.&4"q"tgicnc0
C"nqu"ghgevqu"fg"guvg"vtcdclq."pqu"egpvtctgoqu"gp"nqu"tguwnvcfqu"fgn"itwrq"eqpuwn/
vkxq"vf‌iepkeq"fg"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"vtcvcfqu."rncuocfqu"gp"gn"kphqtog"vkvwncfq",/Υ+∃/;
&4+%1/#/%&∃#∀∗/&∀∋3+ ∀∗∗−∃∗+/#∀∗∀3Χ+)#∋∆+ ∃;%∋∆∆∃#%∃ϑ+fg"42230"Rqtswg."c"rguct" fg"
swg"fgurwf‌iu"fg"guc"hgejc"jcp"crctgekfq"pwgxqu"oqfgnqu"fg"pgiqekq."gn"vtcdclq"
tgcnk¦cfq"rqt"gn"VCI"gp"gn"c‚q"4223"ukiwg"ukgpfq"¿vkn"c"nc"jqtc"fg"ecnkÞect"ncu"tgp/
vcu"qdvgpkfcu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu0"Cjqtc"dkgp."gp"nqu"¿nvkoqu"
c‚qu"jcp" uwtikfq" pwgxcu"rtgiwpvcu"tgncekqpcfcu"eqp" nc" ecnkÞecek„p" fg"cniwpcu"
vtcpuceekqpgu"{"rciqu"ghgevwcfqu"gp"eqpvgzvqu"fqof‌iuvkequ"g"kpvgtpcekqpcngu."swg"
fgdgp"ugt"tgurqpfkfcu0"Cu."gn"kphqtog"fg"4223"pq"qhtgeg"wpc"tgurwguvc"gzrtguc"
tgurgevq"c" nc" ecnkÞecek„p" fg"nqu"rciqu"ghgevwcfqu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"
tgncekqpcfcu"eqp"nc"kortguk„p"gp"5F"q"nqu"ugtxkekqu"gp"nc"pwdg"≅%.∋−0+%∋∆Ι−&∀3ΧΑ6+
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP8;
Ncu"fwfcu"tgncekqpcfcu"eqp"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"guvqu"rciqu"vcorqeq"jcp"ukfq"tg/
uwgnvcu"gp"gn"Kphqtog"Hkpcn"fg"nc"Ceek„p"3"fg"DGRU"fg"42370"["gu"swg."uk"dkgp"gp"gn"
kphqtog"ug"fkuewvkgtqp"cniwpcu"qrekqpgu"rctc"cdqtfct"nqu"rtqdngocu"tgncekqpcfqu"eqp"
gn"pgzq."nqu"fcvqu"q"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu."pq"ug"cnecp¦„"gn"eqpugpuq"pgeguctkq."rqt"
nq"swg"ug"qrv„"rqt"eqpvkpwct"vtcdclcpfq"gp"guvg"ƒodkvq0"Nc"tgurwguvc"c"guvcu"ewguvkqpgu"
vcorqeq"nngi„"eqp"nqu"vtcdclqu"rquvgtkqtgu"fg"nc"QEFG."gp"rctvkewnct."gn"Kphqtog",/Υ +:1 / ;
..∃3Χ∃∗+9#∀∗∀3Χ+)#∋∆+!∀Χ∀&/.∀∗/&∀∋3+κ+∀3&∃#∀∆+#∃Ι∋#&""423:."{c"swg"nqu"okgodtqu"fgn"Octeq"
Kpenwukxq"*>3%.−∗∀8∃+ 2#/∆∃µ∋#π+ Α"pq"nngictqp"c"wp"cewgtfq"tgurgevq"fg"ncu"eqpenwukqpgu"
swg"fgdcp"jcegt"r¿dnkecu"gp"tgncek„p"eqp"gn"korcevq"fg"nc"fkikvcnk¦cek„p"gp"nqu"oqfgnqu"
fg"pgiqekq" {"uw"tgngxcpekc"gp"nqu"korwguvqu" uqdtg"nc"tgpvc."eqortqogvkf‌ipfqug"c"eqp/
vkpwct"vtcdclcpfq"rctc" gpvtgict"wp"kphqtog"Þpcn" gp"4242" gp"gn" swg"ug"rtqrqtekqpg"wpc"
uqnwek„p"c"nctiq"rnc¦q"dcucfc"gp"gn"eqpugpuq0"Fg"guvc"ocpgtc."nqu"okgodtqu"fgn"Octeq"
Kpenwukxq"rwdnkectqp"gp"gpgtq"fg"423;"wpc"Ι∋.∀%4+3∋&∃"swg"eqpvgpc"rtqrwguvcu"eqpetgvcu "
citwrcfcu"gp"fqu"rknctgu"*Rknct"3/"Tgcukipcek„p"fg"dgpgÞekqu"{"tgxkuk„p"fg"ncu"tgincu"uqdtg"
gn"pgzq="{"Rknct"4/"wpc"rtqrwguvc"inqdcn"eqpvtc"nc"gtquk„p"fg"nc"dcug+0"Eqoq"rwgfg"crtg/
ekctug."nc"QEFG"jc"xgpkfq"ecodkcpfq"uw"jqlc"fg"twvc"gp"tgncek„p"eqp"nc"vtkdwvcek„p"fg"nc"
geqpqoc"fkikvcn"gp"ecfc"wpq"fg"uwu"vtcdclqu"fgufg"nc"rwdnkecek„p"fgn"Kphqtog"Hkpcn"fg"nc"
Ceek„p"3"fg"4237"{."cn"ogpqu"rqt"gn"oqogpvq."rctgeg"swg"pq"guvƒ"gpvtg"uwu"rtkqtkfcfgu"
cttqlct"nw¦"gp"gn"rtqdngoc"fg"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"tgpvcu"qtkikpcfcu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"vtcpuce/
ekqpgu"fkikvcngu0"Uk"dkgp"rqt"gn"oqogpvq"gn"vtcdclq"fg"nc"QEFG"gp"guvg"ƒodkvq"pq"jc"
Þpcnk¦cfq."cwpswg"guvcoqu"gp"fkurqukek„p"fg"crqtvct"wpc"ugtkg"fg"fktgevtkegu"swg"
hceknkvgp"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"fgtkxcfcu"fg"guvqu"eqpvtcvqu"cn"Þpcn"fg"guvg"
vtcdclq="nc"dcug"fg"nqu"vtcdclqu"fg"nc"QEFG."nc"Þuecnkfcf"kpvgtpcekqpcn"fgn"eqogt/
ekq"gngevt„pkeq"fgdgtc"guvct"kpurktcfc"rqt"gn"rtkpekrkq"fg"pgwvtcnkfcf."fg"oqfq"
swg"nc"ectic"fg"itcxcogp"c"nc"swg"ug"gpewgpvtcp"uqogvkfqu"nqu"eqpvtkdw{gpvgu"
swg"qrgtcp"gorngcpfq"ogfkqu"vtcfkekqpcngu"fgdg"ugt"gswkrctcdng"c"nc"ectic"fg"
itcxcogp"swg"uqrqtvcp"cswf‌innqu"swg"wvknk¦cp"ogfkqu"fkikvcngu0"Rqt"nq"vcpvq."ewcn/
swkgt"qrgtcek„p"swg"ug"tgcnkeg"gp"nc"Tgf"fgdgtƒ"igpgtct"gn"okuoq"vkrq"fg"tgpvc"
{." gp"eqpugewgpekc. "ugt" itcxcfc" eqoq" uk "nc"qrgtcek„p "ug"jwdkgug"tgcncfq" hwgtc"
fg"gnnc"30
Rwgu"dkgp." gn" kpetgogpvq" fg" qrgtcekqpgu" gp"gn" ogtecfq" gp" ncu" swg"ug" wvknk¦cp"
ogfkqu"fkikvcngu"jc"rtqxqecfq"wpc" ugtkg"fg"rtqdngocu"gp" gn" rncpq"Þuecn" {."gp"
rctvkewnct."gp"vqtpq"c"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"qdvgpkfcu"rqt"nc"tgcnk¦cek„p"fg"
vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu0"Gp"guvg" rwpvq."nc" QEFG"rtgekuc"swg"nq"hwpfcogpvcn" c"nc"
jqtc"fg"ecnkÞect"wpc"tgpvc"gu"fgvgtokpct"nc"ecwuc"gugpekcn"*gn"oqvkxq"q"Þpcnkfcf+"
rqt"nc"swg"ug"tgcnk¦cp"nqu"rciqu0"Cu."gn"vtcvcokgpvq"Þuecn"ugtƒ"fkuvkpvq"gp"hwpek„p"
fg"swg"pqu"gpeqpvtgoqu"cpvg"wpc"xgpvc"q"wpc"eguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"wp"dkgp."wpc"fku/
vkpek„p"swg"rwgfg"eqpukfgtctug"clgpc"c"ewcnswkgt"rtqdngoƒvkec"gp"wpc"ukvwcek„p"
vtkdwvctkc"kpvgtpc."rgtq"swg"rwgfg"gpvtc‚ct"fwfcu"gp"gn"ƒodkvq"fgn"eqogtekq"kp/
vgtpcekqpcn."gp"gn"swg"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"nc"qrgtcek„p"rqftƒ"ugt"fg"eqortcxgpvc"gp"
3" ECNXQ"X¡TIG¥."L0."ÑWpc"crtqzkocek„p"c"ncu"rtkpekrcngu"ewguvkqpgu"fgtkxcfcu"fg"nc"hkuecnkfcf"
fgn"eqogtekq"gngevt„pkeqÒ."!∋%−∆∃3&∋∗+;+>3∗&∀&−&∋+0∃+?∗&−0∀∋∗+2∀∗%/.∃∗ϑ+p¿o0"5."422;."r0"3:0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
92
wp"Guvcfq"q"eguk„p"fg"wuq"gp"gn"qvtq"40"Ncu"fkÞewnvcfgu"cwogpvcp"ewcpfq"gn"dkgp"q"
gn"ugtxkekq"rtguvcfq"uqp"fkikvcngu"{"gp"gnnqu"fguvcec"wp"gngogpvq"kpvgngevwcn."eqoq"
uwgng"uwegfgt"gp"gn"ecuq"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"fg"rtqitcocu"kphqtoƒvkequ0"
Gp"gn"kphqtog"fg"4223."nc"QEFG"kpenw{g"4:"ecvgiqtcu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"vrkecu"fg"
eqogtekq"gngevt„pkeq."swg"rwgfgp"citwrctug"fg"nc"ukiwkgpvg"ocpgtc
*3+" "#∋4/.&∀∃∗"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"fgtgejqu"rtqvgikfqu"rqt"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpvgngevwcn."Kpfwu/
vtkcn"q"π3∋µ;1∋µ="
*4+" "rciqu" rqt" gn"cttgpfcokgpvq"fg"gurcekq"q" rqt" gn" wuq" fg"wp"qtfgpcfqt."wp"
ugtxkfqt"q"wp"gswkrq"ukoknct="
*5+" "rciqu"rqt"ugtxkekqu"rtguvcfqu"c"enkgpvgu="
*6+" "tgpfkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu0"
Cu." nq" rtkogtq" swg" jc" fg" jcegtug" rctc" ecnkÞect" nqu" rciqu" fgtkxcfqu"fg" guvcu"
vtcpuceekqpgu"ugtƒ" kfgpvkÞect"nc"eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"qdvgpkfc0"Guvq"kornkec" swg"ncu"
rqukdngu"ecnkÞecekqpgu" lwtfkeq/vtkdwvctkcu" fg"nqu" rciqu" qdvgpkfqu" ugtcp"eqoq"
#∋4/.&∀∃∗."dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"q"icpcpekcu"fg"ecrkvcn0"[."wpc"xg¦"guvf‌i"enctc"nc"
ecnkÞecek„p"fg"nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc."nc"tgeqpfweek„p" c"wpc"w" qvtc"ecvgiqtc"vgpftƒ"
kornkecekqpgu"gp"nq"swg"tgurgevc"c"nc"fkuvtkdwek„p"fgn"rqfgt"vtkdwvctkq"gpvtg"gn"
Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"{"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc0"Fg"guvg"oqfq."gp"xktvwf"fgn"ctv0"9"
fgn"OE"QEFG."nqu"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"vtkdwvcp"gzenwukxcogpvg"gp"gn"Guvcfq"
fg" tgukfgpekc." ucnxq" swg" nc" gpvkfcf" fgucttqnng" cevkxkfcfgu" geqp„okecu" gp" qvtq"
Guvcfq"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"wp"guvcdngekokgpvq"rgtocpgpvg"*GR+0"Gp"guvg"¿nvkoq"ecuq."nqu"
dgpgÞekqu"swg"ugcp"cvtkdwkdngu"c"gug"GR"ugtƒp"itcxcfqu"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg0"
Rqt"qvtq"ncfq."gn"ctv0"34"fgn"OE"QEFG"rtgekuc"swg"nqu"tq{cnvkgu"vtkdwvctƒp"gzenw/
ukxcogpvg"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc"fg"uw"dgpgÞekctkq"ghgevkxq0"Ukp"godctiq."gn"
ctv0"34"fg"nqu"eqpxgpkqu"rctc"gxkvct"nc"fqdng"korqukek„p"*EFKu+"uwgng"fguxkctug"fg"
guvc"tginc."qrvcpfq"rqt"wpc"vtkdwvcek„p"eqorctvkfc"gpvtg"gn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"
{"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc0"Hkpcnogpvg."gp"xktvwf"fgn"ctv0"35"fgn"OE"QEFG."ncu"ic/
pcpekcu"fg"ecrkvcn"qdvgpkfcu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"guvcu"vtcpuceekqpgu"ug"uqogvgtƒp"c"
korqukek„p"u„nq"gp"gn"Guvcfq"eqpvtcvcpvg"gp"swg"tgukfc"swkgp"gpclgpc0
Rqt"glgornq."uk"pqu"gpeqpvtcoqu"cpvg"rciqu"rqt"nc"eqpeguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"fgtgejqu"
fg"cwvqt"fg"wp"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn" swg" ug"fguectic"gngevt„pkecogpvg." nc" tgpvc" ug"
gpoctec"gp"gn"ctv0"34"fgn"OE"QFG"*tgicncu+0"Rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."uk"gn"rciq"ug"tgcnk¦c"
rctc"cfswktkt"fcvqu"vtcpuokvkfqu"gp"hqtoc"fg"wpc"ug‚cn"fkikvcn"rctc"wuq"q"fkuhtwvg"
rqt"rctvg"fgn"cfswktgpvg."gn"rciq"ug"tgeqpfwektc"cn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG"*dgpgÞ/
ekqu"gortguctkcngu+"q"cn"ctv0"35"fgn"OE"QG"*icpcpekcu"fg"ecrkvcn+0
Ecdg"rtgekuct"swg"gp"gn"c‚q"4225"ug"rtqfwlq"wpc"cevwcnk¦cek„p"fgn"OE"QEFG."gp"
nc"swg"ug" kpeqtrqtctqp" pwgxcu" fktgevtkegu"gp"vqtpq"c"nc"Þuecnkfcf"fgn"eqogtekq"
gngevt„pkeq"q"nqu"rtqfwevqu"fkikvcngu0" Cvgpfkgpfq" cn" eqpvtcvq." uk" nc" ecwuc"fg"nc"
rtguvcek„p"ug" kfgpvkÞec" eqp"nc"fguectic"gngevt„pkec" fg" rtqfwevqu"fkikvcngu"*∗∋);
&µ/#∃ϑ+koƒigpgu."uqpkfqu"q"vgzvq+"rctc"wuq"{"fkuhtwvg"rgtuqpcn."ncu"tgvtkdwekqpgu"
4" UKPINGVQP."R0."ÑPqp/tgukfgpv"gngevtqpke"eqoogteg"vczcvkqppvgtpcvkqpcn"eqorctkuqpÒ."
9∗∀/;(/%∀)∀%+,/Υ+γ−..∃&∀3ϑ+Xqn0 "3 2. "Pq 0"5."Oc te j0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP93
pq"fctƒp"nwict"c"rciqu"ecnkÞecdngu"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0"Nc"eqpenwuk„p"fg"nc"QEFG"ug"
hwpfcogpvc"gp"gn"jgejq"fg"swg"gn"rciq"Μ∗∃+#∃/.∀Σ/+∗∀%/∆∃3&∃+/+%/∆5∀∋+0∃+/0;
Ρ−∀#∀#+0/&∋∗+/3∗∆∀&∀0∋∗+∃3+)∋#∆/+0∃+∗∃φ/.+0∀Χ∀&/.ϑ+4+Ι∋#+.∋+&/3&∋ϑ+3∋+%∋##∃∗Ι∋30∃+/+
#∃Χ/.Τ/∗Ωϑ"tkikf‌ipfqug"rqt"gn"ctv0"9"*dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu+"q"gn"ctv0"35"*icpcpekcu"
fg"ecrkvcn+."ugi¿p"gn"ecuq"50"Rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."ewcpfq"gn"rciq"ug"tgcnk¦c"rqt"nc"eguk„p"
fgn"fgtgejq" c" wuct" wp" fgtgejq"fg"tgrtqfweek„p"fg" wp" rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"swg"ug"
fguectic"rtgekucogpvg"eqp"guc"Þpcnkfcf."nc"vtcpuceek„p"igpgtctƒ"gn"rciq"fg"wpc"
tgicnc0"Cn"tgurgevq."nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"OE"QEFG"crqtvcp"gn"glgornq"fg"wp"gfkvqt"
swg"rcic"rqt"cfswktkt" gn"fgtgejq"c"tgrtqfwekt"wpc"kocigp"uwlgvc"c"fgtgejq"fg"
cwvqt."swg"fguectic"gngevt„pkecogpvg"rctc"swg"fgurwf‌iu"crctg¦ec"gp"nc"rqtvcfc"
fg"wp"nkdtq"swg"guvƒ"rtqfwekgpfq0"Nc" fkhgtgpekc" eqp" gn" uwrwguvq"cpvgtkqt"gu"nc"
ukiwkgpvggfkvqt"rqt"wuct"gn"fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt"kpjgtgpvg"
cn"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"*fgtgejq"c"tgrtqfwekt"{"fkuvtkdwkt"nc"kocigp+."{"pq"¿pkecogpvg"
rqt"nc"cfswkukek„p"fgn" eqpvgpkfq" fkikvcn"6 0" Cu." cvgpkf‌ipfqpqu" c" nc" fqevtkpc" fg" nc"
QEFG."gp"nc"ogfkfc"gp"swg"nqu"rciqu"fgtkxcfqu"fg"nc"vtcpuokuk„p"fg"rtqfwevqu"
fkikvcngu"kpeqtrqtgp" nc"eguk„p"fg" wuq" fg"wp"fgtgejq" fg"tgrtqfweek„p"q" kpenwuq"
wpc"eguk„p" fg" wuq" fg"π3∋µ;1∋µϑ+f‌iuvqu"rqftƒp" ecnkÞectug" eqoq" #∋4/.&∀∃∗"{."gp"
eqpugewgpekc."ugiwktƒp"ncu"tgincu"fg"vtkdwvcek„p"crnkecdngu"c"nqu"okuoqu0
Fg"oqfq"rctcngnq."gp"gn"ecuq" fg"swg"pqu"gpeqpvtgoqu"cpvg"wp"eqpvtcvq"okzvq."
eqttgurqpfg"cpcnk¦ct"gn"eqpvtcvq" {" fgueqorqpgt" nc" tgowpgtcek„p" vqvcn" guvkrw/
ncfc"gp"hwpek„p"fg"ncu"fkuvkpvcu"rtguvcekqpgu"tgekdkfcu."uqogvkgpfq"ecfc"wpc"fg"
ncu"rctvgu" fg"nc"tgowpgtcek„p"cn" tf‌iikogp"Þuecn"qrqtvwpq0"Pq" qduvcpvg."ewcpfq"
ugc"korqukdng" nc" fgucitgicek„p" {" wpc" fg"ncu" rtguvcekqpgu" eqpuvkvw{c" gn" qdlgvq"
rtkpekrcn"fgn"eqpvtcvq."rtgugpvcpfq"ncu"qvtcu"rtguvcekqpgu"wp"ectƒevgt"ceeguqtkq"
{"oƒu" dkgp"fgufg‚cdng."gn"vtcvcokgpvq" crnkecdng"c"nc"rtguvcek„p"rtkpekrcn"rqftƒ"
gzvgpfgtug"c"nc"tgowpgtcek„p"vqvcn0
KK0" TQ[CNVKGU"RQT"GN"WUQ"FG"DKGPGU"RTQVGIKFQU"RQT"
RTQRKGFCF"KPFWUVTKCN."KPVGNGEVWCN"Q"MPQY/JQY
Ukgortg"{"ewcpfq"ug"eworncp"fgvgtokpcfcu"rtgokucu."nqu"rciqu"fgtkxcfqu"fg"
vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu" rwgfgp" ecgt"gp"nc"„tdkvc"fgn" ctv0" 34" fgn"OE"QEFG0"Rctc"
swg"guvq"ugc"rqukdng."gn"rciq"fgdg"ghgevwctug"eqoq"eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"rqt"gn"wuq"
q"eqpeguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"fgtgejqu"rtqvgikfqu"rqt"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpfwuvtkcn."Kpvgngevwcn"
q"π3∋µ;1∋µ6
Gp"nqu"¿nvkoqu"c‚qu."nc"QEFG"jc"kfq"tgcnk¦cpfq"wpc"ugtkg"fg"oqfkÞecekqpgu"gp"gn"
OE"QEFG"eqp"gn"qdlgvq"fg"cenctct"nc"fgnkokvcek„p"gpvtg"nc"crnkecek„p"fg"nqu"ctvu0"9"
{"34"fgn"OE"QEFG0"Eqpetgvcogpvg."ug"jcp"tgcnk¦cfq"rwpvwcnk¦cekqpgu"gp"tgncek„p"
eqp"nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpvgngevwcn."tgpvcu"qdvgpkfcu"rqt"
eguk„p"fg"mpqy/jqy"{"eqp"gn"vtcvcokgpvq"Þuecn"crnkecdng"c"nqu"eqpvtcvqu"okzvqu0
5" Eht0"Rƒttchq"3905"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QEFG0
6" Eht0"Rƒttchq"3906"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QEFG0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
94
Jc{"swg" vgpgt" rtgugpvg" swg" nqu" rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"gp" gn" octeq" fg" qrgtcekqpgu"
fg"xgpvc"fg"dkgpgu"swg"guvƒp" rtqvgikfqu"rqt" Rtqrkgfcf"Kpvgngevwcn"pq"qtkikpcp"
gn"rciq" fg"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0"Gp" guvqu"ecuqu."nc"tgpvc" qdvgpkfc"ugtƒ"ecnkÞecfc"eqoq" dg/
pgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"q" icpcpekcu"fg"ecrkvcn0"Gp"gn"ƒodkvq"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"
fkikvcngu."pqu"gpeqpvtctcoqu"cpvg" qrgtcekqpgu"gp"ncu"swg"gn" enkgpvg"tgcnk¦c"wpc"
fguectic"fg"wp"rtqitcoc"kphqtoƒvkeq"w" qvtq"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"*∗∋)&µ/#."koƒig/
pgu."uqpkfqu"q"vgzvq+"gp"uw"qtfgpcfqt"rctc"wuq"{"fkuhtwvg"rgtuqpcn0"Nqu"fgtgejqu"
swg"cfswkgtg"gp"tgncek„p"eqp"nqu"fgtgejqu"fg"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpfwuvtkcn"swg"rtqvgigp"
gn"∗∋)&µ/#∃"ug"nkokvcp"c"cswf‌innqu"pgeguctkqu"rctc"rgtokvkt"swg"gn"wuwctkq"qrgtg"gn"
rtqitcoc."kpenw{gpfq" nc" fguectic."gn"cnocegpcokgpvq" {" wuq"fgn"∗∋)&µ/#∃"gp"uw"
rtqrkq"qtfgpcfqt."wpc"tgf"q"gp"ewcnswkgt"qvtq"crctcvq"fg"cnocegpcokgpvq"q"fku/
rqukvkxq"fg"xkuwcnk¦cek„p0" Gp"guvg" uwrwguvq"gpeclctcp"nqu"rciqu"rqt"nc"fguectic"
fg"wp"rtqitcoc"kphqtoƒvkeq"fgufg"wpc"rƒikpc"µ∃5."fqpfg"ug"igpgtc"wpc"eqrkc"
fgn"ctejkxq"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃"{"ug"vtcpuokvg"gngevt„pkecogpvg"cn"eqpuwokfqt"rctc"uw"wvk/
nk¦cek„p0"Rwgu"dkgp."gn"jgejq"fg"eqrkct"gn"∗∋)&µ/#∃"gpvtc‚ctc."hqtocnogpvg."gn"wuq"
fg"%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&+q"fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt."rgtq"nc"uwuvcpekc"fg"nc"vtcpuceek„p"gu"nc"eqortc"
fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃0"Nc"eqpenwuk„p"fg"nc"QEFG"ug"hwpfcogpvc"gp"gn"jgejq"fg"swg"gn"rciq"
ug"tgcnk¦c"rctc"cfswktkt"fcvqu"swg"ug"vtcpuokvgp"dclq"nc"hqtoc"fg"wpc"ug‚cn"fkikvcn"
rctc"gn"wuq"{"fkuhtwvg"fgn"cfswktgpvg0"[."cwpswg"nc"eqrkc"fg"wpc"ug‚cn"fkikvcn"gp"gn"
fkueq"fwtq"eqpuvkvw{g"gn"wuq"fg"wp"fgtgejq"rtqvgikfq"rqt"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpvgngevwcn"
rqt"rctvg"fgn"enkgpvg."ug"vtcvc"fg"wpc"rctvg"kpekfgpvcn"fgn"rtqeguq"fg"ecrvcek„p"{"
cnocegpclg"fg"nc"ug‚cn"fkikvcn."swg"gu"cduqnwvcogpvg"kttgngxcpvg"c"ghgevqu"fg"ecnk/
Þecek„p"fg"nc"tgpvc"g"korkfg"uw"ecnkÞecek„p"eqoq"tgicncu."tgfktkikgpfq"gn"rciq"c"
nc"guhgtc"fg"nqu"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"q"ncu"icpcpekcu"fg"ecrkvcn0
Vqocpfq"eqoq"tghgtgpekc"ncu"fktgevtkegu"kpenwkfcu"gp"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn" ctv0" 34"
fgn" OE" QEFG." rctc" eqpenwkt" uk" nqu" rciqu" fgtkxcfqu" fg" vtcpuceekqpgu" fkikvcngu"
eqpuvkvw{gp"tgicncu."nc"ewguvk„p"gugpekcn"swg"jc"fg"cdqtfctug"gu"gn"oqvkxq"gugp/
ekcn"rqt"gn"swg" ug"rcic."guvq"gu."jcdtƒ" swg"kfgpvkÞect"swf‌i"fgtgejqu"cfswkgtg"nc"
rgtuqpc"swg"tgcnk¦c"gn"rciq"70"Uk"nq"swg"cfswkgtg"gu"gn"wuq"q"nc"eqpeguk„p"fgn"fg/
tgejq"fg"wuq"fg"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt"uqdtg"wp"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"swg"ug"fguectic"
gngevt„pkecogpvg"eqp"gug"rtqr„ukvq."fg"ocpgtc"swg."gp"cwugpekc"fg"guc"nkegpekc."
vgpftc"nwict" wpc" xkqncek„p"fg"nc"ngikuncek„p"tgncvkxc"c" nqu"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt."gn"
rciq"jcdtƒ"fg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0"Glgornq"fg"gnnq"ugtcp"ncu"nkegpekcu"rctc"
tgrtqfwekt"{"fkuvtkdwkt"cn"r¿dnkeq"gn"∗∋)&µ/#"kpeqtrqtcfq"gp"wp"rtqitcoc"rtqvg/
ikfq"rqt"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt."q"nkegpekcu"rctc"oqfkÞect"{"gzjkdkt"r¿dnkecogpvg"gn"
rtqitcoc"kphqtoƒvkeq0
Fg"ocpgtc" rctcngnc."ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu"swg" tguwnvgp"gp"gn"rciq" fg" wpc"
ecpvkfcf"eqoq"eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"rqt"nc"rtqxkuk„p"fg"()∗+,−∗+"xkpewncfq"c"wp"
rtqitcoc" kphqtoƒvkeq" *kphqtocek„p" tgncvkxc" c" gzrgtkgpekcu" kpfwuvtkcngu." eqogt/
ekcngu"q" ekgpvÞecu." cu"eqoq"π3∋µ;1∋µ"tgncvkxq" c" ncu"vf‌iepkecu"fg"rtqitcocek„p"
Ïkfgcu"{"rtkpekrkqu"kornekvqu"gp"gn"e„fkiq"hwgpvgÏ+"gpvtcp"fgpvtq"fgn"ƒodkvq"fg"
crnkecek„p"fg"ctvewnq"swg"tgiwnc"nqu"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0"
7" Eht0"Rƒttchq"3903"fg"nqu"eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QFG0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP95
Fkuvkpvqu"uqp" nqu" ecuqu" gp"nqu" swg" vkgpg" nwict" wpc" rtguvcek„p" fg" ugtxkekqu" fg"
cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec0"Ukiwkgpfq"ncu"fktgevtkegu"xgtvkfcu"rqt"nc"QEFG"gp"uw"OE."nqu"
rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu" gp" eqpvtcvqu"fg"guvg"vkrq" igpgtcnogpvg" uqp" ecnkÞecfqu" eqoq"
dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9+0"Glgornq"fg"gnnq"ugtcp"nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"rqt"
cuguqtcokgpvq"rtguvcfq"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg" ogfkqu" fkikvcngu." rqt" eqowpkecekqpgu" eqp"
rgtuqpcn"vf‌iepkeq."q"rqt"ceegfgt."c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"tgfgu"fkikvcngu."c"dcugu"fg"fcvqu"fg"
d¿uswgfc"{"tguqnwek„p"fg" gttqtgu"≅∋−5.∃;∗1∋∋&∀3Χ+0/&/5/∗∃∗Α6"Rgtq."gp"qecukq/
pgu."fkuvkpiwkt"gpvtg"rciqu"rqt"rtqxkuk„p"0∃+π3∋µ;1∋µ"fg"nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"c"
ecodkq"fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p" fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepkec"gu" wpc"vctgc"eqo/
rnkecfc0" Ukp" rgtlwkekq" fgn" cpƒnkuku" ukpiwnctk¦cfq" swg" tgcnk¦ctgoqu"oƒu"cfgncpvg"
tgurgevq"fg"nqu"eqpvtcvqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec."rqfgoqu"cxcp¦ct"gp"guvg"rwpvq"
swg"nqu" Eqogpvctkqu" cn" ctv0" 34"fgn"OE"QEFG"hceknkvcp" wpc" ugtkg" fg"rcwvcu"rctc"
fkhgtgpekct"codqu"eqpvtcvqu
ΖΑ+ +Μ∋3∋%∀∆∀∃3&∋∗+Ι#Γ%&∀%∋∗+κπ3∋µ;1∋µκ+∗∃+#∃Þ∃#∃3+
/.+&∀Ι∋+0∃+∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+0∃∗%#∀&/+∃3+∃.+ΙΓ##/)∋+ΖΖ+Ρ−∃+4/+∃Υ∀∗&∃+∋+/.+∗−∆∀3∀∗&#∋+
0∃+∃∗&∃+ &∀Ι∋+ 0∃+ ∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+ 0∃∗Ι−Φ∗+ 0∃+ 0∃∗/##∋../#./+ ∋+ 0∃+ %#∃/#./+∃+∀3%.−4∃3+
0∀∗Ι∋∗∀%∀∋3∃∗+#∃./&∀8/∗+/+./+%∋3Þ0∃3%∀/.∀0/0+0∃+∃∗&/∗+∀3)∋#∆/%∀∋3∃∗Ωδ"
ΨΑ+ +Μ∃ 3+ .∋ ∗+ %/ ∗∋∗+ 0∃ + %∋3 /&∋ ∗+ 0∃ + Ι#∋ 8∀∗∀Η 3+ 0∃ + ∗∃# 8∀% ∀∋∗ ϑ+ ∃. + Ι#∋8∃ ∃0∋ #+ Ι# ∃∗&/+ . ∋∗+
∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+ Ρ−∃+ Ι−∃0∃3+ #∃Ρ−∃#∀#+ Ρ−∃+ ∃.+ Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#+ 1/Χ/+ −∗∋+ 0∃+ %∋3∋%∀∆∀∃3&∋∗+
∃ΥΙ∃#&∋∗ϑ+1/5∀.∀0/0∃∗+4+%∋3∋%∀∆∀∃3&∋∗+∃∗Ι∃%∀/.∃∗ϑ+Ι∃#∋+Ρ−∃+3∋+.∋∗+ /3∗Þ∃#/+/+
./+∋/+Ι/#&∃Ωδ+
ΝΑ+ +Μ∃ 3+. /+∆ /4∋ #Τ/+0∃+.∋∗ +%/ ∗∋ +∀Ι. Ρ− 3+ ./+ Ι#∋ 8∀∗ Η3 +0∃ +%∋ 3∋% ∆∀ 3& ∗+ Ι %;
&∀%∋∗+κπ3∋µ;1∋µκϑ+ Χ∃3∃#/.∆∃3&∃+ ∃.+ Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#+ 1/5#Γ+ 0∃+ 1/%∃#+ ∆−4+ Ι∋%∋ϑ+ 0∃+
/%−∃#0∋+%∋3+∃.+%∋3/&∋ϑ+/0∃∆Γ∗+0∃+/Ι∋#&/#+./+∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+0∀∗Ι∋3∀5.∃+∋+#∃Ι#∋;
0−%∀#+∃.+∆/&∃#∀/.+∃Υ∀∗&∃3&∃6+(∋#+∋/+Ι/#&∃ϑ+−3+%∋3/&∋+0∃+Ι#∃∗&/%∀Η3+0∃+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+
∗−Ι∋30#Γϑ+∃3+./+∆/4∋#Τ/+0∃+.∋∗+ %/∗∋∗ϑ+Ρ−∃+ ∃.+Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#+&∀∃3∃+−3+ 3∀8∃.+∆−%1∋+
∆Γ∗+∃.∃8/0∋+0∃+Χ/∗&∋+Ι/#/+Ι∋0∃#+%−∆Ι.∀#+%∋3+∗−∗+∋5.∀Χ/%∀∋3∃∗+%∋3/%&−/.∃∗6+
:∋∆∋+∃Π∃∆Ι.∋ϑ+/&∃30∀∃30∋+/+./+3/&−#/.∃Σ/+0∃+.∋∗+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+Ρ−∃+∗∃+1/+0∃+Ι#∃∗&/#ϑ+
∃.+Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#+Ι−∃0∃+∀3%−##∀#+∃3+Χ/∗&∋∗+0∃+∗/./#∀∋∗+0∃+∃∆Ι.∃/0∋∗+/∗∀Χ3/0∋∗+/+./+
∀38∃∗&∀Χ/%∀Η3ϑ+0∀∗∃φ∋ϑ+Ι#−∃5/∗ϑ+0∃.∀3∃/%∀Η3+4+/+∋/∗+/%&∀8∀0/0∃∗+%∋3∃Υ/∗+∋+Ι/#/+
#∃∆−3∃#/#+.∋∗+∗−5%∋3/&∀∗&/∗+∃3%/#Χ/0∋∗+0∃+Χ/#/3&∀Σ/#+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+∗∀∆∀./#∃∗Ω+6"
[."c" eqpvkpwcek„p." ug" gpwogtc" wpc" nkuvc" fg" glgornqu" swg" fguetkdg" rciqu" swg"
fgdgp"ugt" ecnkÞecfqu" eqoq" tgpvcu" fgtkxcfcu"fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"
cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec":0"Gp"rctvkewnct."ogpekqpc"ncu"tgowpgtcekqpgu"qdvgpkfcu"rqt"nqu"
ugtxkekqu"rquvxgpvc="tgowpgtcekqpgu"fg"nqu"ugtxkekqu"rtguvcfqu"rqt"wp"xgpfgfqt"
gp"gn"octeq"fg"nc"ictcpvc"fgdkfc"cn"eqortcfqt="tgowpgtcekqpgu"fg"nc"cukuvgpekc"
vf‌iepkec"gp" ugpvkfq"guvtkevq="tgowpgtcekqpgu" rqt"nkuvcfqu"fg"enkgpvgu" rqvgpekcngu"
8" Gn"Rƒttchq"3303"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QEFG"kpfkec"swg."gp"gn"eqpvtcvq "fg"
mpqy/jqy."Ñwpc"fg"ncu"rctvgu"ug"qdnkic"c"eqowpkect"c"nc"qvtc"rctvg"fg"uwu"eqpqekokgpvqu"{"gzrgtkgp/
ekcu"gurgekcnk¦cfqu."pq"tgxgncfqu"cn"r¿dnkeq."fg"ocpgtc"swg"rwgfc"wvknk¦ctnqu"rqt"uw"ewgpvc0"Ug"cfokvg"
swg"nc"rctvg" egfgpvg"pq"vkgpg"swg"kpvgt xgpkt"gp"gn" wuq"swg" nc"rctvg"egukqpctkc"jcic"fg" ncu"h„towncu"
egfkfcu"{"pq"ictcpvk¦c"gn"tguwnvcfqÒ0
9" Eht0"Rƒttchq"3305"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QFG0
:" Eht0"Rƒttchq"3306"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QEFG0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
96
ewcpfq"guqu"nkuvcfqu"ug"eqphgeekqpcp"gurgeÞecogpvg"rctc"gn"rcicfqt"eqp"kphqt/
ocek„p"fg"ectƒevgt"r¿dnkeq="tgowpgtcekqpgu"rqt"nqu"fkevƒogpgu"gokvkfqu"rqt"wp"
kpigpkgtq."wp"cdqicfq"q"wp" gzrgtvq" eqpvcdng="{"tgowpgtcekqpgu"fg"nc"cuguqtc"
rtguvcfc"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec."rqt"ncu"eqowpkecekqpgu"gngevt„pkecu"eqp"vf‌iepkequ"q"
rqt"gn" ceeguq."xc"tgfgu"kphqtoƒvkecu." c"wpc"dcug"fg" fcvqu"rctc"uqnwekqpct"rtq/
dngocu"≅∋−5.∃;∗1∋∋&∀3ΧΑ"eqoq"rwgfg"ugt"wpc"dcug"fg"fcvqu"swg"rtqrqtekqpc"
kphqtocek„p"pq"eqpÞfgpekcn."gp"tgurwguvc"c"rtgiwpvcu"htgewgpvgu"q"c"rtqdngocu"
eqowpgu"swg"ug"rncpvgcp"c"ogpwfq"c"nqu"wuwctkqu"fg"crnkecekqpgu"kphqtoƒvkecu"
≅∗∋)&µ/#∃Α+]0"Hkpcnogpvg."ug"rwpvwcnk¦c"swg"Ñ∃3+∃.+%/∗∋+∃∗Ι∃%ΤÞ%∋+0∃+−3+%∋3/&∋+Ρ−∃+
∗−Ι∋3∃+./+Ι#∋8∀∗∀Η3ϑ+Ι∋#+Ι/#&∃+0∃.+Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#ϑ+0∃+∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+#∃./&∀8/+/+Ι#∋Χ#/∆/;
%∀Η3+∀3)∋#∆Γ&∀%/ϑ+%∋∆∋+3∋#∆/+Χ∃3∃#/.+∗∃+%∋3∗∀0∃#/#Γ+Ρ−∃+∃.+Ι/Χ∋+∗∃+1/+1∃%1∋+Ι/#/+
#∃∆−3∃#/#+./+Ι#∋8∀∗∀Η3+0∃+./+%∀&/0/+∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3ϑ+0∃+∆∋0∋+Ρ−∃+∃∗&/+%∋3∗&∀&−4∃+−3/+
Ι#∋8∀∗∀Η3+0∃+∗/5∃#+1/%∃#+κπ3∋µ+1∋µκϑ+∗Η.∋+%−/30∋+0∀%1∋+Ι/Χ∋+∗∃+1/+∃)∃%&−/0∋+Ι/#/+
/0Ρ−∀#∀#+∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+Ρ−∃+%∋3∗&∀&−4∃+./∗+∀0∃/∗+4+.∋∗+Ι#∀3%∀Ι∀∋∗+5/∗∃+0∃.+Ι#∋Χ#/∆/+κ./+
.ΗΧ∀%/ϑ+.∋∗+/.Χ∋#∀&∆∋∗+ ∋+ ./∗+ &Φ%3∀%/∗+ ∋+ .∃3Χ−/Π∃∗+0∃+Ι#∋Χ#/∆/%∀Η3κϑ+ %−/30∋+ ∃∗&/+
∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+∃∗+/Ι∋#&/0/+3∋+Ι−0∀∃30∋+∃.+%.∀∃3&∃+#∃8∃./#./+∗∀3+/−&∋#∀Σ/%∀Η3+∋+%−/30∋+
∃∗&Φ+∗−Π∃&/+/+%−/.Ρ−∀∃#+)∋#∆/+0∃+∗∃%#∃&∋+%∋∆∃#%∀/.+∃Υ∀∗&∃3&∃Ω+Ζ[ 0
C"rguct"fg"gnnq."cniwpqu"EFKu"kpenw{gp"nqu" ugtxkekqu" fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"gp" gn"ct/
vewnq"tgncvkxq"c"nqu"#∋4/.&∀∃∗."c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"wpc"kpvgtrtgvcek„p"gzvgpukxc"fgn"ukipkÞec/
fq"fg"nc"gzrtguk„p"Ñkphqtocek„p"tgncvkxc"c"gzrgtkgpekcu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"
ekgpvÞecuÒ."rgtokvkgpfq"fg"guvc"ocpgtc"wpc"tgvgpek„p"gp"nc"hwgpvg"uqdtg"nc"tgpvc"
ucvkuhgejc0"Gp"rctvkewnct."cniwpqu"rcugu"gpvkgpfgp"swg"guvc"gzrtguk„p"eqortgpfg"
vcpvq"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"eqoq"nqu"5#/∀3;µ∋#π∗."ecnkÞecpfq"nqu"rciqu"
tgekdkfqu"eqoq" #∋4/.&∀∃∗"{"crnkecpfq"nc"tginc"fg"fkuvtkdwek„p"fgn"rqfgt"vtkdwvctkq"
eqpvgpkfc"gp"gn"ctv0" 34" fg" EFK"crnkecdng0"Eqoq"jgoqu"cpvkekrcfq."guvg"pq"gu"gn"
gurtkvw"fgn"rtgegrvq"fguvkpcfq"cn"itcxcogp"fg"nqu"#∋4/.&∀∃∗."fg"oqfq"swg"gp"guvqu"
ecuqu"nc"QEFG"tgeqokgpfc"swg"guvcu"tgpvcu"ugcp"ecnkÞecfcu"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"go/
rtguctkcngu0"Cfgoƒu."rqt"nq"swg"jceg"c"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec."gn"rtguvc/
fqt"fgn"ugtxkekq"pq"vtcpuokvg"pkpiwpc"gzrgtkgpekc"kpfwuvtkcn."eqogtekcn"q"ekgpvÞec"
*guvq"gu."π3∋µ;1∋µ+="nq"swg"gp"tgcnkfcf"uwegfg"gu"swg"swkgp"rtguvc"gn"ugtxkekq"wvknk¦c"
uw"π3∋µ/1∋µ"rctc"fgucttqnnct"wpc"uqnwek„p"gurgeÞec"rctc"gn"enkgpvg."fg"oqfq"swg"
guvqu"rciqu"rqt"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"pq"fgdgtcp"ugt"ecnkÞecfqu"eqoq"tgicncu0"C"rg/
uct"fg"gnnq."gp"nc"ogfkfc"gp"swg"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"kpenw{c"guvqu"ugtxkekqu"gp"gn"ctv0"34."
jcdtc"swg"eqpukfgtct"nc"gxgpvwcn"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"nc"tgpvc"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0
Gp"vqfq"ecuq."nc"rtƒevkec"eqpvtcevwcn"rqpg"fg"ocpkÞguvq"swg" gu"dcuvcpvg"eqo¿p"
nc" wvknk¦cek„p" fg" eqpvtcvqu" okzvqu" fg" ()∗+,−∗+"{"rtguvcekp"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"
cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec0"Gp"guvqu"uwrwguvqu."eqoq"jgoqu"cxcp¦cpfq"cpvgtkqtogpvg."nc"
crnkecek„p"fgn"fgpqokpcfq"rtkpekrkq"fg"fgucitgicek„p"gzkig"kfgpvkÞect"ncu"fkuvkpvcu"
rtguvcekqpgu"tgekdkfcu"{"uqogvgt"c"ecfc"wpc"fg"gnncu"cn"vtcvcokgpvq"Þuecn"cfgewcfq"nc"
;" Nqu"rciqu"tgncvkxqu"c"rtqxkuk„p."rqt"rctvg"fgn"rtqxggfqt."fg"kphqtocek„p"tgncvkxc"c"rtqitc/
ocek„p"kphqtoƒvkec." eqoq"pqtoc" igpgtcn." u„nq"ugtƒp" ecnkhkecdngu"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗+ ewcpfq"gn" rciq"ug"
jc{c"ghgevwcfq"rctc"cfswktkt"kphqtocek„p"swg"eqpuvkvw{c"ncu"kfgcu"{"nqu"rtkpekrkqu"dcug"fgn"rtqitcoc."
ewcpfq"nc"kphqtocek„p"ugc"crqtvcfc"ukp"swg"gn"enkgpvg"rwgfc"tgxgnctnc"ukp"rtgxkc"cwvqtk¦cek„p."q"ewcp/
fq"guvf‌i"uwlgvc"c"ewcnswkgt"hqtoc"fg"ugetgvq"eqogtekcn"gzkuvgpvg0
32" Eht0"Rƒttchq"3307"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QEFG0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP97
rctvg"fgn"rciq"swg"ug"kfgpvkÞec"eqp"nc"eguk„p"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ."ug"ecnkÞectƒ"eqoq"#∋4/.;
&4="{"nc"ecpvkfcf"tgekdkfc"gp"xktvwf"fg"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec."
ug"ecnkÞectƒ"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0"Pq"qduvcpvg."uk"wpc"fg"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"
eqpuvkvw{g."eqp"owejq."gn"qdlgvq"rtkpekrcn"fgn"eqpvtcvq."rtgugpvcpfq"nc"qvtc"wp"ectƒe/
vgt"ceeguqtkq."gn"vtcvcokgpvq"Þuecn"crnkecdng"c"nc"rctvg"rtkpekrcn"ug"crnkectƒ"c"nc"uwoc"
inqdcn"fg"nc"tgowpgtcek„p0"Gp"guvg"rwpvq."vcpvq"gn"OE"QFG"eqoq"gn"kphqtog"fgn"VCI"
fg"4223"uqp"rctvkfctkqu"fg"nc"fgucitgicek„p."g"kpukuvgp"gp"swg"gn"vguv"gorngcfq"rctc"
kfgpvkÞect"nc"rtguvcek„p"rtkpekrcn"fgn"eqpvtcvq"tguwnvc"uqnq"crnkecdng"ewcpfq"ncu"qvtcu"
rctvgu"uqp"ceeguqtkcu."kpekfgpvcngu"q"uwdukfkctkcu0
Fkejq"guvq."gn"VCI"gzcokpc"wpc"ugtkg"fg"eqpvtcvqu"gp"gn"Cpgzq"4"fgn"kphqtog"fg"42230
Gp"nqu"uwrwguvqu"gp"nqu"swg"ug"tgcnk¦c"wpc"∋#0∃3+∃.∃%Η3∀%/+4+∗∃+0∃∗%/#Χ/3+∃3+−3+
∋#0∃3/0∋#+Ι#∋0−%&∋∗+ 0∀Χ∀&/.∃∗ϑ+%∋3+./+Þ3/.∀0/0+ 0∃+ ∃ΥΙ.∋&/#+.∋∗+0∃#∃%1∋∗+0∃+/−&∋#+
∋+%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&+*ecvgiqtc"5+."eqoq."rqt"glgornq."ewcpfq"wp"gfkvqt"fg"wp"nkdtq"rcic"
rqt"cfswktkt"gn"fgtgejq"c"tgrtqfwekt"wpc"kocigp"uwlgvc"c"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt"swg"
fguectictƒ"fkikvcnogpvg"rctc"swg" fgurwf‌iu" crctg¦ec" gp" nc" rqtvcfc"fg" wp" nkdtq"
swg"guvƒ"rtqfwekgpfq."nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"fgdgtƒp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗6+C"
fkhgtgpekc"fg"nq"swg"uwegfg"gp"qvtqu"guegpctkqu."gp"guvg"ecuq"gn"rciq"eqpuvkvw{g"
gugpekcnogpvg"nc"tgowpgtcek„p"fg"nc"cfswkukek„p"fgn"fgtgejq"c"wuct"gn"fgtgejq"fg"
cwvqt"kpjgtgpvg"cn"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn."guvq"gu."gn"fgtgejq"c"tgrtqfwekt"{"fkuvtkdwkt"nc"
kocigp."{"pq"¿pkecogpvg"nc"cfswkukek„p"fgn"eqpvgpkfq"fkikvcn0
Rqt"qvtq"ncfq."gn"kphqtog"cpcnk¦c"nqu"Ι/Χ∋∗+#∃/.∀Σ/0∋∗+/+%/∆5∀∋+0∃+./+Ι#∋8∀∗∀Η3+0∃+
∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+&Φ%3∀%/" *ecvgiqtc" 3;+." guvq"gu."eqpvtcvqu"gp" nqu" swg" gn"enkgpvg"tgek/
dg"kphqtocek„p"vf‌iepkec"eqorngvc"eqpÞfgpekcn"uqdtg"wp"rtqfwevq"q"rtqeguq"*rqt"
glgornq."nc" fguetkrek„p" pcttcvkxc"{"nqu"fkcitcocu"fg"wp" rtqeguq"fg"hcdtkecek„p"
ugetgvq+0"Nqu"rciqu"tgekdkfqu"jcp"fg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗."rwguvq"swg"nc"kp/
hqtocek„p"vf‌iepkec"pq"fkxwnicfc"uqdtg"wp"rtqfwevq"q"rtqeguq"gu"π3∋µ;1∋µ0
KKK0" RCIQU"RQT"GN"CTTGPFCOKGPVQ"FG"GURCEKQ"Q"RQT"GN"WUQ"FG"
WP"QTFGPCFQT."WP"UGTXKFQT"Q"WP"GSWKRQ"UKOKNCT
Gu"korqtvcpvg"vgpgt" rtgugpvg"swg."dclq" nc" rgturgevkxc"fgn"OE" QEFG." nqu"rciqu"
rqt"gn"wuq"q"nc"eqpeguk„p"fgn"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞ/
equ"hwgtqp."gp"uw"oqogpvq."eqpukfgtcfqu"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗+ΖΖ 6+Pq"qduvcpvg."vtcu"gn"
Kphqtog"fg"nc"QEFG"uqdtg"gn"cttgpfcokgpvq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"
q"ekgpvÞequ"fg"3;:5"jwdq"wp"ecodkq"korqtvcpvg"gp"gn"vtcvcokgpvq"Þuecn"fg"guvcu"
33"Cu"uwegfc"gp"gn"Rtq{gevq"fgn"Eqpxgpkq"fg"3;85"{"gp"gn"OE"QEFG"fg" 3;990"Kpurktcfqu"gp"
nqu"vgzvqu" fg"3;85"{" 3;99"pcekgtqp"ownvkvwf" fg"eqpxgpkqu"rctc" gxkvct"nc"fqdng" korqukek„p."vqfcxc"
jq{"gp"xkiqt="{."fg"oqfq"rctcngnq."owejqu"rcugu"Ïgpvtg"nqu"swg"ug"gpewgpvtc"Gurc‚cÏ"ug"tgugtxcp"gn"
fgtgejq"c"eqpvkpwct"cfjktkf‌ipfqug."gp" uwu"eqpxgpkqu."c"wpc" fghkpkek„p"fg"#∋4/.&4+swg" kpenw{c"ncu"tgp/
vcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fgn"cttgpfcokgpvq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvhkequ0"Β∀06+ECTOQPC"
HGTPéPFG¥."P0."ÑNc" hkuecnkfcf"fg" nqu"eƒpqpgu" gp"gn" Korwguvq"uqdtg"nc"Tgpvc"fg" Pq"tgukfgpvguÒ6"Gp
>3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+:∋∆∃#%∀/.+?∗Ι/φ∋./β+>:?β+Ο∃8∀∗&/+0∃+?%∋3∋∆Τ/6+?Π∃∆Ι./#+0∃0∀%/0∋+/+Κ−∃8/∗+,∃30∃3%∀/∗+∃3+
?%∋3∋∆Τ/+4+2∀∗%/.∀0/0+>3&∃#3/%∀∋3/.ϑ+p³":47."4227."r0"35;0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
98
egukqpgu"fg"wuq"fg"dkgpgu"vcpikdngu"34."rtqxqecpfq"swg"fkejcu"tgpvcu"ug"vtcuncfc/
tcp"cn"ctvewnq"tgncvkxq"c"tgpfkokgpvqu"fg"cevkxkfcfgu"gortguctkcngu"{c"gp"gn"OE"
QEFG"fg"c‚q"3;;4"35 0"Guvc"eqpegrek„p"rgtfwtc"gp"nc"xgtuk„p"cevwcn"fg"4239"3 6 0
Gn"ecodkq"fg"etkvgtkq"gp"nc"ecvcnqicek„p"fg"guvcu"tgpvcu"ug"jk¦q."rtkpekrcnogpvg."
vgpkgpfq"gp"ewgpvc"ncu"ukiwkgpvgu"rtgokucu0
Gp"rtkogt"nwict."nc"eguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"Çgswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞ/
equÈ"qrgtc"tgurgevq"fg"dkgpgu"vcpikdngu"{"pwpec"tgurgevq"fg"dkgpgu"kpvcpikdngu"37 ."
ucnxq"swg"ug"vtcvg"fg"wp"%∋3/&∋+∆∀Υ&∋"fqpfg."cfgoƒu"fgn"cttgpfcokgpvq"fg"nqu"
gswkrqu."ug"kpenw{c"nc"eguk„p"fg"wp"gngogpvq"kpvcpikdng"eqoq"rwgfg"ugt"nc"eguk„p"
fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ+q"fg"wpc"rcvgpvg0"Uk"cu"hwgtc."gp"rtkogt"nwict."fgdgoqu"fkhgtgpekct."
rqt"wp"ncfq."ncu"tgpvcu"fgtkxcfcu"fg"nc"eguk„p"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"
{"ekgpvÞequ."{."rqt"qvtq."ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"nc"eguk„p"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ"w"qvtq"
cevkxq"kpvcpikdng0"Eqpugewgpvgogpvg."ecfc"wpc"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"vtkdwvctƒ"ukiwkgpfq"
uw"tf‌iikogp"gurgeÞeq."gp"xktvwf"fg"nc"crnkecek„p"fgn"rtkpekrkq"fg"fgucitgicek„p0"
Uqnq"gp" gn"ecuq"fg" swg"nc"fgucitgicek„p" pq"tguwnvg"rqukdng."gn"OE"QEFG"rtgxf‌i"
swg"vqfc"nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc"ugc"itcxcfc"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"nc"tginc"crnkecdng"c"nc"
rtguvcek„p"rtkpekrcn"fgn"eqpvtcvq0
Qvtq"etkvgtkq"guitkokfq" rqt"nc"QEFG"gp"uw"Kphqtog"fg" 3;:5"c" hcxqt"fg"nc"eqpuk/
fgtcek„p"fg" guvqu" rciqu"eqoq"tgpvcu"gortguctkcngu" gu" swg."wpc"kpvgtrtgvcek„p"
34" QGEF.",1∃+&/Υ/&∀∋3+∋)+∀3%∋∆∃+0∃#∀8∃0+)#∋∆+&1∃+.∃/∗∀3Χ+∋)+∀30−∗∀/.ϑ+%∋∆∆∃#%∀/.+∋#+∗%∀∃3&∀)∀%+
∃Ρ−∀Ι∆∃3&ϑ+Rctku."3;:50
35" Guvg"ecodkq"fg"eqpegrek„p"fg"nc"QEFG"vwxq"uw"qtkigp"gp"wpc"Tgeqogpfcek„p"fgn"Eqokvf‌i"
fg"Cuwpvqu"Hkuecngu"fg"38"fg"lwpkq"fg"3;:50"Eqp"rquvgtkqtkfcf."gn"Eqpuglq"fg"nc"QEFG"ukiwk„"ncu"tgeq/
ogpfcekqpgu"rtgugpvcfcu"rqt"gn"Eqokvf‌i"fg"Cuwpvqu"Hkuecngu"{"gn"35"fg"ugrvkgodtg"fg"3;:5"fgekfk„"
tgeqogpfct"c"nqu"Guvcfqu"okgodtqu"fg"nc"Qticpk¦cek„p"swg."ewcpfq"pgiqekcugp"pwgxqu"Eqpxgpkqu"fg"
fqdng"korqukek„p"q"tgxkucugp"nqu"{c"gzkuvgpvgu."pq"kpenw{gugp"ncu"tgpvcu"rqt"eguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"
kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvhkequ"gp"gn"ctv0"34"≅#∋4/.&∀∃∗Α6"Nc"tc¦„p"gtc"nc"ukiwkgpvg¿ogtq"eqpuk/
fgtcdng"fg"Guvcfqu"okgodtqu"fg"nc"QEFG"uwlgvcdcp"c"itcxcogp"gp"nc"hwgpvg"nqu"rciqu"ecnkhkecfqu"eqoq"
#∋4/.&∀∃∗ϑ+c"rguct"fg"swg"gn"OE"QEFG"fghgpfc"wpc"uwlgek„p"gzenwukxc"fg"ncu"tgicncu"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"
tgukfgpekc"fgn"dgpghkekctkq"ghgevkxq"fg"fkejqu"rciqu0"Cn"cornkct"nc"fghkpkek„p"fg"#∋4/.&∀∃∗+g"kpenwkt"gp"f‌in"nqu"
rciqu"rqt"eguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvhkequ."ug"guvcdcp"ownvkrnkecpfq"ncu"
rqukdknkfcfgu"fg"swg"nqu"rciqu"rqt"guvg"eqpegrvq"rwgfcp"guvct"uwlgvqu"c"wp"µ∀&11∋.0∀3Χ+&/Υ+gp"gn"Guvcfq"
fg"nc"hwgpvg."cniq"swg"pq"guvcdc"gp"nc"ogpvg"fg"nqu"Guvcfqu"okgodtqu"ewcpfq"fgnkokvctqp"gn"eqpegrvq"
fg"#∋4/.&∀∃∗+{"ncu"tgincu"fg"vtkdwvcek„p"fg"nqu"okuoqu0"Cu."nc"oglqt"uqnwek„p"gtc"gnkokpct"vqfc"tghgtgpekc"c"
guvqu"rciqu"fgn"ctv0"34"fgn"OE"QEFG"{"gurgtct"c"swg"nqu"Guvcfqu"okgodtqu"fg"nc"QEFG"ukiwkgugp"vcn"fk/
tgevtk¦0"Β∀06+NKFGPETQPC."I0."VQNUVQ[."U0."ÑIgpgtcn"TgrqtvÒ0"Gp:/1∀∃#∗+0∃+!#∋∀&+2∀∗%/.+>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.ϑ+
8∋.6+ε/.",/Υ/ & ∀∋ 3+∋)+ %# ∗∗ +5 #0 #+.∃ /∗∀ 3Χϑ +Couvgtfcouu0
36" Gn"rƒttchq";"fg"nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QEFG"fkurqpgΜ=∀∃3/∗+./+0∃)∀3∀%∀Η3+
0∃.+&Φ#∆∀3∋+Μ#∃Χ/.Τ/∗Ωϑ+∃3+∃.+(#∋4∃%&∋+0∃.+:∋38∃3∀∋+0∃+Ζ]ςΝ+4+∃3+∃.+=∋0∃.∋+0∃+:∋38∃3∀∋+0∃+Ζ]ϑ+%∋∆;
Ι#∃30Τ/+.∋∗+Ι/Χ∋∗+ ΜΙ∋#+∃.+ −∗∋+∋+./+%∋3%∃∗∀Η3+0∃+ −∗∋+0∃+−3+ ∃Ρ−∀Ι∋+∀30−∗∀/.ϑ+ %∋∆∃#%∀/.+∋+%∀∃3&Τ)∀%∋Ωϑ+./+
∆∃3%∀Η3+/+0∀%1∋∗+Ι/Χ∋∗+∃3+∃∗&/+0∃)∀3∀%∀Η3+1/+∗∀0∋+∗−Ι#∀∆∀0/6+λ/5∀0/+%−∃3&/+0∃+./+3/&−#/.∃Σ/+0∃+./∗+#∃3;
&/∗+Ι#∋%∃0∃3&∃∗+0∃.+/##∃30/∆∀∃3&∋+0∃+∃Ρ−∀Ι∋∗+∀30−∗∀/.∃∗ϑ+%∋∆∃#%∀/.∃∗+∋+%∀∃3&Τ)∀%∋∗ϑ+∀3%.−4∃30∋+./∗+#∃3;
&/∗+Ι#∋%∃0∃3&∃∗+0∃.+/##∃30/∆∀∃3&∋+0∃+%∋3&∃3∃0∋#∃∗ϑ+ ∃.+:∋∆∀&Φ+0∃+ 9∗−3&∋∗+2∀∗%/.∃∗+1/+ 0∃%∀0∀0∋+∃Υ%.−∀#+
∃∗&/∗+#∃3&/∗+0∃+./+0∃)∀3∀%∀Η3+0∃+#∃Χ/.Τ/∗+4ϑ+∃3+%∋3∗∃%−∃3%∀/ϑ+0∃.+%/∆Ι∋+0∃+/Ι.∀%/%∀Η3+0∃.+9#&Τ%−.∋+ΖΨϑ+/+)∀3+
0∃+/∗∃Χ−#/#+Ρ−∃+0∀%1/∗+#∃3&/∗+∃∗&Φ3+%∋∆Ι#∃30∀0/∗+0∃3∋+0∃+./∗+0∀∗Ι∋∗∀%∀∋3∃∗+#∃)∃#∃3&∃∗+/+./+∀∆Ι∋∗∀%∀Η3+
0∃+.∋∗+#∃30∀∆∀∃3&∋∗+∃∆Ι#∃∗/#∀/.∃∗+4+0∃+./∗+/%&∀8∀0/0∃∗+ Ι#∋)∃∗∀∋3/.∃∗+%∋∆Ι#∃30∀0/∗+∃3+.∋∗+/#&Τ%−.∋∗+ε+4+
Ω6
37"Gn"qdlgvq"fg"nc"egukp"pq"uqp"nqu"fgtgejqu"fg"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpfwuvtkcn"q"kpvgngevwcn"swg"tgecgp"
uqdtg"gn"dkgp"vcpikdng."ukpq"swg"nq"swg"ug"egfg"gu"ukorngogpvg"gn"wuq"fgn"dkgp"vcpikdng0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP99
nkvgtcn"fgn" ctv0"34"fgn"OE" QEFG" Ïfglcpfq" fg" ncfq" nc" rtƒevkec" eqpxgpekqpcn" swg"
vqoc"gp"eqpukfgtcek„p"wp"µ∀&11∋.0∀3Χ+&/Υ+nkokvcfq"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvgÏ."pqu"
eqpfweg"c"wp"itcxcogp"gzenwukxq"fg"ncu"tgicncu"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc"fg"uw"
rgtegrvqt0"[."rctcngncogpvg."gn"OE"QEFG"fgÞgpfg"swg"nqu"tgpfkokgpvqu"gortg/
uctkcngu"vtkdwvgp"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc0"Cjqtc"dkgp."gn"rtqdngoc"uwd{cegpvg"
gu"nc"rqukdng"fqdng"korqukek„p"swg"ug"igpgtctc"gp"gn"ecuq"fg"rgtokvkt"swg"guvcu"
tgpvcu"gpinqdgp"gn"cdcpkeq"fg"ecvgiqtcu"swg"eqphqtocp"gn"ctv0"340"Cu."okgpvtcu"
swg"gn" Guvcfq"fg"nc" hwgpvg"crnkectc"gn"vkrq" korqukvkxq"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"uqdtg"nc"
tgpvc"dtwvc"rcicfc."nc" fgfweek„p"c"qrgtct"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc"pq"rqftc"
ugt"pvgitc." rwguvq" swg" gp" guvg" ¿nvkoq" ug"rgtokvg"nc"fgfweek„p"fg"icuvqu."wpc"
qrgtcek„p"swg"tgfwektƒ"nc" ewqvc"fgn"korwguvq" gp"eqorctcek„p"eqp"gn"korwguvq"
fgdkfq"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"38 0
Jcdkfc"ewgpvc"fg"gnnq."nc"QEFG"xkgpg"tgeqogpfcpfq"c"nqu"rcugu"okgodtqu"swg"
tgxkugp"nqu"EFK"swg"jc{cp"uwuetkvq"ukiwkgpfq"ncu"fktgevtkegu"fg"nc"Qticpk¦cek„p"{"
gnkokpgp"nc"eguk„p"fg"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞequ"fg"nc"
guhgtc"fgn"ctv0"340
Gp"gn"ecuq"eqpetgvq"fg" Gurc‚c."eqpxkgpg"fguvcect"swg."cwpswg"nc"cevwcn"xgtuk„p"
fg"nqu" Eqogpvctkqu" cn" Ctvewnq" 34" fgn"OE"QEFG"jc"uwrtkokfq" gn" Rƒttchq"67"fg"
nqu"Eqogpvctkqu"gp"gn" swg" Gurc‚c" ug" tgugtxcdc"gn" fgtgejq" fg" itcxcogp" gp" nc"
hwgpvg"fg"ncu" tgpvcu" fgtkxcfcu" fgn" cttgpfcokgpvq" fg" gswkrqu." wp"p¿ogtq"oƒu"
swg"ukipkÞecvkxq" fg"nqu"EFKU" uwuetkvqu"rqt"guvg" rcu"ecnkÞecp"guvcu" tgpvcu"eqoq"
#∋4/.&∀∃∗0"Rwgu"dkgp."ogfkcpfq"wp"eqpxgpkq"fg"fqdng"korqukek„p."{"ukiwkgpfq"f‌iuvg"
nc"npgc" fg"kpenwkt"guvcu" tgpvcu"gp"gn" ƒodkvq"fgn"ctv0"34."ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"rqt"eg/
uk„p"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞequ"swg"ugtcp"ecnkÞecfcu"eqoq"
tgpfkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu"gp"wp"rtkogt"oqogpvq."rcuctƒp"c"ugt"eqpukfgtcfcu"
#∋4/.&∀∃∗0"Gp"ecuq"eqpvtctkq."pqu"gpeqpvtctcoqu"cpvg"rciqu"ecnkÞecdngu"eqoq"tgp/
fkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu0
Gn"kphqtog" fgn"VCI"fg"4223" cpcnk¦c" fkxgtucu"vtcpuceekqpgu"gp" ncu" swg"ug"rqftc"
fghgpfgt"swg"wp"enkgpvg"guvƒ"wucpfq"gswkrqu"kphqtoƒvkequ"vcpikdngu"Ï1/#0µ/#∃Ï"
{."gp"eqpugewgpe kc."e cnect"nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc"eqoq"wp"rciq"rqt"gn"−∗∋+0∃+∃Ρ−∀Ι∋∗+
∀30−∗∀/.∃∗ϑ+%∋∆∃#%∀/.∃∗+ ∋+ %∀∃3&ΤÞ%∋∗0" Gp" guvg" ecuq." gn" itwrq" eqpuwnvkxq" vf‌iepkeq"
rtgekuc"gp"uw"kphqtog"swg"gzkuvgp"wpc"ugtkg"fg"hcevqtgu"pq"gzenwukxqu"swg"rwgfgp"
ugt"¿vkngu"c"nc"jqtc"fg"fkuvkpiwkt"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"cttgpfcokgpvqu"≅#∃3&/.+
Ι/4∆∃3&∗Α+fg"nqu"rciqu"fgtkxcfqu"fg"eqpvtcvqu"fg"rtqxkuk„p"fg"ugtxkekqu0"Cu."nqu"
hcevqtgu"tgngxcpvgu"fg"nqu"rciqu"rqt"cttgpfcokgpvqu"swg"rgtokvgp"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"
fg"nc"tgpvc"eqoq"rciqu"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpv/
Þequ"ugtcp"nqu"ukiwkgpvgu
Ð" "Gn"enkgpvg"quvgpvc"nc"rquguk„p"hukec"fg"nc"rtqrkgfcf="
Ð" "gn"enkgpvg"eqpvtqnc"nc"rtqrkgfcf="
38"OCTVìP"LKO¡PG¥."C0."ÑCtvewnq"340"Nc"vtkdwvcekp"fg"nqu"eƒpqpgu"q"tgicncuÒ0"Gp ECNFG/
TðP"ECTTGTQ."L0O0"{"TWì¥"ICTEìC."L0T0.":∋∆∃3&/#∀∋∗+/+.∋∗+%∋38∃3∀∋∗+Ι/#/+∃8∀&/#+./+0∋5.∃+∀∆Ι∋∗∀%∀Η3+4+
Ι#∃8∃3∀#+./+∃8/∗∀Η3+)∀∗%/.+%∋3%.−∀0∋∗+Ι∋#+?∗Ι/φ/6+93Γ.∀∗∀∗+/+./+.−Σ+0∃.+=∋0∃.∋+0∃+:∋38∃3∀∋+0∃+./+Λ:!?+4+
0∃+./+.∃Χ∀∗./%∀Η3+4+Π−#∀∗Ι#−0∃3%∀/+∃∗Ι/φ∋./6+C"Eqtw‚cKpuvkvwvq"fg"
Guvwfkqu"Geqp„okequ"fg"Icnkekc."4226.+rƒiu0"948/9490
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
9:
Ð" "gn"enkgpvg"vkgpg"wp"kpvgtf‌iu"geqp„okeq"q"rquguqtkq"ukipkÞecvkxq"tgurgevq"fg"nc"
rtqrkgfcf="
Ð" "gn"rtguvcfqt"pq"wvknk¦c"nc"rtqrkgfcf"fg"ocpgtc"ukownvƒpgc"rctc"rtguvct"ugt/
xkekqu"ukipkÞecvkxqu"c"qvtcu"gpvkfcfgu"pq"tgncekqpcfcu"eqp"gn"fguvkpcvctkq"fgn"
ugtxkekq="
Ð" "{"nc"ecpvkfcf"vqvcn"cdqpcfc"pq"gzegfg"eqpukfgtcdngogpvg"gn"xcnqt"fgn"cnswk/
ngt"fg"nqu"gswkrqu"kphqtoƒvkequ"fwtcpvg"nc"fwtcek„p"fgn"eqpvtcvq0
C"eqpvkpwcek„p."rctc"knwuvtct"oglqt"guvqu" uwrwguvqu."gn" VCI"cpcnk¦c"wpc" ugtkg"fg"
eqpvtcvqu"gp"gn"Cpgzq"4"fgn"kphqtog"42230
Gp"rtkogt"nwict."pqu"tghgtktgoqu"c"nqu"∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+0∃+/.∋Π/∆∀∃3&∋+0∃+/Ι.∀%/%∀∋3∃∗+%∋3+
.∀%∃3%∀/+/∀∗./0/"≅/ΙΙ.∀%/&∀∋3+1∋∗&∀3Χ+;+∗∃Ι/#/&∃+.∀%∃3%∃Αϑ"kpenwkfqu"gp"nc"ecvgiqtc"
9"fgn"cpgzq."{"fgÞpkfqu"eqoq"eqpvtcvqu"gp"nqu"swg"gn"wuwctkq"vkgpg"wpc"nkegpekc"
rgtrgvwc"rctc"wuct"wp"rtqfwevq"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃6+Gn"1∋∗&+ectic"wpc"eqrkc"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃+
gp"nqu"ugtxkfqtgu"swg"rqugg"{"swg"uqp"qrgtcfqu"rqt"f‌in."{"rtguvc"uqrqtvg"vf‌iepkeq"
rctc"rtqvgigt"cn" wuwctkq"eqpvtc"nqu" hcnnqu"fgn"ukuvgoc0"Gn"wuwctkq" rwgfg"ceegfgt."
glgewvct"{" qrgtct" eqp" nc" crnkecek„p" fg" ∗∋)&µ/#∃+ fg"ocpgtc" tgoqvc." fgurwf‌iu" fg"
fguectiƒtugnc"gp"uw"ogoqtkc"TCO"q" wvknk¦ctnc" tgoqvcogpvg" gp" gn" ugtxkfqt" fgn"
1∋∗&6+Guvg"vkrq"fg"cewgtfqu"gu"dcuvcpvg"eqo¿p"gp"vgocu"fg"fktgeek„p"Þpcpekgtc."
eqpvtqn"fg"kpxgpvctkq"q" fktgeek„p" fg" tgewtuqu" jwocpqu0" Gp" guvqu"uwrwguvqu."gn"
eqokvf‌i"gpvkgpfg"swg"nqu"rciqu"uqp"tgeqpfwekdngu"cn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG."ocpk/
hguvcpfq"swg"ug"vtcvc"fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu."cwpswg"pq"fg"ugtxkekqu"vf‌ie/
pkequ"*cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec+."rqtswg"ukorngogpvg"ug"vtcvc"fg"qhtgegt"gn"ugtxkekq"rctc"
cnocegpct"fcvqu"gp"gn"∗∋)&µ/#∃+swg"{c" gu"fgn"enkgpvg0"[."gp"nc"ogfkfc"gp"swg"ug"
vtcvc"fg"wp"ukorng"cnocegpcokgpvq"fg"fcvqu"{"pq"tgswkgtg"gn"glgtekekq"fktgevq"fg"
pkpiwpc"fguvtg¦c"q"eqpqekokgpvq"vf‌iepkeq."nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc"pq"rwgfg"ecnkÞectug"
eqoq"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗0"Cukokuoq."gn"kphqtog"fg"4223"rqpg"fg"ocpkÞguvq"swg."gp"nqu"
ecuqu"fg"swg"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"kpenw{c"gp"nc"fgÞpkek„p"fg"#∋4/.&∀∃∗"gn"wuq"fg"gswk/
rqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"{"ekgpvÞequ."rqftc"uwtikt"nc"fwfc"uqdtg"nc"gxgpvwcn"
ecnkÞecek„p"fg" guvqu" rciqu"eqoq"tgicnc0"Pq" qduvcpvg." gp" nc"ogfkfc"gp"swg"gn"
enkgpvg"pq"vkgpg"pk"nc"rquguk„p"pk"gn"eqpvtqn"uqdtg"gn"gswkrq."{"nq"wvknk¦c"ukownvƒpgc/
ogpvg"eqp"qvtqu"enkgpvgu."nqu"rciqu"pq"rwgfgp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0
Gp"ugiwpfq"nwict."cpcnk¦ctgoqu"nqu"∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+0∃+/.∋Π/∆∀∃3&∋+0∃+/Ι.∀%/%∀∋3∃∗+∀3&∃;
Χ#/0∋∗+∃3+−3+Ι/Ρ−∃&∃+0∃+%∋3/&∋∗"*/ΙΙ.∀%/&∀∋3+1∋∗&∀3Χ+;+5−30.∃0+%∋3/%&∗Αϑ+tgeq/
ikfqu"gp"nc"ecvgiqtc":"fgn" cpgzq6+Gp"guvg"vkrq"fg"eqpvtcvqu."gn" rtqxggfqt"Ïswg"
vcodkf‌ip"gu"gn"rtqrkgvctkq"fgn"%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&+fg"wp"rtqitcoc"fg"qtfgpcfqtÏ."c"ecodkq"
fg"wpc"ewqvc"¿pkec."rgtokvg"gn"ceeguq"c"wp"wuwctkq"c"wpc"q"oƒu"crnkecekqpgu"fg"
∗∋)&µ/#∃ϑ+1∋∗&∗+fg"crnkecekqpgu"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃+gp"wp"ugtxkfqt"swg"gu"rtqrkgfcf"{"gu"
qrgtcfq"rqt"gn"1∋∗&ϑ+{"rtqxgg"uqrqtvg"vf‌iepkeq"rctc"gn"1/#0µ/#∃+{"rctc"gn"∗∋)&µ/#∃6+
Gn"wuwctkq" rwgfg" ceegfgt."glgewvct" {" qrgtct" nc" crnkecek„p" fg" uqhvyctg"fg"oqfq"
tgoqvq0"Nc"crnkecek„p"ug"glgewvc"fgufg"gn"qtfgpcfqt"fgn"enkgpvg"fgurwf‌iu"fg"swg"
ug"fguectiwg"gp"nc"ogoqtkc"TCO"q"tgoqvcogpvg"gp"gn"ugtxkfqt"fgn"1∋∗&0"Gn"eqp/
vtcvq"ug" rwgfg"tgpqxct"cpwcnogpvg" c" ecodkq"fgn"rciq"fg" wpc"ewqvc"cfkekqpcn0"
Gp"guvqu" ecuqu."gn"VCI"gpvkgpfg"swg" vqfc"nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc" fgdgtc"ugt"vtcvcfc"
eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu" *ctv0" 9+0" Pq"qduvcpvg."gp" gn" uwrwguvq" fg" swg" gn"
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP9;
EFK"crnkecdng" eqpvgpic" wpc" rtqxkuk„p"gurgekcn"gp"nc"swg" ug" rgtokvc" wpc" tgvgp/
ek„p"gp"nc"hwgpvg"uqdtg"nqu"rciqu"rqt"ugtxkekqu" fg" cukuvgpekc" vf‌iepkec" ≅&∃%13∀%/.+
)∃∃∗Αϑ+cn"vtcvctug"fg"wp"eqpvtcvq"okzvq"jcdtc"swg"fgueqorqpgt"nc"tgpvc"{"crnkect"
c"ecfc"rctvg"fgn"eqpvtcvq"gn"vtcvcokgpvq"vtkdwvctkq"eqttgurqpfkgpvg0"Nc"rctvg"fgn"
rciq"swg"ug"eqttgurqpfg"eqp"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"uqrqtvg" vf‌iepkeq"rctc"gn" ∗∋)&µ/#∃"
ug"ecnkÞectƒ"eqoq"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗"uk"rctc"gnnq"ug"tgswkgtg"nc"crnkecek„p"fg"fguvtg¦cu"
q"eqpqekokgpvqu"vf‌iepkequ"rqt" rctvg" fgn"rtguvcfqt="ncu"qvtcu" rtguvcekqpgu"vkgpgp"
swg"xgt"eqp"rgtokvkt"gn"ceeguq"c"wpc"q"oƒu"crnkecekqpgu"fg"∗∋)&µ/#."{"cnqlct"gucu"
crnkecekqpgu" fg" ∗∋)&µ/#∃" pq" tgswkgtg" gn" gorngq" fg" fguvtg¦cu" q" eqpqekokgpvqu"
vf‌iepkequ."ukpq"ukorngogpvg"fkurqpgt"fgn"gswkrq"{"fg"nqu"fgtgejqu"uqdtg"gn"rtq/
itcoc"swg"ug"qhtgegp0"Rqt"gnnq."guvc"ugiwpfc"rctvg"fgn"rciq"ugtc"ecnkÞecfc"eqoq"
dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
Gp"vgtegt"nwict."gpeqpvtcoqu"nqu"uwrwguvqu"fg"tgpvcu"cdqpcfcu"c"Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#∃∗+0∃+
∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+0∃+ /Ι.∀%/%∀∋3∃∗+ ≅/ΙΙ.∀%/&∀∋3+ ∗∃#8∀%∃+ Ι#∋8∀0∃#ϑ+CUR+."kpenwkfqu"gp"nc" ecvg/
iqtc";"fgn"cpgzq0"Gp"guvg"uwrwguvq."gn"rtqxggfqt"qdvkgpg"nc"nkegpekc"rctc"wuct"gn"
∗∋)&µ/#∃" gp" uw"pgiqekq"fg"rtqxkuk„p"fg"ugtxkekqu" fg" crnkecekqpgu0" Gn"rtqxggfqt"
rqpg"c"fkurqukek„p"fgn"enkgpvg"q"wuwctkq"gn"ceeguq"c"nc"crnkecek„p"fg"∗∋)&µ/#"swg"
guvƒ"gp"wp"ugtxkfqt"swg"gu"rtqrkgfcf"{"gu"qrgtcfq"rqt"gn"rtqxggfqt0"["gn"∗∋)&µ/#∃"
cwvqocvk¦c"wpc"hwpek„p"rctvkewnct"fg"5/%π;∋%∃"rctc"gn"wuwctkq0"Rqt"glgornq."gn"
∗∋)&µ/#∃"rwgfg"cwvqocvk¦ct"nc"eqpvtcvcek„p."gn"rgfkfq."gn"rciq"{"gn"gpxq"fg"nqu"
dkgpgu"q"ugtxkekqu"gp"gn"rtqrkq"pgiqekq"fgn"wuwctkq0"Gp"guvg"ecuq."gn"rtqxggfqt"pq"
rtqxgg"nqu" dkgpgu"q"ugtxkekqu=" ukorngogpvg"ng"hceknkvc"cn" enkgpvg" nqu"ogfkqu"rctc"
cwvqocvk¦ct"{"ocpglct"uw"kpvgtceek„p"eqp"vgtegtqu0"Gn"enkgpvg"pq"vkgpg"fgtgejq"c"
eqrkct"gn"∗∋)&µ/#"q"wuctnq"gp"qvtq"nwict"swg"pq"ugc"gn"ugtxkfqt"fgn"rtqxggfqt."{"
vcorqeq"vkgpg"pk"nc"rquguk„p"pk"gn"eqpvtqn"uqdtg"nc"eqrkc"fg"∗∋)&µ/#0
Gp"guvg" rwpvq." gn"VCI"eqpukfgtc"swg"ug"vtcvc" fg" wp" uwrwguvq"ow{"ukoknct"c" nqu"
/ΙΙ.∀%/&∀∋3+1∋∗&∃0+ ;+5−30.∃0+%∋3/%&∗ϑ+rqt"nq"swg" tgpvc"qdvgpkfc"fgdgtc"ecnkÞ/
ectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9+0
[."gp"ewctvq"nwict."pqu"tghgtktgoqu"c"nqu"%∋3/&∋∗+0∃+µ∃5∗∀&∃+1∋∗&∀3Χ"*ecvgiqtc"33+"
{"/.∆/%∃3/∆∀∃3&∋+0∃+0/&∋∗"≅0/&/+µ/#∃1∋−∗∀3ΧΑ*ecvgiqtc"35+0"
Gp"nqu" eqpvtcvqu"fg"µ∃5∗∀&∃+ 1∋∗&∀3Χ."gn"rtqxggfqt"qhtgeg"gurcekq"gp" uw"ugtxkfqt"
rctc"cndgtict"µ∃5∗∀&∃∗0"Gn"rtqxggfqt"pq"qdvkgpg"fgtgejqu"uqdtg"gn"gxgpvwcn"oc/
vgtkcn"rtqvgikfq"rqt"fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt"swg"rwgfc"etgct" gn"swg"fgucttqnnc"gn"eqp/
vgpkfq" fg" nc" rƒikpc" µ∃50" Gn"rtqrkgvctkq"fgn" ocvgtkcn" fgn" µ∃5∗∀&∃+ rtqvgikfq" rqt"
fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt"rqftƒ"ocpkrwnctnq"tgoqvcogpvg."kpenw{gpfq"nc"oqfkÞecek„p"
fgn"eqpvgpkfq"gp"nc"rtqrkc"µ∃5." {"gn"rtqxggfqt"tgekdktƒ"wpc"ewqvc"swg"ug"Þlc"gp"
hwpek„p"fgn"vkgorq"swg"jc"vtcpuewttkfq0
Rqt" uw" rctvg."gp"nqu" %∋3/&∋∗+0∃+/.∆/%∃3/∆∀∃3&∋+ 0∃+ 0/&∋∗."gn" enkgpvg" cnocegpc"
uwu"fcvqu"kphqtoƒvkequ"gp"ugtxkfqtgu"swg" uqp"rtqrkgfcf"{" uqp"qrgtcfqu"rqt"gn"
rtqxggfqt0"Gn"enkgpvg"rwgfg"ceegfgt."uwdkt."tgewrgtct"{"ocpkrwnct"nqu"fcvqu"tgoq/
vcogpvg0"[" pq" ug" qvqtic"nkegpekc"fg"∗∋)&µ/#"cniwpc"cn"enkgpvg0"Rqt"glgornqwp"
okpqtkuvc"swg" cnocegpc" uwu" ctejkxqu"fg"kpxgpvctkq"*gzkuvgpekcu+"gp" gn" 1/#0µ/#∃"
fgn"rtqxggfqt"{"ncu"rgtuqpcu"swg"guvf‌ip"gp"gn"oquvtcfqt"fg"rgfkfqu"rwgfgp"ce/
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
:2
egfgt"fg"oqfq"tgoqvq"c"guvc"kphqtocek„p"rctc"fgvgtokpct"swf‌i"rgfkfqu"rwgfgp"
ewdtktug"eqp"gn"∗&∋%π"gzkuvgpvg0
Gp"codqu"uwrwguvqu."gn"VCI"gpvkgpfg"swg"nqu"rciqu"jcp"fg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dg/
pgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9+="vcodkf‌ip"gp"gn"ecuq"fg"swg"wp"gxgpvwcn"EFK"kpenw{c"
gp"nc" fgÞpkek„p" fg" #∋4/.&∀∃∗+ nqu" rciqu"rqt"gn"wuq."q" gn" fgtgejq" c" wuct."gswkrqu"
kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞequ."q"kpenwuq"rtgxkukqpgu"cnvgtpcvkxcu"uqdtg"gn"
itcxcogp"gp"nc"hwgpvg"fg"nc"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec0"
KX0" RCIQU"RQT"UGTXKEKQU"RTGUVCFQU"C"ENKGPVGU
Ukiwkgpfq"ncu"tgeqogpfcekqpgu"fg"nc"QEFG"rncuocfcu"gp"gn"Oqfgnq"fg"Eqpxgpkq"
rctc"gxkvct"nc"fqdng"korqukek„p."eqoq" tginc"igpgtcn."nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"eqoq"
eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"rqt"nc"rtqxkuk„p"fg" ugtxkekqu" uqp" tgeqpfwekfqu"c"nc"guhgtc" fg"
nqu"dgpgÞekqu" gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9"OE"QEFG+." nq"swg"kornkec"swg" nc"tgpvc"ugtƒ"
itcxcfc"gzenwukxcogpvg"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc"fg"nc"gpvkfcf"swg" nqu"tgekdg0"
Cn"okuoq"vkgorq."wp"rtqxggfqt"fg"ugtxkekqu"pq"tgukfgpvg"swg"vgpic"wp"guvcdngek/
okgpvq"rgtocpgpvg"*GR+"gp"qvtq"Guvcfq"rqftƒ"ugt"itcxcfq"gp"guc"lwtkufkeek„p"gp"
tgncek„p"eqp"nc"tgpvc"cvtkdwkdng"c"gug"GR"*ctv0"7"OE"QEFG+0
Cjqtc"dkgp."gp"qecukqpgu."nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"tgswkgtg"swg"nc"rctvg"rtguvc/
fqtc"fkurqpic"fg"jcdknkfcfgu"q"eqpqekokgpvqu"gurgekcngu."nq"swg"kornkectc"swg"
nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc"ugtc"ecnkÞecfc"eqoq"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗6"Nc"fkuvkpek„p"gpvtg"&∃%13∀%/.+
)∃∃∗"{"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"gu"tgngxcpvg"rqtswg."eqoq"ug"jc"rwguvq" fg"oc/
pkÞguvq"cpvgtkqtogpvg."uk" gn"EFK"crnkecdng"kpenw{g"wpc" rtgxkuk„p"gurgeÞec" rctc"
ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"q"nqu"kpenw{g"gp"gn"ctv0"34"fgfkecfq"cn"itcxcogp"fg"
#∋4/.&∀∃∗."gn"rciq"rqftc"ugt"uqogvkfq"c"wpc"tgvgpek„p"gp"nc"hwgpvg0
Gn"eqpvtcvq"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"rwgfg"gpvgpfgtug"eqoq"wp"eqpvtcvq"fg"vtcpuhg/
tgpekc"fg"vgepqnqic"dcucfq"gp"wp"cttgpfcokgpvq"fg"qdtc."{c"swg"swkgp"rtguvc"
gn"ugtxkekq"ug"qdnkic"c"qdvgpgt"wp"tguwnvcfq"kpfwuvtkcn0"C"lwkekq"fg"nc"QEFG."nc"gz/
rtguk„p"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"kpenw{g"wpc"cornkc"icoc"fg"ΜΙ#∃∗&/%∀∋3∃∗+0∃+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+
0∃+/Ι.∀%/%∀Η3+0∃+ &∃%3∋.∋ΧΤ/ϑ+0∃3∋+0∃+−3+Ι#∋%∃∗∋+∃∆Ι#∃∗/#∀/.ϑ+∗∀3+Ρ−∃+3∃%∃∗/#∀/;
∆∃3&∃+0∃5/3+8∃3∀#+.∀Χ/0∋∗+/+Ι#∋%∃∗∋∗+∀30−∗∀/.∃∗ϑ+Ι−0∀∃30∋ϑ+Ι∋#+&/3&∋ϑ+Ι#∋0−%∀#∗∃+
∃3+∋/∗+Γ#∃/∗+κ%∋∆∃#%∀/.ϑ+∆/#π∃&∀3Χϑ+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗ϑ+∃&%κ+0∃+./+/%&∀8∀0/0+∃%∋3Η∆∀%/δ+σϕτ+
∗∃+/&/+0∃+Ι#∃∗&/%∀∋3∃∗+0∃+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗ϑ+0∃+∋5.∀Χ/%∀∋3∃∗+0∃+Μ1/%∃#Ωϑ+4+3∋+0∃+−3/+%∃∗∀Η3+
0∃+−3+ 5∀∃3+&/3Χ∀5.∃+∋+ ∀3&/3Χ∀5.∃ϑ+∗∃/+#∃Χ∀∗/0∋+∋+3∋+Ζ Ω6"Uqp."gp"uwoc."eqpvtcvqu"
fqpfg"Μ∃.+Ι# 8∃ 0∋ #+0∃. +∗#8 %∀ +∗∃+∋5 .∀Χ /+/+%#∃ /#+−3 #∋0 %& +3−∃ 8∋+∋+/+0∃∗/ ##∋../# +
−3∋+4/+∃Υ∀∗&∃3&∃+≅Ρ−∃+Ι−∃0∃+∀3%.−∗∋+∗∃#+−3+π3∋µ;1∋µ+∃∗Ι∃%ΤÞ%∋Α6+(/#/+0∃∗/##∋../#+
∃.+3−∃8∋+ Ι#∋0−%&∋ϑ+ ∃.+ Ι#∋8∃∃0∋#+0∃.+ ∗∃#8∀%∀∋+ /Ι.∀%/#Γ+−3+ %∋3∋%∀∆∀∃3&∋+ ∃Υ∀∗&∃3&∃ϑ+
∋+ ∃∗Ι∃%∀/.∃∗+ 1/5∀.∀0/0∃∗ϑ+ ∋+ ∃ΥΙ∃#∀∃3%∀/∗+ /0Ρ−∀#∀0/∗"3: 6+ Cu." pq" jc{" uwokpkuvtq" fg"
39" ECTOQPC"HGTPéPFG¥."P0."ÑNc"hkuecnkfcf"fg"nqu"eƒpqpgu"gp"gn"Korwguvq"uqdtg"nc"Tgpvc"fg"
Pq"tgukfgpvguÒ6">:?β+Ο∃8∀∗&/+0∃+∃%∋3∋∆Τ/ϑ+∋Ι6+%∀&6."rƒiu0"355/3680
3:"OCTVìP"LKO¡PG¥."C0."ÑCtvewnq"340"Nc"vtkdwvcekp"fg"nqu"eƒpqpgu"q"tgicncuÒ0"Gp
ECTTGTQ."L0O0"{"TWì¥"ICTEìC."L0T0.":∋∆∃3&/#∀∋∗+/+.∋∗+%∋38∃3∀∋∗+Ι/#/+∃8∀&/#+./+0∋5.∃+∀∆Ι∋∗∀%∀Η3+4+Ι#∃;
8∃3∀#+./+∃8/∗∀Η3+)∀∗%/.ϕ+∋Ι6+%∀&6ϑ+rƒi0"93:0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP:3
π3∋µ;1∋µ"eqoq"vcn"cn"tgegrvqt"fgn"ugtxkekq0"Gnnq"ukipkÞec"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"crnkec"
wp"eqpqekokgpvq" {c"cfswktkfq"c" wpc"Þpcnkfcf"fgvgtokpcfc0"[" uk"guvc"crnkecek„p"
uwrqpg"nc"etgcek„p"fg"wp"rtqfwevq."gn"tgegrvqt"ugtƒ+rtqrkgvctkq"fg"nqu"gxgpvwcngu"
fgtgejqu"uqdtg"gn"okuoq0
Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq."gn"VCI"fgÞpk„"gp"uw"kphqtog"fg"4223"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"
vf‌iepkequ"q"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"≅&∃%13∀%/.+∗∃#8∀%∃∗Α"eqoq"nqu"ugtxkekqu"gp"nqu"ewcngu"
gu"pgeguctkq"swg"gn"rtguvcfqt"ewgpvg"eqp"wpc"rgtkekc."jcdknkfcf"q"eqpqekokgpvqu"
vf‌iepkequ"gurgeÞequ0"Gp"eqpetgvq."ug"vtcvctc"fg"eqpqekokgpvqu"rgtvgpgekgpvgu"cn"
ƒodkvq"fg"nc"ekgpekc"q"nc"ctvgucpc0"Cu"rwgu."gp"guvc"ecvgiqtc"ug"gpvgpfgtcp"kp/
enwkfcu"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"vf‌iepkequ"g"kpvgngevwcngu"≅5#/∀3;µ∋#πΑ+Ζ] 6+Cjqtc"
dkgp."gn"jgejq"fg"swg"nc"vgepqnqic"ugc"wucfc"cn"rtguvct"wp"ugtxkekq"pq"gu"wp"jg/
ejq"kpfkecvkxq"fg"swg"ug"vtcvg"fg"wp"ugtxkekq"vf‌iepkeq."c"rguct"fg"swg"gp"guvg"fqew/
ogpvq"ug"rqpic"fg"ocpkÞguvq"swg"nc"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec"gu"wpc"uwdecvgiqtc"fg"nc"
ecvgiqtc"igpf‌itkec"Ñrtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekquÒ0"Gnnq."pq"qduvcpvg."pq"swkgtg"fgekt"
swg"ugc"nc"¿pkec"fg"guvcu"ecvgiqtcu0"Cu."gn"kphqtog"fkuvkpiwg"gpvtg"nc"cukuvgpekc"
vf‌iepkec"gp"ugpvkfq"guvtkevq"≅&∃%13∀%/.+∗∃#8∀%∃∗+Ψ [ Α."nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"cfokpkuvtcek„p"{"
fktgeek„p"≅∆/3/Χ∃#∀/.+∗∃#8∀%∃∗+Ψ Ζ Α+{."rqt"¿nvkoq."nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqpuwnvqtc"≅%∋3∗−.;
&/3%4+∗∃#8∀%∃∗+ΨΨ Α6"Fg"guvg"oqfq."nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"rqt"cuguqtcokgpvq"rtguvcfq"
c"vtcxf‌iu" fg" ogfkqu"fkikvcngu." rqt" eqowpkecekqpgu"eqp" rgtuqpcn" vf‌iepkeq."q" rqt"
ceegfgt."c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"tgfgu"fkikvcngu."c"dcugu"fg"fcvqu"fg"d¿uswgfc"{"tguqnwek„p"fg"
gttqtgu"≅∋−5.∃;∗1∋∋&∀3Χ+0/&/5/∗∃∗Αϑ+uqp"enctqu"glgornqu"fg"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗6
Gn"kphqtog"fg"4223"fgn"VCI"cpcnk¦c"fkxgtuqu"eqpvtcvqu"fg"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxk/
ekqu."eqp"gn"qdlgvq"fg"fgvgtokpct"uk"rwgfgp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgp/
ekc"vf‌iepkec"q"uk."rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."ug"vtcvc"fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"ukorng"q"
igpgtcn0
Gp"rtkogt"nwict."ug"gzcokpcp"nqu"∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+0∃+∆/3&∃3∀∆∀∃3&∋+0∃+∗∋)&µ/#∃"≅∗∋)&µ/#∃+
∆/∀3&∃3/3%∃Α+*ecvgiqtc"34+."swg"uqp"eqpvtcvqu"swg"uwgngp"kpenwkt"cevwcnk¦cekqpgu"
fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃ϑ" eqplwpvcogpvg" eqp" nc" rtguvcek„p" fg" uqrqtvg" vf‌iepkeq" cn" wuwctkq" q"
enkgpvg0"Eqoq"eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"rqt"codcu"rtguvcekqpgu"ug"uwgng"rcict"wpc"uqnc"
3;" Ugi¿p"nq"fkurwguvq"gp"gn"ctv0"3405"fgn"OE"QPW."nc"gzrtguk„p"Ñkphqtocekqpgu"tgncvkxcu"c"gzrg/
tkgpekcu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"{"ekgpvhkecuÒ"cdctec"pq"u„nq"nc"eguk„p"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ."ukpq"vcodkf‌ip"nqu"
5#/∀3;µ∋#π"*eht0"Eqogpvctkqu"cn"Ctvewnq"34"fgn"OE"QPW+0"Gp"gugpekc."nqu"5#/∀3;µ∋#π+kornkecp"nc"vtcpu/
hgtgpekc"fg"kphqtocek„p" Ïpqtocnogpvg"xkpewncfc" eqp"nc" rtguvcek„p"fg" ugtxkekqu" vf‌iepkequÏ"rgtq" f‌iuvc"
pq"cnecp¦c"nqu"guvƒpfctgu"pgeguctkqu"rctc"ugt"eqpukfgtcfc"vtcpuhgtgpekc"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ6"Pq"ug"ukiwg"nc"
okuoc"npgc"gp"gn"OE"QEFG."fqpfg"nqu"5#/∀3;µ∋#π"pq"igpgtctcp"tgicncu."ukpq"swg"ug"tgeqpfwektcp"
cn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG0"Β∀06+NCKPQHH."U0T0."XCKUJ."T0E0."ÑIgpgtcn"TgrqtvÒ0"GpKHC.":/1∀∃#∗+0∃+!#∋∀&+2∀∗%/.+
>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.ϑ+8∋.6+⊥Ψ/.",1∃+&/Υ/&∀∋3+∋)+∀3%∋∆∃+0∃#∀8∃0+)#∋∆+&1∃+∗−ΙΙ.4+∋)+&∃%13∋.∋Χ4ϑ"Couvgtfco
3;;9."rƒiu0"4:/4;0
42" Ug"vtcvc"fg"ugtxkekqu"uwokpkuvtcfqu"c"enkgpvgu"swg"tgswkgtgp"wpc"rtgrctcek„p"q"wpqu"eqpq/
ekokgpvqu"gurgekcngu"tgncekqpcfqu"eqp"wp"ecorq"vf‌iepkeq0"Gp"guvg"rwpvq."gn"jgejq"fg"swg"ug"wvknkeg"nc"
vgepqnqic"rctc"uwokpkuvtct"gn"ugtxkekq."pq"nq"eqpxkgtvg"gp"wp"ugtxkekq"fg"ectƒevgt"vf‌iepkeq0
43" Nc"gzrtguk„p"∆/3/Χ∃#∀/.+∗∃#8∀%∃∗"gpinqdc"ncu"hwpekqpgu"tgncekqpcfcu"eqp"nc"igtgpekc"fgn"pg/
iqekq0"Eqoq"glgornq."ug"kpfkec"swg"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fguvkpcfqu"c"nc"ugngeek„p"{"rtgrctcek„p"fgn"rgtuqpcn"
fg"wpc"gortguc"ug"kpenwktcp"gp"nc"ecvgiqtc"∆/3/Χ∃#∀/.+∗∃#8∀%∃∗0
44" Nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqpuwnvctc"uqp"nqu"swg"rtguvcp"rtqhgukqpcngu"eqp"wpc"gurgekcn"ewcnkhkecek„p"
swg"ngu"rgtokvg"rtguvct"guvg"vkrq"fg"ugtxkekqu0"Guvc"ecvgiqtc"rwgfg"nngict"c"uqncrctug"eqp"nc"ecvgiqtc"
fg"∆/3/Χ∃#∀/.+∗∃#8∀%∃∗6
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
:4
ewqvc"cpwcn" {."gp" nc"oc{qtc"fg"ecuqu." gn"qdlgvq"rtkpekrcn" fgn"eqpvtcvq"gu" nc"ce/
vwcnk¦cek„p"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃6" Tgurgevq" fg" f‌iuvqu." gn" VCI"eqpenw{g" swg." cn" vtcvctug" fg"
wp"eqpvtcvq"okzvq."rctvg"fgn"rciq"tgekdkfq"ug"tghgtktc"c"nc"rtqxkuk„p"fg"uqrqtvg"
vf‌iepkeq."tgekdkgpfq" eqoq" eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗0"Tgurgvq"fg"guvc" rctvg"
fg"nc"tgpvc."uk"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"kpenw{g"guvc"ecvgiqtc"gp"nc"fgÞpkek„p"fg"#∋4/.&∀∃∗."
ugtc"rqukdng" glgtegt" wpc" tgvgpek„p"gp"nc"hwgpvg0"Pq" qduvcpvg." gn"VCI"kpukuvg"gp"
swg"gp"nc"oc{qtc"fg"nqu"uwrwguvqu"guvqu"rciqu"ugtƒp"ecnkÞecfqu"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"
gortguctkcngu0
Rqt"qvtq"ncfq."ug"eqpukfgtcp"nqu"eqpvtcvqu"fg"/∗∀∗&∃3%∀/+/+%.∀∃3&∃∗+/+/8Φ∗+0∃+−3/+
#∃0+∀3)∋#∆Γ&∀%/+≅%−∗&∋∆∃#+∗−ΙΙ∋#&+∋8∃#+/+%∋∆Ι−&∃#+3∃&µ∋#πΑ"*ecvgiqtc"36+."gp"nqu"
swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"hceknkvc"uqrqtvg" vf‌iepkeq" ∋3.∀3∃"cn"enkgpvg."kpenw{gpfq"cuguqtc/
okgpvq"uqdtg"nc" kpuvcncek„p"g"kphqtocek„p"uqdtg"tguqnwek„p"fg"rtqdngocu0"Guvg"
uqrqtvg"rwgfg" tgcnk¦ctug"c"vtcxf‌iu"fgn"uwokpkuvtq"fg"fqewogpvcek„p" vf‌iepkec"c"nc"
swg"ug"rwgfg"ceegfgt"∋3.∀3∃."c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"wpc"dcug"fg"fcvqu"fg"tguqnwek„p"fg"rtq/
dngocu"q"eqowpkecekqpgu"eqp"nqu"vf‌iepkequ"*rqt"g/ockn."gve+0"Gp"guvg"ecuq."gn"VCI"
eqpenw{g"swg"ug"vtcvc"fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"{"pq"fg"wpc"eguk„p"fg"π3∋µ;
1∋µ0"[."gp"gn"ecuq"fg"swg"gn"cuguqtcokgpvq"∋3.∀3∃"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"eqowpkecekqpgu"eqp"
nqu"vf‌iepkequ"tgswkgtc"fg"nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fg"fguvtg¦cu"{"eqpqekokgpvqu"gurgekcngu."nqu"
rciqu"tgekdkfqu"rqftcp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"&∃%13∀%/.+ )∃∃∗6"Gp"guvg"rwpvq."uk" gn"EFK"
crnkecdng"kpenw{gug"wpc"rtqxkuk„p"gurgeÞec"tgncvkxc"c"ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepk/
ec."ugtc"rqukdng"crnkect"wpc"tgvgpek„p"gp"nc"hwgpvg"uqdtg"nc"tgpvc"ucvkuhgejc0"Rqt"gn"
eqpvtctkq."gn"ceeguq"c"wpc"dcug"fg"fcvqu"fg"tguqnwek„p"fg"rtqdngocu"pq"tgswkgtg"
nc"crnkecek„p" fg" pkpiwpc"fguvtg¦c."jcdknkfcf"q" eqpqekokgpvq" gurgekcn"rqt"rctvg"
fg"nqu"vf‌iepkequ."ukpq"ukorngogpvg"vgpgt"fkurqpkdng"nc"dcug"fg"fcvqu"{"gn"∗∋)&µ/#∃"
pgeguctkq"rctc"ceegfgt"c"nc"okuoc0"Rqt"guvg"oqvkxq."gp"guvg"¿nvkoq"ecuq"nqu"rciqu"
tgekdkfqu"fgdgp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu" gortguctkcngu0"Hkpcnogpvg."gn" uwok/
pkuvtq"fg"fqewogpvcek„p"vf‌iepkec"rqftc"eqpuvkvwkt"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ."uk"
ug"vtcvc"fg"kphqtocek„p"vf‌iepkec"pq"fkxwnicfc="gp"guvg"ecuq."gn"π3∋µ;1∋µ"fgdg"ugt"
kphqtocek„p"vf‌iepkec"tgncekqpcfc"eqp"nc"tgrtqfweek„p"kpfwuvtkcn"fg"wp"rtqfwevq"q"
rtqeguq0"Gp"vqfq"ecuq."nc"kphqtocek„p"tgncekqpcfc"eqp"gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"q"gn"wuq"
fg"rtqfwevqu"pq"gpeclc"gp"gn"eqpegrvq"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ6
Rqt"uw" rctvg."gp"nqu"eqpvtcvqu"swg"vkgpgp"rqt"qdlgvq"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+0∃+
#∃%−Ι∃#/%∀Η3+0∃+0/&∋∗+≅0/&/+#∃∀∃8/.Α"*ecvgiqtc"37+ϑ+gn"rtqxggfqt"rqpg"c"fkurquk/
ek„p"fg"uwu"enkgpvgu"kphqtocek„p."rwfkgpfq"f‌iuvqu"tgcnk¦ct"d¿uswgfcu"{"tgewrgtct"
fcvqu0"Gn"rtkpekrcn"xcnqt"rctc"nc"enkgpvgnc"gu"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"dwuect"{"gzvtcgt"fcvqu"
gurgeÞequ"fgpvtq"fg"wpc"cornkc"eqngeek„p"fg"kphqtocek„p"q"fcvqu"fkurqpkdngu0"
Gp"guvg"ecuq." cniwpqu"okgodtqu"fgn"VCI"rwukgtqp"fg"ocpkÞguvq"ncu"fkÞewnvcfgu"
rctc" fgvgtokpct" uk" ug" vtcvcdc" fg"wp" eqpvtcvq" fg"rtguvcek„p" fg" ugtxkekqu" q." rqt"
gn"eqpvtctkq."fg"wpc"vtcpuceek„p"gp"nc"swg"gn"enkgpvg"ucvkuhceg"wp"rciq"c"ecodkq"
fg"tgcnk¦ct"wpc"d¿uswgfc"{"qdvgpgt"fcvqu0"Jc{"swg"rtgekuct"swg."cwpswg"rwgfc"
eqpukfgtctug"swg"guvcoqu"cpvg"wp"eqpvtcvq"fg"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu."pq"ug"vtc/
vctc"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepkec."{c"swg"pq"ug"tgswkgtg"gn"glgtekekq"fg"wpc"
ewcnkfcf"q" eqpqekokgpvq" gurgekcn"rqt"rctvg"fgn"rtguvcfqt"fgn" ugtxkekq0"Rqt"gnnq."
gp"ewcnswkgtc"fg"nqu"uwrwguvqu"guvctcoqu"cpvg"rciqu"tgeqpfwekdngu"cn"ctv0"9"fgn"
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP:5
OE"QEFG"{."rqt"nq"vcpvq."nc"tgpvc"ug"ecnkÞectc"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0"Ukp"
godctiq."cni¿p" cwvqt" jc" cÞtocfq" swg" f‌iuvc" gu" wpc" ewguvk„p" fkuewvkdng." {c"swg"
guvcu"dcugu"fg"fcvqu"uqp"eqorctcdngu"eqp"dkdnkqvgecu"∋3.∀3∃."gp"ncu"swg"wpc"rgt/
uqpc"rwgfg"gpvtct"{"wuct"nc"kphqtocek„p"eqpvgpkfc"gp"gnncu"rcicpfq"wpc"ewqvc."
pqtocnogpvg"Þlcfc" gp" hwpek„p" fgn" vkgorq" swg" ug"rgtokvg"gn"ceeguq"45 0" Ug" vtcvc"
fg"nkegpekcu"fg"kpvcpikdngu."eqp"nc"rgewnkctkfcf"fg"swg"jc{"rgtuqpcn"jwocpq"swg"
cukuvg"cn"wuwctkq"okgpvtcu"vkgpg"ceeguq"c"nc"kphqtocek„p0"Guvctcoqu."ugi¿p"Y嚢杷波能蚤"
cpvg."wp"eqpvtcvq"okzvq."{"jcdtc"swg"fgueqorqpgt"ncu"tgpvcu"rgtekdkfcu"uk"hwgtc"
rqukdng."ecnkÞecpfq"nc"nkegpekc"fg"nqu"kpvcpikdngu"rqt"wp"ncfq"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗+{"nqu"
ugtxkekqu"fg"eqpuwnvqtc"rtguvcfqu"eqoq"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗0
Gn"ukiwkgpvg"uwrwguvq"cpcnk¦cfq"uqp"nqu"eqpvtcvqu"swg"vkgpgp"rqt"qdlgvq"nc"∃3∃Χ/+
0∃+0/&∋∗+∃Υ%.−∗∀8∋∗+∋+ 0∃+∀∆Ι∋#&/3&∃+8/.∋#+≅0∃.∀8∃#4+∋)+∃Υ%.−∗∀8∃+∋#+∋&1∃#+1∀Χ1;8/.−∃+
0/&/Α+*ecvgiqtc"38+6+Gp"gnnqu."gn"rtqxggfqt"rqpg"c"fkurqukek„p"fg"uwu"eqpuwokfqtgu"
wp"tgrqukvqtkq"fg"kphqtocek„p0"Rgtq."gp"guvg"ecuq."nqu"fcvqu"uqp"fg"itcp"xcnqt"rctc"
gn"eqpuwokfqt."{"gn"ceeguq"c"gnnqu"gu"oƒu"korqtvcpvg"swg"nqu"ogfkqu"fg"d¿uswgfc"
q"fg"tgewrgtcek„p"fg"fcvqu"hceknkvcfqu0"Gn"rtqxggfqt"c‚cfg"wp"xcnqt"korqtvcpvg"cn"
eqpvgpkfq"fg"nqu"fcvqu."rgtq"pq"ug"vtcvc"fg"wp"rtqfwevq"rtgrctcfq"rctc"wp"enkgp/
vg"gurgeÞeq."{"pq"jc{"qdnkicek„p" fg"eqpÞfgpekcnkfcf"tgurgevq"fgn"eqpvgpkfq0" Gp"
guvc"ecvgiqtc"ug"rqftcp"kpenwkt"kphqtogu"kpfwuvtkcngu"q"fg"kpxgtuk„p."swg"rwgfgp"
gpxkctug"gngevt„pkecogpvg"c"nqu"uwuetkrvqtgu"q"fguectictug"fg"wp"ecvƒnqiq"∋3.∀3∃0
Gp"guvg"rwpvq."ukiwkgpfq"nc"okuoc"npgc"ctiwogpvcn"wvknk¦cfc"tgurgevq"fg"nc"ecvgiq/
tc"37."nqu"okgodtqu"fgn"VCI"eqpenw{gtqp"swg"nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"rqt"nqu"enkgpvgu"
gp"guvg"ecuq"gpeclcp" gp"gn"ctv" 9"fgn"OE" QEFG."ukp"swg"rwgfc"gpvgpfgtug"swg"ug"
guvƒ"cdqpcpfq"wpc"ewqvc"rqt"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"vf‌iepkequ"≅&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗Α6
Rqt" u w" rct vg." gp " nqu" u wrwg uvqu" f g" /%%∃∗∋+∃.∃%Η3∀%∋+ /+ /∗∃∗∋#/∆∀∃3&∋+Ι#∋)∃∗∀∋3/.++
κ%∋3∗−.&∋#Τ/ϑ+∃&%6κ+≅∃.∃%∋3∀%+/%%∃∗∗+&∋+Ι#∋)∃∗∗∀∋3/.+/08∀%∃Α+*ecvgiqtc"3:+ϑ+nqu"rciqu"
ug"ghgev¿cp"rqt"vgpgt"ceeguq"q"tgekdkt"gn"cuguqtcokgpvq"fg"wp"eqpuwnvqt."cdqicfq."
fqevqt"q" rtqxggfqt" fg"wp"ugtxkekq" rtqhgukqpcn"fc"cuguqtcokgpvq"c" uwu" enkgpvgu"c"
vtcxf‌iu"fg" ∃;∆/∀.."xkfgq/eqphgtgpekc"w" qvtqu"ogfkqu"fg" eqowpkecek„p"tgoqvqu0"Cn"
cpcnk¦ct"guvqu" ecuqu." nqu" okgodtqu"fgn"VCI"gpvgpfkgtqp"rqt"wpcpkokfcf"swg" nqu"
rciqu" tgekdkfqu" fgdgtcp" tgeqpfwektug" cn" ctv0" 9" gp"nwict" fgn" ctv0" 34."fgurwf‌iu" fg"
tgeqpqegt"swg"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"cuguqtcokgpvq"c"fgocpfc"gtc"wp"ugt xkekq"{"pq"wpc"
rtqxkuk„p"fg"π3∋µ;1∋µ0"Cjqtc"dkgp."cn"vtcvctug"fg"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗."gu"rqukdng"swg"gn"
eqpxgpkq"crnkecdng"rtgxgc"wpc"tgvgpek„p"gp"nc"hwgpvg"tgurgevq"fg"guvqu"rciqu0
Nqu"eqpvtcvqu"fg"∃3∃Χ/+0∃+∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3"≅∀3)∋#∆/&∀∋3+0∃.∀8∃#4Α+*ecvgiqtc"42+"eqp/
nngxcp"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"gpxg"fcvqu"gngevt„pkecogpvg"c"uwu"uwuetkrvqtgu."fg"oc/
pgtc"rgtk„fkec."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"uwu"rtghgtgpekcu"rgtuqpcngu0"Gn"rtkpekrcn"xcnqt"rctc"
nqu" enkgpvgu" gu" tgekdkt" kphqtocek„p" gp" wp" rcswgvg" ewuvqok¦cfq." fkug‚cfq" rctc"
uwu"pgegukfcfgu"gurgeÞecu0"C"lwkekq"fgn"VCI."gn"rciq"ucvkuhgejq"fgdg"ecnkÞectug"
eqoq"tgpfkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu0"Rctc"nngict"c"guvc"eqpenwuk„p."gn"eqokvf‌i"gorngc"
gn"okuoq"ctiwogpvq"swg"wvknk¦„"tgurgevq"fg"nc"ecvgiqtc"370"Cu."cwpswg"ug"vtcvc"
45" YGUVKP."T0C0." >3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+ &/Υ/&∀∋3+ ∋)+ ∃.∃%∋3∀%+%∋∆∆∃#%∃ϑ+Ugeqpf" gfkvkqp." Vjg" Pgvjgt/
ncpfur0"4590
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
:6
fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu."pq"guvctcoqu"cpvg"ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepk/
ec."ukgpfq"korqukdng"nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fgn"rciq"eqoq"&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗6
Rqt" qvtq"ncfq." gp" nqu" ecuqu" fg"∗−∗%#∀Ι%∀∋3∃∗+0∃+ /%%∃∗∋+/+ −3/+ΙΓΧ∀3/+µ∃5+ ∀3&∃#/%&∀8/"
*ecvgiqtc"43+."gn"rtqxggfqt"rgtokvg"gn"ceeguq"c"nqu"uwuetkrvqtgu"c"wpc"rƒikpc"µ∃5"gp"
nc"swg"ug"owguvtc"eqpvgpkfq"fkikvcn."kpenw{gpfq"kphqtocek„p."o¿ukec."xkfgqu."lwgiqu"
{"cevkxkfcfgu"*guvf‌ip"q"pq"fgucttqnncfcu"{1q"ugcp"q"pq"rtqrkgfcf"fgn"rtqxggfqt+0"Nqu"
uwuetkrvqtgu"rcicp"wpc"ewqvc"Þlc" rgtk„fkec" rctc"ceegfgt"cn"∗∀&∃." {"gn"xcnqt"rtkpekrcn"
rctc"gnnqu"gu"tgncekqpctug"eqp"gn"ukvkq"okgpvtcu"guvƒp"∋3.∀3∃."ukp"fguectict"rtqfwevqu0"
Rwgu"dkgp."guvc"uwuetkrek„p"qtkikpctc"gn"rciq"c"ecodkq"fg"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxk/
ekqu."cwpswg"pq"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepkec0"Nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc."gp"eqpugewgp/
ekc."fgdg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"tgpfkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu0" Ukp"godctiq."gn"rciq"swg"
tgcnk¦c"gn"rtqxggfqt"cn"rtqrkgvctkq"fg"nqu"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"kpvcpikdngu"
swg"kpenw{g"gp"uw"rƒikpc"µ∃5"rqftc"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗ϑ+uk"ug"gpvkgpfg"swg"gp"
uw"µ∃5∗∀&∃+ug"guvƒ"tgrtqfwekgpfq"gug"eqpvgpkfq"rtqvgikfq"rqt"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt"{"
ug"eqdtcp"ewqvcu"c"nqu"uwuetkrvqtgu"rqt"ceegfgt"c"guqu"eqpvgpkfqu0
Ncu" ecpvkfcfgu" swg" ucvkuhcegp" nqu" eqogtekcpvgu" swg" xgpfgp" uwu" rtqfwevqu" gp"
Ι∋#&/.∃∗+0∃+%∋∆Ι#/+∋3.∀3∃*ecvgiqtc"44++cn"qrgtcfqt"fgn"ukvkq"µ∃5"c" vtcxf‌iu" fgn"
swg"xgpfgp"uwu"rtqfwevqu"fgdgp" ecnkÞectug." c" lwkekq" fgn" VCI."eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"
gortguctkcngu0"Gp" guvg" uwrwguvq." gn" qrgtcfqt" qhtgeg"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"uw"rƒikpc"µ∃5+
{"uwu"ugtxkfqtgu"ecvƒnqiqu"gngevt„pkequ"fg"xctkqu"eqogtekcpvgu0"Nqu"wuwctkqu"fgn"
µ∃5∗∀&∃" rwgfgp" ugngeekqpct" nqu" rtqfwevqu" fg" nqu" ecvƒnqiqu" {" eqortctnqu" ∋3.∀;
3∃0"Gn"qrgtcfqt"fgn" µ∃5∗∀&∃" pq" vkgpg" tgncek„p" eqpvtcevwcn" eqp" nqu" eqortcfqtgu="
ukorngogpvg"vtcpuokvg"ncu"„tfgpgu"c"nqu"eqogtekcpvgu."swg"uqp"tgurqpucdngu"fg"
cegrvct"{"ewornkt"eqp"gn"gpxq0"Nqu"eqogtekcpvgu"rcicp"cn"qrgtcfqt"fgn"µ∃5∗∀&∃"
wpc"eqokuk„p"kiwcn"cn"rqtegpvclg"fg"rgfkfqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"uw"rƒikpc"µ∃56
Gp"wp"ugpvkfq"ukoknct."nc"eqokuk„p"fg"xgpvcu"swg"ucvkuhceg"wp"xgpfgfqt"qpnkpg"cn"
rtqxggfqt"fg"wpc"ygd"fg"∗−5/∗&/∗+∋3.∀3∃+*ecvgiqtc"45++gu"ecnkÞecfc" eqoq"dg/
pgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0"Pqu"gpeqpvtcoqu"cpvg"uwrwguvqu"gp"nqu"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"
owguvtc"xctkqu"qdlgvqu"rctc"swg"nqu"wuwctkqu"rwgfcp"cfswktktnqu"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"uw/
dcuvc0"Gn"wuwctkq"cfswkgtg"nqu"qdlgvqu"fktgevcogpvg"fgn"rtqrkgvctkq."{"gn"xgpfgfqt"
eqorgpuc"cn"rtqxggfqt"eqp"wp"rqtegpvclg"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"q"eqp"wpc"ewqvc"Þlc0"Rqt"
guvg"oqvkxq." nc" ecnkÞecek„p"qvqticfc"c"guvqu" rciqu"pq"rwgfg"ugt"qvtc" oƒu" swg"
dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
Rqt" u w" rct vg." gp " nqu" Ι#∋Χ#/∆/∗+ 0∃+ #∃)∃#∃3%∀/∗+0∃+ 8∃3&/∗"≅∗/.∃∗+#∃)∃##/.+Ι#∋Χ#/∆∗Α+
*ecvgiqtc"46+ϑ+wp"rtqxggfqt"∋3.∀3∃"rcic"wpc"eqokuk„p"fg"xgpvcu"cn"qrgtcfqt"fg"wp"
ukvkq"µ∃5ϑ"swg"tgeqokgpfc"uwu"rtqfwevqu"q"ugtxkekqu0"Gn"qrgtcfqt"fgn"µ∃5∗∀&∃"kpenwk/
tƒ"wpq"q"oƒu"rtqfwevqu"fgn"rtqxggfqt"gp"uw"rƒikpc"µ∃50"Uk"wp"wuwctkq"ugngeekqpc"q"
ÑrkpejcÒ"uqdtg"wpq"fg"guqu"rtqfwevqu."ugtƒ"tgfktkikfq"c"nc"µ∃5"fgn"rtqxggfqt."fgu/
fg"nc"swg"rqftƒ"eqortct"gn"rtqfwevq0"Ewcpfq"gn".∀3π"gp"nc"µ∃5"fgn"qrgtcfqt"ug"wuc."
gn"rtqxggfqt"rwgfg"kfgpvkÞect"nc"hwgpvg"fg"ncu"xgpvcu."{"ng"rcictƒ"cn"qrgtcfqt"fg"nc"
rƒikpc"wpc"eqokuk„p"rqtegpvwcn"uk"gn"wuwctkq"Þpcnogpvg"eqortc"gn"rtqfwevq0"Rwgu"
dkgp."nqu"rciqu+ghgevwcfqu"rqt"gn"rtqxggfqt"qpnkpg"cn"qrgtcfqt"fg"wp"ukvkq"µ∃5"swg"
tgeqokgpfc"uwu"rtqfwevqu"q"ugtxkekqu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"rtqitcocu"fg"tghgtgpekcu"fg"
xgpvcu"ug"ecnkÞecp"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP:7
C"uw"xg¦."gp"ncu"/3∗/%%∀∋3∃∗+Ρ−∃+∀3%.−4∃3+−3/+/0Ρ−∀∗∀%∀Η3+0∃+%∋3&∃3∀0∋∗"≅%∋3&∃3&+
/%Ρ−∀∗∀&∀∋3+/3∗/%&∀∋3∗Α+*ecvgiqtc"47+.+wp"qrgtcfqt"fg"rƒikpc"µ∃5"rcic"c"xctkqu"
rtqxggfqtgu" fg" eqpvgpkfq" rqt" pwgxcu"jkuvqtkcu." kphqtocek„p" {" qvtq" e qpvgpkfq"
∋3.∀3∃."rctc"cvtcgt"wuwctkqu" c"uw"µ∃50"Cnvgtpcvkxcogpvg."gn"qrgtcfqt"fgn" µ∃5∗∀&∃"
fgdg"eqpvtcvct"c"wp"rtqxggfqt"fg"eqpvgpkfq"rctc"etgct"pwgxq"eqpvgpkfq"gurge/
Þeq"rctc"uw"µ∃5∗∀&∃6+Gp"guvqu"uwrwguvqu."gn"VCI"eqpukfgtc"swg."cn"vtcvctug"fg"wp"
eqpvtcvq"okzvq."jc{"swg"ugrctct"ncu"fkhgtgpvgu"rtguvcekqpgucpfq"gn"qrgtcfqt"
fgn"ukvkq"µ∃5"rcic"c"wp"rtqxggfqt"fg"eqpvgpkfq"rqt"gn"fgtgejq"c"gzjkdkt"ocvgtkcn"
rtqvgikfq"rqt"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt."gn"rciq"rwgfg"gpvtct"gp"nc"fgÞpkek„p"fg"#∋4/.;
&∀∃∗0"Ukp"godctiq."ewcpfq"gn"qrgtcfqt"rcic"rqt"nc"etgcek„p"fg"pwgxq"eqpvgpkfq"
{." eq oq" t guwn vcfq " fgn" c ewg tfq" e qpvt cevw cn. "u g" xw gnxg " rtqr kgvc tkq" fgn" %∋Ι4#∀Χ1&"
uqdtg"gn"eqpvgpkfq"etgcfq."gn" rciq"pq"gu"ecnkÞecdng" eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗." ukpq"swg" ug"
kpectfkpc"gp"gn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG0
Gp"gn"ecuq"fg"∃∆∀∗∀∋3∃∗+/3∗∆∀&∀0/∗+κ∃3+&∀∃∆Ι∋+#∃/.κ+Ρ−∃+∗∋3+/%%∃∗∀5.∃∗+/+/8Φ∗+
0∃+−3/+#∃0+0∀Χ∀&/."≅∗∃/∆∃0+κ#∃/.+&∀∆∃κ+µ∃5+5/∗∃+5#∋/0%/∗&∀3ΧΑ"*ecvgiqtc"48+."gn"
wuwctkq"ceegfg"c"dcugu" fg"fcvqu"swg"eqpvkgpgp"ocvgtkcn" xkuwcn"q"fg"cwfkq"rtq/
vgikfq"rqt"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt"q"%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&0"["swkgp"gokvg."tgekdg"wpc"uwuetkrek„p"
q"kpitguqu"rwdnkekvctkqu0" Gp" guvg" ecuq." gn" VCI"eqpenw{g" swg" nc" uwuetkrek„p" q" nqu"
kpitguqu"rwdnkekvctkqu"uqp"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"{"fgdgtƒp"tgeqpfwektug"cn"ctv0"
9"fgn"OE"QEFG0
Hkpcnogpvg."gn"kphqtog"cpcnk¦c"gn"uwrwguvq"fg"ncu"fgpqokpcfcu+%/##∀/Χ∃+)∃∃∗"*ec/
vgiqtc"49+."guvq"gu."rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"rqt"wp"rtqxggfqt"fg" eqpvgpkfq"c"wp" ukvkq"
µ∃5"q"c"wp"qrgtcfqt"fg"tgfgu"rctc"oquvtct"uw"eqpvgpkfq"gp"gn"qrgtcfqt"fg"
3∃&µ∋#π"q"gp"gn"ukvkq∃56+Gn"VCI"eqpukfgtc"swg."gp"guvqu" ecuqu."gn"µ∃5∗∀&∃"q"gn"
qrgtcfqt"fg"3∃&µ∋#π"guvƒ"rtguvcpfq"wp"ugtxkekq"eqogtekcn"c"ecodkq"fgn"rciq"fg"
wpc"ewqvc." {" guc"tgpvc"fgdgtc"ecnkÞectug" eqoq" tgpfkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu"fgn"
ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG0"Gp"guvqu"ecuqu."gu"gn"rtqrkgvctkq"fgn"ocvgtkcn"rtqvgikfq"rqt"
fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt"q"%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&"gn"swg"jceg"gn"rciq."nq"swg"fglc"dkgp"enctq"swg"gn"
ctv0"34"fgn"OE"QEFG"pq"gu"crnkecdng0
Rwgu"dkgp."uk"guvcu" uqp"ncu"eqpenwukqpgu" xgtvkfcu"gp"gn"kphqtog"fgn"VCI"fg"4223"
{." gp" fpkvkxc."ncu" fg" nc" QEFG."jc{" swg"rtgekuct" swg" nc " kp vtqfweek„p"fgn"pwgxq"
ctvewnq"uqdtg"ugtxkekqu"vf‌iepkequ"gp"gn"OE"QPW"fg"4239"*ctv0"34C+"ug"ugrctc"
fg"ncu"tgincu"fg"fkuvtkdwek„p"fgn"rqfgt"vtkdwvctkq"gzkuvgpvgu"jcuvc"gn"oqogpvq"{."cn"
okuoq"vkgorq."vtcg"eqpukiq"ecodkqu"uwuvcpekcngu"gp"ncu"tgincu"uqdtg"ecnkÞecek„p"
fg"tgpvcu0"Guvg"rtgegrvq"rgtokvg"cn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"glgtegt"wpc"tgvgpek„p"gp"
nc"hwgpvg"uqdtg"nqu"rciqu"tgncekqpcfqu"eqp"fgvgtokpcfqu"ugtxkekqu"vf‌iepkequ."uk"ncu"
ecpvkfcfgu"uqp" ucvkuhgejcu" rqt" wp" tgukfgpvg"fg"gug" okuoq" Guvcfq"q"rqt"wp"pq"
tgukfgpvg" swg"vgpic" wp"GR"gp"gug"vgttkvqtkq." {"nc"tgpvc"ugc"cvtkdwkdng"c"gug"GR0"Nc"
rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu" gp"qvtq"Guvcfq" eqpvtcvcpvg"c"vtcxf‌iu" fg"ogfkqu"fkikvcngu"
rqftc"eqpukfgtctug."rqt"u"okuoc."uwÞekgpvg."eqpuvkvw{gpfq"wp"pgzq"swg"rgtok/
vktc"itcxct"nc"tgpvc"gp"guc"lwtkufkeek„p"46 0"
46" EQOKV¡"FG" NCU" PCEKQPGU" WPKFCU."ÑVjg" vczcvkqp"qh"hggu" hqt" vgejpkecn." ocpcigtkcn"cpf"
eqpuwnvcpe{"ugtxkegu"kp"vjg"fkikvcn"geqpqo{"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"Ctv0"34C"qh"vjg"4239"WP"OqfgnÒ."2∀)&∃∃3&1+
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
:8
Eqp"guvc" rtgxkuk„p" ug" rtgvgpfg"eqodcvkt"nc"gtquk„p" fg" dcugu" {"vtcuncfq"fg"dg/
pgÞekqu"swg"ug" rtqfweg" gp" gn" Guvcfq" fg" nc" hwgpvg" c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"nc"fgfweek„p"fg"
ncu"ecpvkfcfgu" rcicfcu" c"gortgucu"pq"tgukfgpvgu" swg" rtguvcp"ugtxkekqu" gp"wpc"
fgvgtokpcfc"lwtkufkeek„p"47 0"Eqoq"ug"ucdg."nqu"rcugu"gp"xcu"fg"fgucttqnnq"uqp"ko/
rqtvcfqtgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepkec."fg"iguvk„p"{"fg"eqpuwnvqtc0"Jcuvc"
gn"oqogpvq."nqu"rciqu"rqt"guvg"vkrq"fg"ugtxkekqu"rqfcp"wvknk¦ctug"rctc"vtcuncfct"
dgpgÞekqu"fgufg" wpc"gortguc"kpvgitcpvg"fgn"itwrq"nqecnk¦cfc" gp"gn"Guvcfq" fgn"
rcicfqt"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"jcekc"qvtc"gpvkfcf"kpvgitcpvg"fgn"itwrq"nqecnk¦cfc"gp"wpc"
lwtkufkeek„p"fg"dclc"vtkdwvcek„p0"Gn"rcicfqt"rqfc"fgfwekt"gn"rciq"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"
nc"hwgpvg."tgfwekgpfq"fg"guvg"oqfq"uw"dcug"korqpkdng0"["nc"gpvkfcf"tgegrvqtc"fgn"
rciq"kpetgogpvcdc"uwu"dgpgÞekqu."swg"guvctcp"uwlgvqu"c"dclc"q"pwnc"vtkdwvcek„p0"
Gn"pwgxq"Ctvewnq"34C"eqpvtkdwktƒ"c"eqodcvkt"guvg"rtqdngoc."rgtokvkgpfq"swg"gn"
Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"qrgtg"wpc"tgvgpek„p"uqdtg"nqu"rciqu"rqt"ugtxkekqu"c"nqu"swg"
ug"tgÞgtg"gn"rtgegrvq."guvq"gu."ugtxkekqu"swg"tgswkgtcp"nc"crnkecek„p"fg"wp"eqpqek/
okgpvq"gurgekcnk¦cfq."jcdknkfcf"q"fguvtg¦c"rqt"rctvg"fgn"rtqxggfqt."gzenw{gpfq"
rqt"vcpvq"vctgcu"fg"ugtxkekq"twvkpctkcu"q"ugtxkekqu"guvcpfctk¦cfqu0
Eqp"vqfq."gn"Ctvewnq" 34C" OE" QPW"pq"guvƒ" rgpucfq" rctc" cdqtfct" fg" ocpgtc"
gurgeÞec" nqu" rtqdngocu" fg" gtquk„p" fg" nc" dcug" {" vtcuncfq" fg" dgpgÞekqu" gp" gn"
eqpvgzvq"fg" nc" geqpqoc" fkikvcn." rgtq" nq" ekgtvq" gu" swg" rwgfg" nngict" c" lwict" wp"
rcrgn"korqtvcpvg"c"nc"jqtc"fg"eqodcvkt"fgvgtokpcfqu"ecuqu"fg"gnwuk„p"Þuecn"gp"
gn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fg"ogfkqu"fkikvcngu0"
Gp"vqfq"ecuq."rctc"gxkvct"rtqdngocu"fg"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu" tgpvcu."gurgekcnogpvg"
nqu"tgncekqpcfqu"eqp"qvtqu"rtgegrvqu"eqoq"nqu"tgncvkxqu"cn"itcxcogp"fg"tq{cnvkgu."
dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"q"nc"enƒwuwnc"fg"GR"fg"ugtxkekqu."{"eqp"gn"qdlgvq"fg"ucn/
xciwctfct"gn"rtkpekrkq"fg"pgwvtcnkfcf."ugtc"ceqpuglcdng"swg"gn"pwgxq"ctvewnq"34C"
OE"QPW"gnkokpcug"nc"tghgtgpekc"c"ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"Ñvf‌iepkec."fg" iguvk„p"q"
eqpuwnvqtcÒ."fg"ocpgtc"swg"gn"pwgxq"rtgegrvq"rwfkgtc"crnkectug"c"ewcnswkgt"vkrq"
fg"ugtxkekqu"rtguvcfqu0"
X0" D GPG H K E KQU"GOR T G U CTK C N G U
Gn"kphqtog"fgn"VCI"fg"nc"QEFG"fg"4223"eqpenw{g"swg"nc"oc{qtc"fg"rciqu"tgcnk/
¦cfqu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu"fgdgp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"
gortguctkcngu"{."rqt"nq"vcpvq."tgeqpfwektug"cn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG."ukgpfq"gxgpvwcn"
nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"nqu"okuoqu"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0
Fg"guvc" ocpgtc." gn"VCI"gzcokp„"gn" uwrwguvq" fg"ncu"Η#0∃3∃∗+∃)∃%&−/0/∗+ ∃.∃%Η;
3∀%/∆∃3&∃+Ι∃#∋+Ρ−∃+&∀∃3∃3+Ι∋#+∋5Π∃&∋+5∀∃3∃∗+∋+Ι#∋0−%&∋∗+&/3Χ∀5.∃∗"*ecvgiqtc"3+0"
∗∃∗∗∀∋3ϑ+ 9Χ∃30/ + ∀&∃∆+ ε≅%Α≅∀ΥΑβ+ ,/Υ+ %∋3∗∃Ρ−∃3%∃∗+ ∋)+ &1 ∃+ 0∀Χ∀&/.∀Σ∃0+ ∃%∋3∋∆46" *Eqookvvgg" qh" Gzrgtvu"
G1E03:142391ETR045"/"32"Qevqdgt"4239+
47" EQOKV¡"FG"NCU"PCEKQPGU"WPKFCU."ÑTgxkugf"Eqoogpvct{"qp"Ctvkeng"34C"/"hggu"hqt"vgejpk/
ecn"ugtxkeguÒ."2∋−#&∃∃3&1+∗∃∗∗∀∋3ϑ+9Χ∃30/+∀&∃∆+Ν≅/Αβ+>∗∗−∃∗+#∃./&∃0+&∋+&1∃+−Ι0/&∀3Χ+∋)+&1∃+73∀&∃0+Κ/&∀∋3∗+
=∋0∃.+!∋−5.∃+,/Υ/&∀∋3+:∋38∃3&∀∋3+5∃&µ∃∃3+ !∃8∃.∋Ι∃0+/30+!∃8∃.∋Ι∀3Χ+:∋−3∀∃∗6"*Eqookvvgg"qh"Gz/
rgtvu"G1E"3:142391ETR03"Octej"4239+
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP:9
Gp"guvg"ecuq."gn"enkgpvg"ugngeekqpc"wp"ctvewnq" fg" wp" ecvƒnqiq" ∋3.∀3∃" fg" dkgpgu"
vcpikdngu."{"jceg"wp"rgfkfq"gngevt„pkeq"c"wp"rtqxggfqt"eqogtekcn0"Gp"guvqu"ecuqu."
gn"enkgpvg" pq"vkgpg"swg"ucvkuhcegt"wpc" ecpvkfcf" cfkekqpcn"{"ugrctcfc"rqt" wuct"gn"
ecvƒnqiq"∋3.∀3∃."{"nc"ocpgtc"gp"swg"tgekdg"gn"rtqfwevq"gu"nc"qtfkpctkc"*eqttgq"rqu/
vcn"q"ugtxkekq"fg"ogpuclgtc+0"Gn"VCI"gpvgpfk„"swg"f‌iuvg"gtc"oƒu"dkgp"wp"uwrwguvq"
tgeqpfwekdng"cn" ctv0" 9" fgn" OE" QEFG" *dgpgÞekqu" gortguctkcngu+." cpvgu" swg" wpc"
ukvwcek„p"swg"ug"rwgfc"gpoctect"gp"gn"ctv0"34"*#∋4/.&∀∃∗+."rqtswg"pq"gpvtc‚cdc"gn"
wuq"fg"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt0
C"uw" xg¦."gn"VCI"vcodkf‌ip"cpcnk¦„" gn"vtcvcokgpvq"lwtfkeq/vtkdwvctkq" fg"nqu"Ι/Χ∋∗+
Ρ−∃+ ∃)∃%&α/+ −3+ −∗−/#∀∋+ %−/30∋+ #∃/.∀Σ/+ −3/+ ∋#0∃3+ ∃.∃%Η3∀%/+ 4+ 0∃∗%/#Χ/+ ∃3+ ∗−+
∋#0∃3/0∋#+Ι#∋0−%&∋∗+ 0∀Χ∀&/.∃∗+ *ecvgiqtc" 4+0" Gp"guvg" rwpvq." gn" VCI"gzcokp„" ncu"
fkhgtgpekcu"gpvtg"nqu"#∋4/.&∀∃∗+{"nqu"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"{"eqpenw{„"swg."gp"gn"
ecuq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu" swg"rgtokvgp"cn"enkgpvg"fguectictug"fg"oqfq"gngevt„pkeq"
rtqfwevqu"fkikvcnk¦cfqu"*eqoq"∗∋)&µ/#∃."koƒigpgu."uqpkfqu"q"vgzvq+"rctc"uw"rtq/
rkq"wuq" q"fkuhtwvg."gn" rciq"ug"tgcnk¦c"rctc"cfswktkt"fcvqu"vtcpuokvkfqu"gp" hqtoc"
fg"ug‚cn"fkikvcn0"[."uk"guc" eqpuvkvw{g"nc"eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"gugpekcn" gp"gn"rciq."gp/
vqpegu"fkejcu"ecpvkfcfgu"pq"rwgfgp"ugt"eqpukfgtcfcu"eqoq"#∋4/.&∀∃∗."rqtswg"pq"
ug"tgcnk¦c"gn"rciq"rctc"wuct"wp"dkgp"rtqvgikfq"rqt"fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt"q"%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&0"
Eqoq"ug"fklq"cpvgtkqtogpvg."gn"jgejq"fg"eqrkct"nc"ug‚cn"fkikvcn"gp"gn"fkueq"fwtq"
fgn"enkgpvg" q" gp"qvtqu"ogecpkuoqu"eqpuvkvw{g" gn" wuq" fg"%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&." rgtq" guvq"ug"
eqpukfgtc"wpc" rctvg" kpekfgpvcn" fgn" rtqeguq"fg"ecrvwtc"{" cnocegpcokgpvq" fg"nc"
ug‚cn"fkikvcn0"Ukiwkgpfq"gp"nc"npgc"fg"ncu"Ñtgincu"fg"tgngxcpekcÒ"hqtowncfcu"rqt"nc"
QEFG."gp"nc"ogfkfc"gp"swg"guvc"rctvg"kpekfgpvcn"pq"gu"tgngxcpvg"rctc"nc"ecnkÞec/
ek„p"Ïrqtswg"pq"ug"kfgpvkÞec"eqp"nc"rtguvcek„p"gugpekcn."{c"swg"csw"nc"rtguvcek„p"
rtkpekrcn"gu"nc"cfswkukek„p"fg"fcvqu"vtcpuokvkfqu"gp"hqtoc"fg"ug‚cn"fkikvcnÏ."pq"ug"
rwgfg"kpvgitct"gp"nc"fgÞpkek„p"fg"#∋4/.&∀∃∗0
Cjqtc"dkgp."fkuvkpvq"gu"gn"uwrwguvq"gp"gn"swg"gn"wuwctkq"tgcnk¦c"wpc"∋#0∃3+∃.∃%Η;
3∀%/+4+0∃∗%/#Χ/+∃3+∗−+∋#0∃3/0∋#+Ι#∋0−%&∋∗+0∀Χ∀&/.∃∗ϑ+Ι∃#∋+.∋+1/%∃+%∋3+./+Þ3/.∀0/0+
0∃+∃ΥΙ.∋&/#+.∋∗+0∃#∃%1∋∗+0∃+/−&∋#+∋+%∋Ι4#∀Χ1&+*ecvgiqtc"5+ϑ+Wpc"xg¦"oƒu."gn"enkgpvg"
ugngeekqpc"wp"rtqfwevq"fg"wp"ecvƒnqiq"∋3.∀3∃"fg"∗∋)&µ/#"w"qvtqu"rtqfwevqu"fkik/
vcngu."{"nq"cfswkgtg"fg"wp"rtqxggfqt"eqogtekcn"wvknk¦cpfq"ogfkqu"gngevt„pkequ0"Gp"
guvg"ecuq."gn"wuwctkq"pq"rcic"pkpiwpc"ecpvkfcf"cfkekqpcn"q"ugrctcfc"rqt"jcdgtnq"
eqortcfq"c"vtcxf‌iu"fgn"ecvƒnqiq"∋3.∀3∃0"Gn"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"ug"fguectic"gp"gn"fkueq"
fwtq"fgn"enkgpvg."q"gp"qvtqu"ctejkxqu"pq"vgorqtcngu."{"f‌iuvg"cfswkgtg"gn"fgtgejq"c"
gzrnqvct"eqogtekcnogpvg"gn"fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt"swg"rtqvgig"cn"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn0"Gn"
VCI"eqpukfgt„."rqt"wpcpkokfcf"fg"uwu"okgodtqu."swg"gn"rciq" fgdc"ecnkÞectug"
eqoq"#∋4/.&40"Cfgoƒu."gp"guvg"ecuq."gn"rciq"ug"jceg"gp"eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"rqt"gn"
fgtgejq"c"wuct"gn"fgtgejq"fg"cwvqt"fgn"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn0
Rqt"nq"swg"jceg"c"nqu"uwrwguvqu"fg"−Ι0/&∃∗+{"/00;∋3∗+*ecvgiqtc"6+.+gn"rtqxggfqt"
fgn"∗∋)&µ/#∃"q"fg"qvtq"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"ug"qdnkic"c"rtqxggt"cn"enkgpvg"eqp"cevwc/
nk¦cekqpgu"{1q" cfkekqpgu" fgn" rtqfwevq" fkikvcn"cfswktkfq0" Gp" guvqu" ecuqu." gn"VCI"
gpvkgpfg"swg."uk"ncu"cevwcnk¦cekqpgu"{1q"cfkekqpgu"ug"tgekdgp"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"wp"ogfkq"
vcpikdng."guvctcoqu" cpvg"wpc"xgpvc" fg"dkgpgu"swg"gpeclc" gp"nc"ecvgiqtc"3" fgn"
kphqtog0"Rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."uk"nqu"−Ι0/&∃∗+{"/00;∋3∗"ug"tgekdgp"gngevt„pkecogpvg."gn"
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
::
VCI"eqp ukfg tc"sw g"ug"vt cvc "f g"wpc "x gpv c"fg"rt qfw evqu"fkik vcn k¦cfqu"swg"gpeclc"gp"
nc"ecvgiqtc"4"fgn"kphqtog0"Gp"ewcnswkgtc"fg"nqu"fqu"uwrwguvqu."nqu"rciqu"tgekdkfqu"
jcdtƒp"fg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
Rqt"uw"rctvg."gp"nqu"uwrwguvqu"fg"cfswkukek„p"rqt"ogfkqu"gngevt„pkequ"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃+
0∃+0−#/%∀Η3+.∀∆∀&/0/+ 4+ ∋/∗+ .∀%∃3%∀/∗+ 0∃+ ∀3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+0∀Χ∀&/.∃∗+≅.∀∆∀&∃0+ 0−#/&∀∋3+
∗∋)&µ/#∃+ /30+∋&1∃#+ 0∀Χ∀&/.+∀3)∋#∆/&∀∋3+.∀%∃3∗∃∗Α+ *ecvgiqtc" 7+." gn"enkgpvg"tgekdg" gn"
fgtgejq"c" wuct" ∗∋)&µ/#∃"w"qvtqu"rtqfwevqu" fkikvcngu" rqt" wp" rgtkqfq" fg"vkgorq"
swg"gu"ogpqt"fgn"vkgorq"fg"xkfc"¿vkn"fgn"rtqfwevq0"Gn"rtqfwevq"ug"fguectic"gnge/
vt„pkecogpvg"q"ug"gpvtgic"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"wp"ogfkq"vcpikdng."eqoq"rwgfg"ugt"wp"EF0"
["vqfcu"ncu"eqrkcu"fgn"rtqfwevq"fkikvcn"ug"dqttcp"q"ug"xwgnxgp"kpugtxkdngu"fgurwf‌iu"
fg"swg"gzrktg"nc"nkegpekc0"Gp"guvqu"ecuqu."gn"VCI"gpvgpfk„"swg"nqu"rciqu"ghgevwc/
fqu"rqt"guvg"eqpegrvq"fgdcp"ektewpuetkdktug"cn"rtgegrvq"tgncvkxq"c"nqu"dgpgÞekqu"
gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9"OE"QEFG+."tgeqpfwekf‌ipfqnqu"dkgp"c"nc"ecvgiqtc"3"q"c"nc"
ecvgiqtc"40"G."kpenwuq"gp"gn"ecuq"fg"swg"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"kpenw{gug"gp"gn"ctvewnq"
tgncvkxq"c"nqu"#∋4/.&∀∃∗"nqu"rciqu"ghgevwcfqu"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eq/
ogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞequ."guvqu"tgpfkokgpvqu"pq"fgdgtcp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"tgicncu0"
Gp"nqu"uwrwguvqu"fg+−∗∋+α3∀%∋ +0∃ +∗∋)&µ/#∃+∋+0∃+∋& #∋∗+Ι#∋0−%&∋∗+0∀Χ∀&/. ∃∗"≅∗∀3Χ.∃;−∗∃+
∗∋)&µ/#∃+∋#+∋&1∃#+0∀Χ∀&/.+Ι#∋0−%&∗Α+*ecvgiqtc"8+."gn"wuwctkq"tgekdg"gn"fgtgejq"c"wuct"
∗∋)&µ/#∃" w" qvtqu" rtqfwevqu" fkikvcngu." rgtq" u„nq" rqt"wpc"¿pkec" xg¦0" Gn" rtqfwevq"
rwgfg"ugt"fguecticfq"q"wucfq" fg"ocpgtc" tgoqvc."{"gn"wuwctkq"pq"tgekdg"gn"fg/
tgejq" c" jcegt"eqrkcu" fgn"rtqfwevq" fkikvcn." ukpq"swg"ukorngogpvg"rwgfg" wuct"gn"
rtqfwevq"fkikvcn" rctc" uw" eqpuwoq0" Gn" kphqtog"fgn"VCI"rqpg"fg"ocpkÞguvq"swg"
cniwpqu"okgodtqu"fgn"eqokvf‌i"vwxkgtqp"fwfcu"uqdtg"uk"ug"vtcvcdc"fg"wp"eqpvtcvq"
fg"ugtxkekqu."wpc" xgpvc"fg"rtqfwevqu"fkikvcnk¦cfqu"*vtcpuceekqpgu"tgeqpfwekdngu"
c"nc"ecvgiqtc"4+"q"wp"wuq"¿pkeq"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃"q"rtqfwevqu"fkikvcngu"*vtcpuceekqpgu"
tgeqpfwekdngu"c"nc"ecvgiqtc"3+0" Pquqvtqu"gpvgpfgoqu"swg" pq"gu"wpc"fkuewuk„p"
fgvgtokpcpvg."rwguvq"swg."gp"vqfq"ecuq."guvqu"rciqu"ecgp"fgpvtq"fg"nc"„tdkvc"fg"
nqu"tgpfkokgpvqu"gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG+."{"vqfq"nq"swg"ugc"kpvgpvct"
tgcnk¦ct"uwd/encukÞecekqpgu"gu"rqeq"qrgtcvkxq"c"nqu"ghgevqu"fg"tgcnk¦ct"wpc"ecnkÞ/
ecek„p"lwtfkeq/vtkdwvctkc"fg"nc"tgpvc."rwguvq"swg"vqfcu"ncu"ecvgiqtcu"pqu"nngxcp"
cn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG0
Rqt" uw"rctvg."ncu" 9Ε(+.∀%∃3%∃+)∃∃∗+*ecvgiqtc"32+ϑ+uqp"ecpvkfcfgu"cdqpcfcu"rqt"gn"
rtqxggfqt" fg" ugtxkekqu" fg" crnkecekqpgu" *CUR+" cn" rtqxggfqt" fg" crnkecekqpgu" fg"
∗∋)&µ/#∃."swg"pqtocnogpvg"ugtƒp"wp"rqtegpvclg"fg"nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"rqt"uwu"
enkgpvgu0"Gp"guvg"rwpvq."gn"VCI"rtgekuc"swg."cn"vtcvctug"fg"ecpvkfcfgu"swg"ug"cdq/
pcp"gp" eqpvtcrtguvcek„p" rqt" nc" rtqxkuk„p"fg"wp"rtqfwevq"fg" ∗∋)&µ/#∃"swg"xc"c"
wvknk¦ctug"guvtkevcogpvg" gp" gn"pgiqekq"fgn"tgegrvqt."nqu"rciqu" jcp"fg"ecnkÞectug"
eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
Kiwcnogpvg."ug"cpcnk¦ctqp"nqu"rciqu"rqt" rwdnkekfcf" gp" nc" Tgf" ≅/08∃#&∀∗∀3ΧΑ+*ec/
vgiqtc"39+"swg"ucvkuhceg"gn"cpwpekcpvg"rctc"swg"ug"owguvtgp"uwu"cpwpekqu"c"nqu"
wuwctkqu"fg"wp" µ∃5∗∀&∃." c" vtcxf‌iu" fg" nqu" eqpqekfqu" eqoq" 5/33∃#;/0∗"*rgswg‚cu"
koƒigpgu" itƒÞecu" gp" wpc" µ∃5." swg" ewcpfq" ug" ugngeekqpcp" q" ug" rkpejc" uqdtg"
gnncu."ecticp"nc"rƒikpc"swg"rtgxkcogpvg"gn"cpwpekcpvg"jc"gurgekÞecfq+0"Ncu"ewq/
vcu"rqt"cpwpekctug"ug"uwgngp" gurgekÞect"gp"hwpek„p" fg"ncu"xgegu"swg"gn" cpwpekq"
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP:;
ug"owguvtc"cn"wuwctkq."cwpswg"c"xgegu"vcodkf‌ip"ug"rwgfgp"dcuct"gp"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"
Ñ%.∀%π;&1#∋−Χ1∗Ò"swg" tgcnk¦c" gn"wuwctkq0"Gp"guvqu"ecuqu."gn"VCI"eqpenw{„"swg"nqu"
rciqu"fgdgp"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu"*ctv0"9+0
Hkpcnogpvg."nc"ewqvc"fg"uwuetkrek„p"c"wpc"rƒikpc"µ∃5"gp"nc"swg"ug"rgtokvc"nc"fgu/
ectic"fg"rtqfwevqu"fkikvcngu"*∗−5∗%#∀Ι&∀∋3+&∋+/+µ∃5∗∀&∃+/..∋µ∀3Χ+&1∃+0∋µ3.∋/0∀3Χ+
∋)+0∀Χ∀&/.+Ι#∋0−%&∗Α+ *ecvgiqtc"4:+"gpeclc"gp"gn"ctv0"9"fgn"OE"QEFG0"Gp"guvg"ecuq."
gn"rtqxggfqt"rgtokvg"gn"ceeguq"c"nqu"uwuetkrvqtgu"c"wpc" rƒikpc"µ∃5." oquvtcpfq"
eqpvgpkfq" fkikvcn" rtqvgikfq" rqt" fgtgejqu" fg" cwvqt"*rqt" glgornq." o¿ukec+0" Nqu"
uwuetkrvqtgu"rcicp"wpc"ewqvc" Þlc"rgtk„fkec"rqt"ceegfgt" cn"ukvkq"µ∃5"{" gn"rtkpek/
rcn" xcnqt" fg" nc" µ∃5"rctc"nqu"uwuetkrvqtgu"gu" nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"fguectictug"guqu"
rtqfwevqu"fkikvcngu0"Fg"guvg"oqfq."nqu"rciqu"tgekdkfqu"ug"ecnkÞecp"eqoq"dgpgÞ/
ekqu"gortguctkcngu"rqtswg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"swg"rgtokvgp"cn"enkgpvg"fguectictug"
gngevt„pkecogpvg"rtqfwevqu"fkikvcngu"*rqt"glgornq."o¿ukec+"rctc"uw"rtqrkq"wuq"{"
fkuhtwvg."pq"rwgfgp"qtkikpct"gn"rciq"fg"tgicncu0
XK0" ECVGIQTìCU"PQ"KPENWKFCU"GP"GN"KPHQTOG"FGN"VCI"FG"
4223KEKQU"FG"EQORWVCEKðP"GP"NC"PWDG"["RCIQU"RQT"
KORTGUKðP"GP"5F
Gn"qtkigp"fg"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqorwvcek„p" gp"nc"pwdg"≅%.∋−0+%∋∆Ι−&∀3ΧΑ"ug"tg/
oqpvc" c" nqu" c‚qu" ugugpvc." ewcpfq" nqu" rtqxggfqtgu" fg" qtfgpcfqtgu" egpvtcngu"
qhtgecp"ecrcekfcf"kphqtoƒvkec"{" cnocegpcokgpvq"fg"dcugu"fg" fcvqu"c"itcpfgu"
qticpk¦cekqpgu"{"dcpequ0"Eqp"gn"vkgorq."nc"Ñeqorwvcek„p"gp"nc"pwdgÒ."ncu"Ñcrnkec/
ekqpgu"∀3)∋µ/#∃Ω."nc"Ñeqorwvcek„p"dclq"fgocpfcÒ"q"nc"Ñeqorwvcek„p"wdkewcÒ" ug"
eqpxktvkgtqp"gp"wp"pwgxq"oqfgnq"fg"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"pgiqekq"{"vgepq/
nqic"c"itcp"guecnc0
Gn"Kphqtog"Hkpcn"fg"nc"Ceek„p"3"fgn"Rncp"DGRU"kpfkec"swg"nc"eqorwvcek„p"gp"nc"pwdg"
Ñeqpu kuvg" gp" gn" u wokpk uvtq" fg" ugt xke kqu" kphqt oƒvke qu" g p"n pgc" pqt ocn cfqu. " eqp /
Þiwtcdngu"{" c" nc" ectvc."vcngu"eqoq" gn" rtqegucokgpvq." cnocegpcokgpvq." ∗∋)&µ/#∃+
≅∗∋)&µ/#∃;/∗;/;∗∃#8∀%∃ϑ"UccU+"{"iguvk„p"fg"fcvqu."wvknk¦cpfq"c"vcn"Þp"tgewtuqu"huk/
equ"{"xktvwcngu"eqorctvkfqu"*tgfgu."ugtxkfqtgu"{"crnkecekqpgu+0"Gn"ugtxkekq"ug"rtguvc"
∋3.∀3∃ϑ"eqp"nc"c{wfc"fgn"uqrqtvg"hukeq"*jctfyctg+"fgn"rtqxggfqt."{"nqu" wuwctkqu"
rwgfgp"ceegfgt"cn"okuoq"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"ewcnswkgt"fkurqukvkxq."kpfgrgpfkgpvgogpvg"
fg"uw"nqecnk¦cek„p."ukgortg"{"ewcpfq"fkurqpic"fg"wpc"eqpgzk„p"c"Kpvgtpgv0
Gzkuvgp"fkxgtuqu"oqfgnqu"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqorwvcek„p"gp"nc"pwdg."ukgpfq"nqu"oƒu"
gzvgpfkfqu"nqu"ukiwkgpvgu
/"Kphtcguvtwevwtc"eqoq"ugtxkekq" *KccU+ gp" guvg" ecuq." nqu" rtqxggfqtgu"rqpgp"qt/
fgpcfqtgu"{" qvtqu"tgewtuqu"kphqtoƒvkequ"c"fkurqukek„p" fg" uwu" enkgpvgu0"Gp"guvqu"
ecuqu."gn"enkgpvg"pk"iguvkqpc"pk"eqpvtqnc"nc"kphtcguvtwevwtc"uwd{cegpvg"fg"nc"pwdg."
rgtq"vkgpg" eqpvtqn" uqdtg" gn" ukuvgoc" qrgtcvkxq." gn" gurcekq" fg" cnocegpcokgpvq"{"
ncu"crnkecekqpgu" kpuvcncfcu." rwfkgpfq"kpenwuq"qdvgpgt"wp" eqpvtqn"nkokvcfq"uqdtg"
ekgtvqu"eqorqpgpvgu"fg"tgf"*rqt"glgornq."eqtvchwgiqu"cnqlcfqu"gp"ugtxkfqtgu+0
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
;2
/"Rncvchqtoc"eqoq"ugtxkekq"*Rccu+qecuk„p."ug"qhtgeg"wpc"rncvchqtoc"kp/
hqtoƒvkec"{"jgttcokgpvcu" fg" rtqitcocek„p" gp" ecnkfcf" fg" ugtxkekq"rctc"nqu"fg/
ucttqnncfqtgu"fg" rtqitcocu" kphqtoƒvkequ0" Nqu" tgewtuqu" uqhvyctg" qhtgekfqu"gp"nc"
rncvchqtoc"guvƒp"kpvgitcfqu"gp"gn"e„fkiq"fg"ncu"crnkecekqpgu"kphqtoƒvkecu"eqpeg/
dkfcu"rctc"ugt"wvknk¦cfcu"rqt"nqu"wuwctkqu"Þpcngu0"Gn"wuwctkq"q"enkgpvg"pq"eqpvtqnc"
pk"iguvkqpc"nc"kphtcguvtwevwtc" uwd{cegpvg" gp" nc" pwdg" *nc" tgf." nqu" ugtxkfqtgu."nqu"
ukuvgocu"qrgtcvkxqu"q"ncu"ecrcekfcfgu"fg"cnocegpcokgpvq+."rgtq"u"glgteg"eqpvtqn"
uqdtg"ncu"crnkecekqpgu"kpuvcncfcu0
/"Ε∋)&µ/#∃" eqoq" ugtxkekq"*UccU+ gp" guvg"ecuq."wp"rtqxggfqt"rgtokvg" cn"wuwctkq"
ceegfgt"c"wpc"crnkecek„p"c"vtcxf‌iu"fg"xctkqu"fkurqukvkxqu"ogfkcpvg"wpc"kpvgthc¦"fg"
enkgpvg."swg"rwgfg"ugt" wp"pcxgicfqt0"Ugtc"gn"uwrwguvq"fg"wp"eqttgq"gp"tgf0"Gp"
guvc"qecuk„p."gn"e„fkiq"ug"glgewvc"c"fkuvcpekc"gp"nqu"ugtxkfqtgu"{"gn"wuwctkq"pq"guvƒ"
qdnkicfq"c"cevwcnk¦ct" wp" fgvgtokpcfq" rtqitcoc" ukgortg" swg" gzkuvc"wpc"pwgxc"
xgtuk„p."rqtswg"ukgortg"ug"glgewvc"nc"xgtuk„p"oƒu"tgekgpvg0"Gn"wuwctkq"pq"iguvkqpc"
pk"eqpvtqnc"nc" kphtcguvtwevwtc" uwd{cegpvg" gp" nc"pwdg" *nc" tgf." nqu" ugtxkfqtgu." nqu"
ukuvgocu"qrgtcvkxqu."ncu"ecrcekfcfgu"fg"cnocegpcokgpvq"q"fg" crnkecek„p"kpfkxk/
fwcn+."{"nqu"rgtokuqu"fg"nqu"swg"fkurqpg"guvƒp"tgncekqpcfqu"eqp"cniwpqu"clwuvgu"
fg"eqpÞiwtcek„p"fg"fgvgtokpcfcu"crnkecekqpgu0
Eqoq"jgoqu" cpvkekrcfq." gn" kphqtog" fgn"VCI"fgn" 4223" pq"eqpvkgpg" tghgtgpekcu"
c"nqu" rciqu" rqt" ∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗+ 0∃+ %∋∆Ι−&/%∀Η3+ ∃3+ ./+3−5∃"≅%.∋−0+ %∋∆Ι−&∀3ΧΑϑ+{c"swg"
gp"cswgn"oqogpvq"guvg"vkrq"fg"eqpvtcvqu"pq"guvcdc"vcp"korncpvcfq"eqoq"gp"nc"
cevwcnkfcf0"C"fc"fg"jq{."nc"QEFG"c¿p"pq"jc"rwdnkecfq"fktgevtkegu"enctcu"uqdtg"nc"
ecnkÞecek„p"fg"guvqu"rciqu."uk"dkgp"wp"itwrq"fg"gzrgtvqu"guvƒ"vtcdclcpfq"gp"guvc"
ewguvk„p"{"gu"rtgxkukdng"swg"gp" nqu"rt„zkoqu"ogugu"ug"rwdnkswgp"nqu"tguwnvcfqu"
fg"uwu"vtcdclqu0
Gp"vqfq" ecuq."nc"ewguvk„p"gugpekcn" ugtƒ"fgvgtokpct"uk" pqu" gpeqpvtcoqu"cpvg"#∋;
4/.&∀∃∗"Ïgurgekcnogpvg"uk"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"kpenw{g"gp"gn"eqpegrvq"fg"tgicncu"nqu"
rciqu"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞequÏ."&∃%13∀%/.+)∃∃∗"
Ïrctvkewnctogpvg"uk"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"eqpvkgpg"wpc"rtqxkuk„p"gurgekcn"tgncvkxc"c"nqu"
ugtxkekqu"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepkecÏ"q"dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
Nqu"rtqdngocu" rctc"ecnkÞect"nc"tgpvc" qdvgpkfc"ug"citcxcp"ewcpfq" nqu"eqpvtcvqu"
rqt"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqorwvcek„p"gp"nc"pwdg"ug" rtgugpvcp" eqoq" eqpvtcvqu" okzvqu."
kpenw{gpfq"fkxgtuqu"ugtxkekqu"vcngu"eqoq"cnocegpcokgpvq"fg"kphqtocek„p."ceeguq"
c"kphqtocek„p."rtqegucokgpvq"fg"fcvqu"q"ugtxkekqu"fg"cukuvgpekc"vf‌iepkec0"Gp"guvg"
uwrwguvq."jcdtƒ" swg" crnkect"c"ecfc"rtguvcek„p" gn" vtcvcokgpvq"lwtfkeq/vtkdwvctkq"
swg"ng"eqttgurqpfc0"Rgtq."cwpswg"guvc"tginc"rctgeg"enctc"fgufg"wp"rwpvq"fg"xkuvc"
vg„tkeq."nq"ekgtvq"gu"swg"c"xgegu"gp"nc"rtƒevkec"tguwnvc"eqornkecfq"fkuvkpiwkt"gpvtg"
nc"rtguvcek„p"rtkpekrcn"fgn"eqpvtcvq"{"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"ceeguqtkcu0
Rwgu"dkgp."eqoq"nc" rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqorwvcek„p"gp" nc"pwdg"ukgortg"
kpenw{g"gn"fgtgejq"c"wuct" q" fguectict" ∗∋)&µ/#∃." rctc"ecnkÞect"nc"tgpvc"qdvgpkfc"
jcdtƒ"swg"vqoct"eqoq"rwpvq" fg" rctvkfc" ncu" tgincu" fg" vtkdwvcek„p" crnkecdngu" c"
ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃0"[."uk"gn"wuwctkq"rcic"rqt"gn"wuq"q"nc"cfswkukek„p"fgn"
fgtgejq"fg"wuq"fg"fgtgejqu"rtqvgikfqu"rqt"Rtqrkgfcf"Kpvgngevwcn."ncu"ecpvkfcfgu"
cdqpcfcu"ugtƒp"ecnkÞecfcu"eqoq"tgicncu0"Gp"guvg"rwpvq."jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP;3
ncu"fkuvkpekqpgu"c"ncu"swg"cnwfkoqu"cpvgtkqtogpvg"gpvtg"wpc"nkegpekc"fg"fgtgejqu"
fg"cwvqt"uqdtg"gn"rtqitcoc"kphqtoƒvkeq"{"gn"ceeguq"c"wpc"eqrkc"uqdtg"gn"rtqitcoc"
fg"∗∋)&µ/#∃"rtqvgikfq"eqp"fgtgejqu"fg"cwvqt0"Rqt"qvtq"ncfq."uk"gn"wuwctkq"ucvkuhc/
eg"wpc"ecpvkfcf"c" ecodkq"fg"cfswktkt" ¿pkecogpvg"nqu"fgtgejqu"pgeguctkqu"rctc"
qrgtct"gn"rtqitcoc."nc"tgpvc"ucvkuhgejc"fgdg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguc/
tkcngu0"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"rtgugpvg"swg"gp"gn"ƒodkvq"fg"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqorwvcek„p"
gp"nc" pwdg" fkheknogpvg" ug"rqftƒ"ecnkÞect"nc"tgpvc" qdvgpkfc"eqoq"icpcpekcu"fg"
ecrkvcn"*ctv0"35"OE"QEFG+."rwgu"nqu"eqpvtcvqu"swg"kpenw{gp"guvg"vkrq"fg"ugtxkekqu"
pq"kpenw{gp"pkpiwpc"eguk„p"vqvcn"fg"nqu"fgtgejqu"uqdtg"wp"dkgp"48 0
Rgtq"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"eqorwvcek„p"gp"nc"pwdg"vcodkf‌ip"rwgfgp"kpenwkt"nc"rqukdknk/
fcf"fg"cnocegpct"fcvqu"gp"nqu"ugtxkfqtgu0"Gp"guvg"uwrwguvq."jcdtc"swg"fgvgtok/
pct"uk"gn"rciq"ucvkuhgejq"rqt"gn"wuwctkq"fgdg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"dgpgÞekqu"gortguc/
tkcngu"q"eqoq"rciqu"rqt"gn"wuq"fg"gswkrqu"kpfwuvtkcngu."eqogtekcngu"q"ekgpvÞequ."
gurgekcnogpvg"gp"cswgnnqu"uwrwguvqu"gp"nqu"swg" gn" EFK" crnkecdng"kpenw{g"guvqu"
rciqu"gp"gn"eqpegrvq"fg"tgicncu0"Rwgu"dkgp."gp"nc"ogfkfc"gp"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"fgn"
ugtxkekq"ocpvkgpg"gn"eqpvtqn"vqvcn"uqdtg"gn"egpvtq"fg"fcvqu"{"ukiwg"ukgpfq"gn"tgu/
rqpucdng"fgn"ocpvgpkokgpvq"fgn"gswkrq."gn"rciq"tgekdkfq"fgdg"ecnkÞectug"eqoq"
dgpgÞekqu"gortguctkcngu0
Fg"qvtc" rctvg."eqoq"tginc" igpgtcn."nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"eqoq" eqpvtcrtguvcek„p"
rqt"nc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu" fg" uqrqtvg" fgdgp" ecnkÞectug" eqoq"tgpfkokgpvqu"
gortguctkcngu."{c" swg"guvcu"vtcpuceekqpgu"pq" kornkecp"pkpiwpc"eguk„p"fg" fgtg/
ejqu"fg"cwvqt."vtkdwvcpfq"gzenwukxcogpvg"gp"gn"Guvcfq"fg"tgukfgpekc0"Ukp"godct/
iq."uk"nqu"ugtxkekqu"rtguvcfqu"uqp"fg"pcvwtcng¦c"vf‌iepkec"{"gn"EFK"crnkecdng"eqpvkgpg"
wpc"rtqxkuk„p"gurgeÞec"gp"gn"rtgegrvq"tgncvkxq"c"ncu"tgicncu"*ctv0"34+"q"wpc"rtq/
xkuk„p"fg"GR"fg"ugtxkekqu."gn"Guvcfq"fg"nc"hwgpvg"rqftƒ"qrgtct"wpc"tgvgpek„p"gp"nc"
hwgpvg"tgurgevq"fg"guvcu"tgpvcu0
Gp"nq"swg"tgurgevc"c"nc"kortguk„p"gp"5Fϑ"nqu"cxcpegu"gp"guvg"ecorq"jcp"uwrwgu/
vq"korqtvcpvgu"ecodkqu"gp"nc"rtqfweek„p."vtcpurqtvg."oqpvclg"{"fkuvtkdwek„p"fg"
rtqfwevqu0"Cfgoƒu."nc"kortguk„p"gp"5F"cegtec"gn"rtqeguq"fg"hcdtkecek„p"cn"enkgpvg."
rgtokvkgpfq"swg" nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"kpvgtxgpicp" fg"cniwpc"ocpgtc" gp"gn"fkug‚q"
fgn"rtqfwevq"Þpcn0"Nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fg"nc"kortguk„p"gp"5F."ow{"gzvgpfkfc"gp"gn"uge/
vqt" ucpkvctkq." rwgfg" ugt" wpc" gzegngpvg" cnvgtpcvkxc"c" nqu" rtqeguqu" vtcfkekqpcngu."
tgfwekgpfq"nc"jwgnnc"codkgpvcn0
Gp"npgcu"igpgtcngu."nqu"rciqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"eqpvtcvqu"fg"kortguk„p"
gp"5F" ugtƒp"tgeqpfwekfqu"cn"rtgegrvq"fguvkpcfq" c"nqu"dgpgÞekqu" gortguctkcngu"
*ctv0"9"fgn" OE" QEFG+0" Ukp"godctiq."uwtigp" cniwpcu" fwfcu"gp"nqu"uwrwguvqu" gp"
nqu"swg"nqu"hcdtkecpvgu"qvqticp"wpc"nkegpekc"c"wp"vgtegtq"swg"kpenw{c"nqu"rncpqu"{"
gurgekÞecekqpgu"rctc"kortkokt"gp"5F"nqu"rtqfwevqu0"Gp"guvg"ecuq."uk"nc"hcdtkecek„p"
fktgevc"rcuc"c"eqpxgtvktug" gp"wpc"nkegpekc"fg"fkug‚qu" rctc"kortguk„p"tgoqvc"gp"
5F"rqt"rctvg"fg"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu."jcdtc"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"nc"gxgpvwcn"ecnkÞ/
ecek„p"fgn"rciq"ucvkuhgejq"eqoq"tgicncu0
48" DCN."C0."ÑVjg"um{Ôu"vjg"nkokv"/"enqwf/dcugf"ugtxkegu"kp"cp"Kpvgtpcvkqpcn"rgturgevkxgÒ."γ−..∃&∀3+
)∋#+>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+,/Υ/&∀∋3ϑ"Ugrvgodgt"42360
+;
Nc"ecnkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"tgpvcu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkikvcngu""
*Uqtc{c"Tqftiwg¦"Nqucfc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
;4
Gp"fgÞpkvkxc."jcdtƒ"swg"gurgtct"c"nqu"tguwnvcfqu"fgn"vtcdclq"fg"nc" QEFG"gp" guvg"
ecorq" {." rquvgtkqtogpvg."ugtc" rtgekuq" kpenwkt" ncu" qrqt vwpcu" fktgevtkegu"gp" nqu"
Eqogpvctkqu"c"nqu"ctvewnqu"9"{"34"fgn"OE"QEFG0
XKK0"DKDNKQITCHìC
DCN."C0."ÑVjg"um{Ôu"vjg"nkokv"/"enqwf/dcugf"ugtxkegu"kp"cp"Kpvgtpcvkqpcn"rgturgevkxgÒ."γ−..∃&∀3+
)∋#+>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+,/Υ/&∀∋3ϑ"Ugrvgodgt"42360
ECNXQ"X¡TIG¥."L0."ÑWpc"crtqzkocek„p"c"ncu"rtkpekrcngu"ewguvkqpgu"fgtkxcfcu"fg"nc"Þuecnkfcf"
fgn"eqogtekq"gngevt„pkeqÒ."!∋%−∆∃3&∋∗+;+>3∗&∀&−&∋+0∃+?∗&−0∀∋∗+2∀∗%/.∃∗ϑ+p¿o0"5."422;0
ECTOQPC"HGTPéPFG¥."P0."ÑNc"Þuecnkfcf"fg"nqu"eƒpqpgu"gp"gn" Korwguvq"uqdtg"nc"Tgpvc"
fg"Pq" tgukfgpvguÒ6"Gp>3)∋#∆/%∀Η3+:∋∆∃#%∀/.+?∗Ι/φ∋./β+ >:?β+ Ο∃8∀∗&/+0∃+ ?%∋3∋∆Τ/6+
?Π∃∆Ι./#+0∃0∀%/0∋+/+Κ−∃8/∗+,∃30∃3%∀/∗+∃3+?%∋3∋∆Τ/+4+ 2∀∗%/.∀0/0+>3&∃#3/%∀∋3/.ϑ+p³"
:47."42270
EQOKV¡"FG"NCU"PCEKQPGU"WPKFCU."ÑTgxkugf"Eqoogpvct{"qp"Ctvkeng"34C"/"hggu"hqt"vgej/
pkecn"ugtxkeguÒ."2∋−#&∃∃3&1+ ∗∃∗∗∀∋3ϑ+9Χ∃30/+∀&∃∆+Ν≅/Αβ+>∗∗−∃∗+#∃./&∃0+&∋+&1∃+ −Ι0/&∀3Χ+
∋)+&1∃+ 73∀&∃0+ Κ/&∀∋3∗+=∋0∃.+!∋−5.∃+,/Υ/&∀∋3+:∋38∃3&∀∋3+5∃&µ∃∃3+ !∃8∃.∋Ι∃0+ /30+
!∃8∃.∋Ι∀3Χ+:∋−3∀∃∗6"*Eqookvvgg"qh"Gzrgtvu"G1E"3:142391ETR03"Octej"4239+
EQOKV¡"FG"NCU"PCEKQPGU"WPKFCU."ÑVjg"vczcvkqp"qh"hggu"hqt" vgejpkecn."ocpcigtkcn"cpf"
eqpuwnvcpe{"ugtxkegu"kp"vjg"fkikvcn"geqpqo{"ykvj"tgurgev"vq"Ctv0"34C"qh"vjg"4239"WP"
OqfgnÒ."2∀)&∃∃3&1+∗∃∗∗∀∋3ϑ+9Χ∃30/+ ∀&∃∆+ε≅%Α≅∀ΥΑβ+ ,/Υ+%∋3∗∃Ρ−∃3%∃∗+∋)+ &1∃+0∀Χ∀&/.∀Σ∃0+
∃%∋3∋∆46"*Eqookvvgg"qh"Gzrgtvu"G1E03:142391ETR045"/"32"Qevqdgt"4239+
NCKPQHH."U0T0."XCKUJ."T0E0."ÑIgpgtcn"TgrqtvÒ0"Gp:/1∀∃#∗+0∃+!#∋∀&+2∀∗%/.+>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.ϑ+
8∋.6+⊥Ψ/.",1∃+&/Υ/&∀∋3+∋)+∀3%∋∆∃+0∃#∀8∃0+)#∋∆+&1∃+∗−ΙΙ.4+∋)+&∃%13∋.∋Χ4ϑ"Couvgtfco
KHC."3;;90
NKFGPETQPC."I0."VQNUVQ[."U0."ÑIgpgtcn"TgrqtvÒ0"Gp:/1∀∃#∗+0∃+!#∋∀&+2∀∗%/.+>3&∃#3/&∀∋;
3/.ϑ+8∋.6+ε/.",/Υ /&∀ 3+∋ )+% # ∗∗ +5∋ # 0∃# + .∃/ ∀3 Χ ϑ+Couvgtfco
OCTVìP"LKO¡PG¥."C0."ÑCtvewnq"340"Nc" vtkdwvcek„p"fg"nqu" eƒpqpgu"q"tgicncuÒ0"Gp
TðP"ECTTGTQ."L0O0"{"TWì¥"ICTEìC."L0T0.":∋∆∃3&/#∀∋∗+/+.∋∗+%∋38∃3∀∋∗+Ι/#/+∃8∀&/#+./+
0∋5.∃+∀∆Ι∋∗∀%∀Η3+4+Ι#∃8∃3∀#+./+∃8/∗∀Η3+Þ∗%/.+%∋3%.−∀0∋∗+Ι∋#+?∗Ι/φ/6+93Γ.∀∗∀∗+/+./+.−Σ+
0∃.+=∋0∃.∋+0∃+:∋38∃3∀∋+0∃+./+Λ:!?+4+0∃+./+.∃Χ∀∗./%∀Η3+4+Π−#∀∗Ι#−0∃3%∀/+∃∗Ι/φ∋./6+C"
Eqtw‚c Rgftq"Dcttkf‌i"fg"nc" Oc¦cKpuvkvwvq"fg" Guvwfkqu"Geqp„okequ" fg"
Icnkekc."42260
QGEF.",1∃+&/Υ/&∀∋3+∋)+∀3%∋∆∃+0∃#∀8∃0+)#∋∆+&1∃+.∃/∗∀3Χ+∋)+∀30−∗∀/.ϑ+%∋∆∆∃#%∀/.+∋#+∗%∀∃3&∀Þ%+
∃Ρ−∀Ι∆∃3&ϑ+Rctku
UKPINGVQP."R0."ÑPqp/tgukfgpv"gngevtqpke"eqoogteg"vczcvkqppvgtpcvkqpcn"eqorctkuqpÒ."
9∗∀/;(/%∀Þ%+,/Υ+γ−..∃&∀3ϑ+Xqn0" 32 ." Pq0"5."Oc tej0
YGUVKP."T0C0." >3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+&/Υ/&∀∋3+ ∋)+∃.∃%∋3∀%+ %∋∆∆∃#%∃ϑ+Ugeqpf"gfkvkqp." Vjg"Pgvjgt/
ncpfu

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba

VLEX utiliza cookies de inicio de sesión para aportarte una mejor experiencia de navegación. Si haces click en 'Aceptar' o continúas navegando por esta web consideramos que aceptas nuestra política de cookies. ACEPTAR